In recent years, the development of electric vehicles has been widely recognised as an essential pathway to address the increasing pressure of energy shortage and environmental pollution. Compared with conventional internal combustion engine vehicles, electric vehicles exhibit a distinctive set of advantages, including higher energy-conversion efficiency, lower operating noise, and zero tailpipe emissions. As a result, the market share of electric vehicles has expanded rapidly. The stock of electric vehicles in China has increased substantially from roughly 730,000 units in 2016 to well over 25 million units in 2025, as illustrated below.

Nevertheless, the growing popularity of electric vehicles has introduced new challenges in the field of noise, vibration, and harshness engineering. Unlike traditional powertrains, the electric drive system of an electric vehicle lacks the masking effect of internal combustion engine noise. High rotational speeds and rapid torque response therefore make the transient impact phenomena more perceptible to drivers. Among the various driving conditions that can provoke such impact phenomena, the Tip in/out condition is especially critical. During Tip in and Tip out events, the motor torque frequently changes sign within a very short interval, and the powertrain repeatedly switches between the driving mode and the regenerative braking mode. Because several clearances inevitably exist in the transmission path, such as gear backlash, differential side gear backlash, and spline clearances, the torque zero-crossing process causes the gears to rattle, knock, and separate repeatedly. This type of transient impact leads to rotational speed oscillations, uncomfortable shuffle, and undesirable noise inside the cabin. Thus, investigating the transient impact mechanism and developing an effective multi-clearance design method has become an important research topic for improving the driving comfort of electric vehicles.
Existing studies on the dynamics of gear transmission systems have provided valuable insight into the influence of time-varying mesh stiffness, backlash nonlinearity, and transmission error. Numerous dynamic models have been proposed to describe the steady-state or quasi-steady-state vibration behaviour of gear pairs. Research on the Clunk phenomenon of electric vehicle powertrains has also revealed that clearance-induced impact plays a dominant role during rapid torque reversals. In addition, the theory of multibody contact-impact has offered a series of modelling frameworks, including the impulse-momentum approach and the continuous contact-force approach. Nonlinear dynamic analysis tools such as bifurcation diagrams and Lyapunov exponents have also been introduced into gear dynamics. However, from a design perspective, most published studies concentrated on a single clearance parameter or treated the contact force with linearised spring-damper elements. When the motor torque passes through zero under Tip in/out conditions, the gear pair experiences frequent, short-duration impacts. In this situation, the use of a conventional continuous contact model may not be sufficiently accurate to reproduce the real transient response. In addition, the clearance parameters in engineering practice are often determined on the basis of geometric considerations, while the dynamic response and stability of the whole powertrain system are not fully considered. Therefore, there is a need to construct a more physically consistent transient dynamics model, verify it with vehicle test data, and propose a multi-clearance coordinated optimisation procedure that can suppress the transient impact while maintaining a stable nonlinear dynamic response.
In this thesis, I focus on the powertrain system of a front-wheel-drive battery electric vehicle. The main goals of this study are summarised as follows. First, I establish a complete transient dynamic model of the electric vehicle powertrain that incorporates the input shaft spline, a two-stage fixed-axis helical gear reducer, a differential, and the left and right half-shaft splines. In this model, the time-varying mesh stiffness, mesh damping, nonlinear oil-film force, and backlash are all included. Second, I propose two different methods for describing the transient gear impact. In the first model, named the spring-damper-based form, both normal meshing and gear knocking are described by a continuous contact force. In the second model, named the momentum-theorem-based form, the normal meshing stage is still modelled by a continuous contact force, but the short-time gear knocking is modelled by an impact force derived from the impulse-momentum theorem. Third, I carry out full-vehicle road tests under Tip in/out conditions and compare the simulation results with measured CAN-bus data. On the basis of this comparison, I assess the validity and prediction performance of the two transient dynamics models. Finally, I investigate the influence of multiple clearances on the transient impact, judge the stability range of the nonlinear transient response by using global bifurcation diagrams and the maximum Lyapunov exponent, and then perform a multi-objective optimisation of the clearance parameters.
This chapter provides the system description and mathematical modelling procedure in detail. The target electric vehicle contains a drive motor, an input shaft spline, a two-stage helical gear reducer, a differential, and two half-shaft splines. The motor torque is transmitted to the differential through the two-stage reducer, and the differential then distributes the torque to the left and right wheels. The key parameters of the two-stage helical gear reducer are summarised in the following table.
| Parameter | First-stage gear pair | Second-stage gear pair | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Driving/Driven gear | Pinion | Wheel | Pinion | Wheel |
| Number of teeth | 22 | 59 | 31 | 97 |
| Transverse module (mm) | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 |
| Helix direction | Right | Left | Left | Right |
| Helix angle (deg) | 32 | 32 | 20 | 20 |
| Normal pressure angle (deg) | 18.5 | 18.5 | 20 | 20 |
In the dynamic model, each gear is considered as a lumped inertia with a single torsional degree of freedom. This simplification is reasonable because the torsional response is the dominant factor in the transient speed fluctuation of the reducer gears under Tip in/out conditions. For the first stage of the reducer, the equations of motion can be written as:
$$
\begin{aligned}
J_1 \ddot{\theta}_1 &= T_1 – r_1 F_1 \cos\beta_1, \\
J_2 \ddot{\theta}_2 &= r_1 F_1 \cos\beta_1 – T_2,
\end{aligned}
$$
where \(T_1\) is the input torque applied to the driving gear of the first-stage gear pair, \(r_1\) is the pitch radius of the driving gear, \(\beta_1\) is the helix angle of the first-stage gear pair, \(F_1\) is the dynamic mesh force of the first-stage gear pair, \(J_1\) and \(J_2\) are the moments of inertia of the first pinion and wheel, and \(\theta_1\) and \(\theta_2\) are the corresponding angular displacements. For the second-stage gear pair, similar equations are obtained:
$$
\begin{aligned}
J_3 \ddot{\theta}_3 &= T_3 – r_3 F_2 \cos\beta_2, \\
J_4 \ddot{\theta}_4 &= r_3 F_2 \cos\beta_2 – T_4,
\end{aligned}
$$
where \(T_3\) represents the input torque to the second-stage pinion, \(T_4\) is the output torque from the second-stage wheel, \(r_3\) is the pitch radius of the second-stage pinion, \(\beta_2\) is the helix angle of the second-stage gear pair, \(F_2\) is the dynamic mesh force of the second-stage gear pair, and \(J_3\), \(J_4\), \(\theta_3\), and \(\theta_4\) are the corresponding inertias and angular displacements.
The differential model includes the differential casing, four planetary gears, and the left and right side gears. I considered the torsional degrees of freedom of the casing and each gear. The dynamic equations of the side gears take the form:
$$
\begin{aligned}
J_s \ddot{\theta}_s &= \sum_{i=1}^{4} r_s F_{pis}\cos\alpha – T_L, \\
J_r \ddot{\theta}_r &= \sum_{i=1}^{4} r_r F_{pir}\cos\alpha – T_R,
\end{aligned}
$$
where \(r_s\) and \(r_r\) are the pitch radii of the left and right side gears, \(F_{pis}\) and \(F_{pir}\) are the dynamic mesh forces between the planetary gears and the left and right side gears, \(T_L\) and \(T_R\) are the output torques of the half-shafts, and \(J_s\), \(J_r\), \(\theta_s\), and \(\theta_r\) are the moments of inertia and angular displacements of the left and right side gears. The dynamics of the planetary gears are described by:
$$
J_{pi}\ddot{\theta}_{pi} = r_{pi}\left(F_{pis} + F_{pir}\right)\cos\alpha,
$$
while the differential casing is governed by:
$$
J_c\ddot{\theta}_c = T_c – \sum_{i=1}^{4} r_s F_{pis}\cos\alpha – \sum_{i=1}^{4} r_r F_{pir}\cos\alpha.
$$
The dynamic mesh forces of the bevelled gears in the differential are expressed in a linearised spring-damper form along the line of action:
$$
F_{pis} = k_{pis}p_{pis} + c_{pis}\dot{p}_{pis}, \qquad F_{pir} = k_{pir}p_{pir} + c_{pir}\dot{p}_{pir},
$$
where \(k_{pis}\) and \(c_{pis}\) represent the mesh stiffness and damping between the left side gear and the planetary gear, and \(k_{pir}\) and \(c_{pir}\) are the corresponding values for the right side gear and the planetary gear.
The spline connections in the transmission system are also modelled by the torsional spring-damper form with a dead zone. The torque transmitted through a spline is expressed as:
$$
T_s = h\,k\left(\theta_1-\theta_2-\frac{n\Delta_s}{2}\right) + c\left(\dot{\theta}_1-\dot{\theta}_2\right),
$$
where \(\theta_1\) and \(\theta_2\) are the angular displacements of the internal and external splines, \(k\) is the spline equivalent stiffness, \(c\) is the spline damping coefficient, \(\Delta_s\) is the spline clearance, and \(h\) and \(n\) are switching functions that determine whether the spline is in contact on the driving flank, on the coast flank, or in the clearance region.
In order to accurately capture the transient impact of the electric vehicle powertrain under Tip in/out conditions, the gear backlash is introduced as a piecewise function. The gear clearance function is:
$$
f(x_n) =
\begin{cases}
x_n – b_c, & x_n > b_c, \\
0, & -b_c \le x_n \le b_c, \\
x_n + b_c, & x_n < -b_c,
\end{cases}
$$
where \(x_n\) is the relative displacement of the gear pair along the line of action, and \(b_c\) is half of the backlash. This formulation enables the model to describe three different states: tooth face contact, separation, and impact on the reverse flank.
The time-varying mesh stiffness of the helical gear pairs is calculated using the potential-energy method and the slicing method. The total mesh stiffness is obtained as:
$$
k = \frac{1}{\frac{1}{k_h} + \frac{1}{k_{b1}} + \frac{1}{k_{s1}} + \frac{1}{k_{a1}} + \frac{1}{k_{f1}} + \frac{1}{k_{b2}} + \frac{1}{k_{s2}} + \frac{1}{k_{a2}} + \frac{1}{k_{f2}}}
$$
where the subscripts 1 and 2 denote the pinion and wheel, respectively. The individual stiffness components \(k_h\), \(k_b\), \(k_s\), \(k_a\), and \(k_f\) represent the Hertzian contact stiffness, bending stiffness, shear stiffness, axial compressive stiffness, and fillet-foundation stiffness. The gear tooth is discretised into multiple thin slices, and the bending, shear, and axial stiffnesses are obtained by integrating along the tooth depth. The expressions used in this thesis can be written as:
$$
\frac{1}{k_b} = \int_{0}^{d} \frac{\left(x\cos\alpha_1 – h\sin\alpha_1\right)^2}{EI_x} dx,
$$
$$
\frac{1}{k_s} = \int_{0}^{d} \frac{1.2\cos^2\alpha_1}{GA_x} dx,
$$
$$
\frac{1}{k_a} = \int_{0}^{d} \frac{\sin^2\alpha_1}{EA_x} dx,
$$
where \(d\) is the effective tooth length, \(\alpha_1\) is the angle between the mesh force and the tooth centre line, \(h\) is the half tooth thickness at the contact point, \(h_x\) is the half tooth thickness at a distance \(x\) from the contact point, \(G\) and \(E\) are the shear and elastic moduli, and \(A_x\) and \(I_x\) are the area and area moment of inertia of the tooth slice. The time-varying mesh stiffness of the first-stage and second-stage gear pairs is periodic with the rotation of the gears, and this periodicity is an important internal excitation source of the nonlinear dynamic response.
The mesh damping of the gear pairs is approximated by the empirical formula:
$$
c_m = 2\zeta \sqrt{\frac{k_m r_5^2 r_6^2 J_5 J_6}{r_6^2 J_6 + r_5^2 J_5}},
$$
where \(k_m\) is the average mesh stiffness, \(r_5\) and \(r_6\) are the base-circle radii of the two gears, \(J_5\) and \(J_6\) are their moments of inertia, and \(\zeta\) is the mesh damping ratio. In this study, \(\zeta\) is set to 0.1, which is a reasonable value for lubricated gear contacts in vehicle drivetrains.
When the gear pair is separated and the teeth do not directly contact, the lubricant oil film between the teeth still generates a nonlinear force. This oil-film force is especially important during the clearance stage because it influences the speed of the gear pair before the next impact occurs. I model the nonlinear oil-film force as:
$$
F_{oil} =
\begin{cases}
C_{Wedge}\dot{\delta}_i, & \delta_i > h_{min}, \\
0, & \delta_i \le h_{min},
\end{cases}
$$
where \(C_{Wedge}\) is the wedge-flow equivalent damping coefficient, \(\delta_i\) is the distance between the tooth flanks, and \(h_{min}\) is a saturation value introduced to avoid the singular behaviour when the oil-film thickness approaches zero. The squeeze and wedge damping terms are calculated from the elastohydrodynamic lubrication theory:
$$
C_{Wedge} = \frac{\eta_0 L r_{eq}}{\delta_i},
\qquad
C_{Squeeze} = \frac{3\pi\eta_0 L r_{eq}^2}{2\delta_i^3}.
$$
Here, \(\eta_0\) is the dynamic viscosity of the lubricant, \(L\) is the contact line length, and \(r_{eq}\) is the equivalent curvature radius of the meshing gear pair.
A key contribution of this thesis is that the gear impact under Tip in/out conditions is treated by two fundamentally different modelling philosophies. The first philosophy is based on the conventional continuous contact assumption. In this approach, the gear mesh force is always expressed by a spring-damper element, regardless of whether the gear pair is in normal contact or experiencing transient knocking:
$$
F_{mesh} = k_m x_n + c_m \dot{x}_n.
$$
In the second philosophy, the impact process is regarded as a very short-duration impulsive event that cannot be accurately represented by a continuous elastic contact law. When the teeth collide after traversing the backlash region, the relative velocity along the line of action changes abruptly. According to the impulse-momentum theorem, the impact force can be expressed as:
$$
F_{impact} = \frac{m_{eq} v_{rel}}{\Delta t} + c_m v_{rel},
$$
where \(v_{rel}\) is the relative velocity projected on the line of action:
$$
v_{rel} = r_5 \omega_5 \cos\beta – r_6 \omega_6 \cos\beta,
$$
and \(m_{eq}\) is the equivalent mass of the two gears reduced to the line of action:
$$
m_{eq} = \frac{J_5 J_6}{J_5 r_6^2 + J_6 r_5^2}.
$$
In the equations above, \(r_5\) and \(r_6\) are the base radii of the driving and driven gears, \(\omega_5\) and \(\omega_6\) are their angular velocities, \(\Delta t\) is the impact duration, and \(\beta\) is the helix angle. By introducing the impact force directly into the equation of motion at the moment of contact, the momentum-theorem-based model can better reproduce the abrupt speed jump caused by the repeated gear knocking. For clarity, I denote the first approach as the spring-damper-based transient dynamic model, and the second as the momentum-theorem-based transient dynamic model.
The complete transient dynamic model of the electric vehicle powertrain is assembled by coupling the reducer, the differential, and the spline models through their interaction torques and angular displacement relationships. The system of ordinary differential equations is solved by an adaptive Runge–Kutta integrator. This solver is suitable for the transient impact problem because the response contains very steep changes during the knocking events. The automatic step-size adjustment helps preserve numerical accuracy during impacts while retaining acceptable computational efficiency.
One important aspect of the modelling process is the ability to simulate transient speed fluctuations. To check the initial validity of the model, I apply a motor torque signal to the system that contains repeated Tip in and Tip out events. The simulation results show that the rotational speed of both the first-stage and second-stage driving gears changes sharply when the torque crosses zero. These speed oscillations demonstrate the existence of transient impacts in the electric vehicle powertrain and provide a basis for the subsequent vehicle test validation.
In order to validate the transient dynamic models, I designed and conducted a full-vehicle road test using an electric vehicle that exhibited a noticeable transient impact problem. The test setup consisted of the test vehicle, a CAN bus, a CAN FD bridge, a multi-channel dynamic data acquisition system, and a laptop computer for data recording. The motor output torque and the rotational speed of the first-stage driving gear of the reducer were acquired through the CAN bus. The measurement principle is shown in the following flow: the vehicle CAN bus sends signals to the CAN FD bridge, which converts them into digital signals for the multi-channel data acquisition front end; the signals are then transmitted to the host computer. In this way, the motor torque and speed signals are synchronised and stored with high precision.
During the vehicle test, the driver repeatedly pressed and released the accelerator pedal to reproduce typical Tip in/out conditions. When the driver pressed the accelerator pedal, the motor torque rapidly increased from \(-40\,\mathrm{Nm}\) to \(260\,\mathrm{Nm}\), representing a Tip in event. When the driver released the accelerator pedal, the motor torque rapidly decreased from \(260\,\mathrm{Nm}\) to \(-40\,\mathrm{Nm}\), representing a Tip out event. The measured torque signal is shown in the figure at the beginning of this chapter. The measured motor speed shows visible oscillations around the torque zero crossing. For example, after the driver suddenly re-applied the accelerator, the speed of the first-stage driving gear exhibited a peak-to-peak fluctuation of approximately \(70.94\,\mathrm{r/min}\). Such a high magnitude of speed fluctuation confirms that the clearance-induced impacts under Tip in/out conditions are severe and should not be neglected.
To validate the dynamic models, I first input the measured motor torque into the momentum-theorem-based model and simulate the response of the powertrain. The simulated rotational speed of the first-stage driving gear is then compared with the speed acquired from the CAN bus. The overall trend of the simulated speed agrees well with the experimental speed. At the torque zero-crossing moment, both the simulation and the experiment exhibit a rapid speed fluctuation followed by gradual attenuation. A similar comparison is made with the spring-damper-based model. Both models are found to be capable of reproducing the transient impact phenomenon, but their prediction accuracy is not the same. This difference is analysed in further detail in the next chapter.
In order to quantitatively compare the transient-impact prediction capability of the two dynamic models, I introduce two metrics. The first metric is the average relative error, which reflects the overall magnitude deviation between the simulation and the experiment. The second metric is the Pearson correlation coefficient, which measures the similarity between the simulated trend and the experimental trend. The average relative error is defined as:
$$
MAE_{rel} = \frac{1}{N}\sum_{i=1}^{N}\left|\frac{y_i^{exp}-y_i^{sim}}{y_i^{exp}}\right| \times 100\%,
$$
where \(y_i^{exp}\) is the experimental peak-to-peak speed fluctuation of the first-stage driving gear, \(y_i^{sim}\) is the corresponding simulated value, and \(N\) is the total number of operating conditions considered. The Pearson correlation coefficient is:
$$
r = \frac{\sum_{i=1}^{N}\left(y_i^{sim}-\bar{y}^{sim}\right)\left(y_i^{exp}-\bar{y}^{exp}\right)}
{\sqrt{\sum_{i=1}^{N}\left(y_i^{sim}-\bar{y}^{sim}\right)^2}\sqrt{\sum_{i=1}^{N}\left(y_i^{exp}-\bar{y}^{exp}\right)^2}}.
$$
I use the peak-to-peak value of the first-stage driving gear speed as the evaluation indicator because it is representative of the transient impact severity and is directly measurable in the vehicle test. The comparison is performed under two different assembly clearance conditions: a large-clearance condition and a small-clearance condition. The clearance parameters of the powertrain are listed in the following table.
| Clearance parameter | Small clearance (mm) | Large clearance (mm) |
|---|---|---|
| Input shaft spline clearance | 0.349 | 0.698 |
| First-stage gear backlash | 0.05 | 0.15 |
| Second-stage gear backlash | 0.05 | 0.15 |
| Differential side gear backlash | 0.05 | 0.15 |
| Left half-shaft spline clearance | 0.4255 | 0.712 |
| Right half-shaft spline clearance | 0.4255 | 0.712 |
Under the large clearance condition, the simulation is carried out using both dynamic models. The corresponding peak-to-peak speed fluctuations of the first-stage driving gear are reported below for the Tip in cases and Tip out cases.
| Tip in case | Test result (r/min) | Momentum-theorem model (r/min) | Spring-damper model (r/min) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Case 1 | 57.82 | 46.25 | 60.98 |
| Case 2 | 70.94 | 65.47 | 62.75 |
| Case 3 | 67.97 | 70.88 | 55.63 |
| Case 4 | 87.33 | 75.61 | 69.54 |
| Case 5 | 83.56 | 70.69 | 80.48 |
| Case 6 | 80.52 | 70.65 | 78.62 |
| Case 7 | 90.31 | 83.66 | 81.91 |
| Tip out case | Test result (r/min) | Momentum-theorem model (r/min) | Spring-damper model (r/min) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Case 1 | 42.43 | 54.89 | 48.21 |
| Case 2 | 51.98 | 56.87 | 63.14 |
| Case 3 | 54.86 | 62.54 | 58.15 |
| Case 4 | 68.60 | 64.07 | 68.79 |
| Case 5 | 57.87 | 56.79 | 50.47 |
| Case 6 | 69.69 | 66.96 | 63.27 |
From the statistical evaluation of the large-clearance cases, I find that, under the Tip in condition, the average relative error of the momentum-theorem-based model is about \(11.5\%\), which is close to that of the spring-damper model. However, the Pearson correlation coefficient between the momentum-theorem-based model and the test data is \(0.89\), noticeably higher than the value of \(0.81\) obtained by the spring-damper model. Under the Tip out condition, the correlation coefficient of the momentum-theorem model is \(0.86\), while the spring-damper model provides a value of only \(0.72\). This indicates that, under the large-clearance condition, both models can predict the oscillation amplitude reasonably well, but the momentum-theorem-based model is better at reproducing the variation trend from one operating point to the next.
Under the small-clearance condition, the difference between the two models is magnified. The simulated peak-to-peak speed fluctuations of the first-stage reducer gear for the Tip in cases are listed as follows.
| Tip in case | Test result (r/min) | Momentum-theorem model (r/min) | Spring-damper model (r/min) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Case 1 | 72.76 | 68.67 | 47.26 |
| Case 2 | 56.49 | 60.96 | 26.94 |
| Case 3 | 86.79 | 76.93 | 46.79 |
| Case 4 | 45.98 | 50.63 | 36.93 |
| Case 5 | 56.36 | 55.62 | 26.39 |
| Case 6 | 70.82 | 65.28 | 40.28 |
| Case 7 | 49.85 | 53.54 | 50.89 |
| Tip out case | Test result (r/min) | Momentum-theorem model (r/min) | Spring-damper model (r/min) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Case 1 | 42.34 | 56.48 | 38.43 |
| Case 2 | 65.94 | 77.65 | 45.37 |
| Case 3 | 68.97 | 80.62 | 48.72 |
| Case 4 | 54.34 | 60.28 | 28.19 |
| Case 5 | 65.69 | 80.27 | 35.26 |
| Case 6 | 80.18 | 65.22 | 50.84 |
For the Tip in condition under the small clearance, the momentum-theorem-based model produces an average relative error of \(7.36\%\) and a correlation coefficient of \(0.98\). By contrast, the spring-damper model yields an average relative error of \(35.93\%\) and a correlation coefficient of only \(0.37\). For the Tip out condition, the momentum-theorem-based model again provides better amplitude prediction and trend reproduction than the spring-damper model. The table below compares the two indicators for both clearance conditions.
| Clearance condition | Condition | Model | MAErel (%) | Correlation coefficient r |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Large clearance | Tip in | Momentum-theorem | 11.5 | 0.89 |
| Large clearance | Tip in | Spring-damper | 10.1 | 0.81 |
| Large clearance | Tip out | Momentum-theorem | 11.1 | 0.86 |
| Large clearance | Tip out | Spring-damper | 10.6 | 0.72 |
| Small clearance | Tip in | Momentum-theorem | 7.36 | 0.98 |
| Small clearance | Tip in | Spring-damper | 35.93 | 0.37 |
| Small clearance | Tip out | Momentum-theorem | 19.97 | 0.66 |
| Small clearance | Tip out | Spring-damper | 33.47 | 0.56 |
This comparative analysis leads to a clear conclusion. The physical nature of the gear impact under Tip in/out conditions is closer to a sequence of impulsive collisions than to a continuous elastic deformation process. When the clearance is small and the motor torque changes sign rapidly, the gear teeth repeatedly traverse the backlash gap and collide with each other in a very short time. The continuous contact model tends to smooth out the impact peak, while the momentum-theorem model explicitly introduces the velocity jump in the governing equation. For this reason, I select the momentum-theorem-based transient dynamic model as the basis for the subsequent parameter studies and multi-clearance optimisation.
After confirming the advantage of the momentum-theorem-based model, I investigate the influence of the multi-clearance parameters on the transient impact. The input torque is selected as a single Tip in/out cycle, because a shorter simulation period is sufficient to evaluate the relative influence of each clearance while maintaining a reasonable computation cost. The response of the system is evaluated by extracting the peak-to-peak speed fluctuation of the first-stage and second-stage driving gears of the reducer. Several single-factor analyses are first carried out by changing the input shaft spline clearance, the backlash of the first-stage reducer gear pair, the backlash of the second-stage reducer gear pair, the differential side gear backlash, and the half-shaft spline clearances individually. The results show that the transient impact response is not a simple linear function of any single clearance. For instance, the peak-to-peak speed of the first-stage driving gear may be higher under the large gear-backlash condition in one operating condition, while the peak-to-peak speed of the second-stage driving gear is lower under the same condition. Similarly, increasing the differential side gear backlash can sometimes decrease the speed fluctuation, whereas increasing the reducer gear backlash can increase the first-stage response and reduce the second-stage response. Therefore, the transient impact is governed by the coupled effect of multiple clearances rather than by any single dominant parameter.
Based on the preceding analysis, the influence of the clearance parameters on the transient impact of the electric vehicle powertrain can be summarised in the following table.
| Parameter changed | Assembly condition | Tip in, first-stage peak-peak (r/min) | Tip out, first-stage peak-peak (r/min) | Tip in, second-stage peak-peak (r/min) | Tip out, second-stage peak-peak (r/min) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reducer gear backlash | Large | 78.03 | 58.87 | 53.92 | 68.87 |
| Reducer gear backlash | Small | 87.52 | 102.65 | 68.21 | 47.31 |
| Differential side gear backlash | Large | 43.54 | 45.16 | 50.90 | 46.07 |
| Differential side gear backlash | Small | 66.67 | 62.95 | 31.27 | 58.69 |
| Input shaft spline clearance | Large | 18.64 | 19.75 | 15.63 | 12.35 |
| Input shaft spline clearance | Small | 20.53 | 27.03 | 13.26 | 13.72 |
| Half-shaft spline clearance | Large | 19.24 | 18.88 | 17.26 | 23.69 |
| Half-shaft spline clearance | Small | 26.57 | 24.60 | 26.07 | 12.66 |
This table clearly shows that the sign of the influence of a given clearance may change when the objective changes from the first-stage gear to the second-stage gear, or when the operating condition changes from Tip in to Tip out. The non-linear, cross-coupled nature of the multi-clearance effects indicates that local single-parameter tuning is insufficient. From a system design point of view, the clearances should be optimised as a whole, subject to the requirement that the nonlinear dynamics of the powertrain remain in a stable regime.
To establish the stability constraint, I perform a nonlinear dynamic analysis of the gear systems. The analysis evaluates the transient response of the first-stage reducer gear pair, the second-stage reducer gear pair, and the differential gear when the clearance parameter is changed step by step. For each value of the clearance, the state of the system is sampled after the transient component has decayed. The global bifurcation diagram is then constructed from the sampled steady-state response. At the same time, the maximum Lyapunov exponent is calculated to distinguish between stable periodic motion and unstable chaotic motion.
For the first-stage reducer gear pair, the global bifurcation diagram and the maximum Lyapunov exponent are computed and compared. The first-stage gear system shows a single-period motion in the clearance range \([0,\,9.42\times10^{-5}]\) m, then a period-doubling motion in \([9.42\times10^{-5},\,1.23\times10^{-4}]\) m, and finally chaotic motion in the range \([1.23\times10^{-4},\,1.5\times10^{-4}]\) m. The maximum Lyapunov exponent is negative in the range \([2.76\times10^{-5},\,8.66\times10^{-5}]\) m, which suggests that the first-stage gear system is stable in this interval. The unstable intervals are excluded from the optimisation region. For the second-stage reducer gear pair, the maximum Lyapunov exponent remains negative in the interval \([1.9\times10^{-5},\,9.5\times10^{-5}]\) m. This range therefore becomes the stability constraint for the second-stage backlash. For the differential gear system, the maximum Lyapunov exponent is negative in the interval \([2\times10^{-5},\,9\times10^{-5}]\) m. The stability ranges obtained from the nonlinear stability analysis are summarised below.
| Nonlinear subsystem | Stable backlash range (m) |
|---|---|
| First-stage gear pair of the reducer | [2.76e-5, 8.66e-5] |
| Second-stage gear pair of the reducer | [1.9e-5, 9.5e-5] |
| Differential side gear | [2e-5, 9e-5] |
These stable intervals provide a physically meaningful constraint for the clearance optimisation. A clearance value that produces a chaotic response should always be avoided because chaotic motion can lead to irregular impacts and unpredictable dynamic loads. The stable ranges obtained above are therefore used as upper and lower bounds for the reducer gear backlash and differential side gear backlash in the subsequent optimisation.
To further identify the relative importance of the clearance variables, I perform a global sensitivity analysis using the optimal Latin hypercube design method. The reason for employing this experimental design method is that the multi-clearance system contains several variables with significant interaction effects. The optimal Latin hypercube design improves the uniformity of the sample points over the design space compared with the conventional Latin hypercube method. In the sensitivity analysis, the design variables are the input shaft spline clearance, the two-stage reducer gear backlash, the differential side gear backlash, and the left and right half-shaft spline clearances. Each design variable is transferred to the transient dynamics model, and the simulated peak-to-peak speed of the first-stage driving gear is returned to the sensitivity model after each calculation. The design-variable ranges are listed in the following table.
| Design variable | Lower bound (m) | Upper bound (m) |
|---|---|---|
| Input shaft spline clearance | 3.49e-4 | 6.98e-4 |
| First-stage gear backlash | 2.76e-5 | 8.66e-5 |
| Second-stage gear backlash | 1.9e-5 | 9.5e-5 |
| Differential side gear backlash | 2e-5 | 9e-5 |
| Left half-shaft spline clearance | 4.255e-4 | 7.12e-4 |
| Right half-shaft spline clearance | 4.255e-4 | 7.12e-4 |
The Pareto chart of the parameter sensitivity is obtained after the design-of-experiment runs. The contribution ratios of the variables to the peak-to-peak speed response of the first-stage reducer gear are ranked in descending order as follows: differential side gear backlash, second-stage reducer gear backlash, first-stage reducer gear backlash, right half-shaft spline clearance, left half-shaft spline clearance, and input shaft spline clearance. The corresponding percentage contributions are summarised below.
| Design variable | Contribution (%) |
|---|---|
| Differential side gear backlash | 31.59 |
| Second-stage reducer gear backlash | 30.92 |
| First-stage reducer gear backlash | 29.12 |
| Right half-shaft spline clearance | 3.84 |
| Left half-shaft spline clearance | 3.07 |
| Input shaft spline clearance | 1.46 |
This sensitivity ranking shows that the three gear backlash values dominate the transient impact response of the system. The spline clearances have a comparatively smaller but still non-negligible contribution. The difference in sensitivity is related to the transmission path of the impact as well as the effective inertia and stiffness at each connection. Based on this sensitivity result, I retain all six clearance parameters as design variables in the multi-objective optimisation but apply tighter bounds for the more sensitive variables according to the stability analysis.
Finally, I construct a multi-objective optimisation model for the transient-impact suppression of the electric vehicle powertrain. The objective functions are the peak-to-peak speed fluctuation of the first-stage driving gear of the reducer and the peak-to-peak speed fluctuation of the second-stage driving gear of the reducer. The objective functions are expressed as:
$$
\begin{aligned}
& \min \;\; f_1\left(b_{spline,in}, b_{g1}, b_{g2}, b_{diff}, b_{left}, b_{right}\right) = n_{pp, gear1}, \\
& \min \;\; f_2\left(b_{spline,in}, b_{g1}, b_{g2}, b_{diff}, b_{left}, b_{right}\right) = n_{pp, gear2},
\end{aligned}
$$
where \(b_{spline,in}\) is the input shaft spline clearance, \(b_{g1}\) and \(b_{g2}\) are the backlash of the first- and second-stage gear pairs, \(b_{diff}\) is the differential side gear backlash, and \(b_{left}\) and \(b_{right}\) represent the left and right half-shaft spline clearances. The optimisation constraints are listed as:
$$
\begin{aligned}
3.49\times10^{-4} &\le b_{spline,in} \le 6.98\times10^{-4},\\
2.76\times10^{-5} &\le b_{g1} \le 8.66\times10^{-5},\\
1.9\times10^{-5} &\le b_{g2} \le 9.5\times10^{-5},\\
2\times10^{-5} &\le b_{diff} \le 9\times10^{-5},\\
4.255\times10^{-4} &\le b_{left} \le 7.12\times10^{-4},\\
4.255\times10^{-4} &\le b_{right} \le 7.12\times10^{-4}.
\end{aligned}
$$
The optimisation is carried out by an automatic expert optimisation algorithm embedded in the multi-objective optimisation platform. This algorithm adaptively combines the simplex method, sequential quadratic programming, and genetic algorithm according to the landscape of the design space. Because the transient dynamic model of the electric vehicle powertrain is strongly nonlinear and time-consuming, the genetic algorithm is automatically selected as the main search strategy. The optimisation process begins with an initial population of candidate clearance combinations. Each candidate is passed to the dynamic model, where the peak-to-peak speed fluctuations are evaluated. The fitness values are then returned to the optimiser. Over successive generations, the algorithm updates the population by selection, crossover, and mutation until convergence is reached. During this process, many feasible solutions are produced, and the algorithm finally identifies the optimal parameter set. The iteration histories show a clear convergence trend. The optimised clearance parameters are listed below.
| Clearance parameter | Optimised value (m) |
|---|---|
| Input shaft spline clearance | 5.19e-4 |
| First-stage reducer gear backlash | 3.73e-5 |
| Second-stage reducer gear backlash | 2.76e-5 |
| Differential side gear backlash | 4.5e-5 |
| Left half-shaft spline clearance | 4.5e-4 |
| Right half-shaft spline clearance | 6.9e-4 |
To examine the effectiveness of the proposed multi-clearance optimisation design method, I substitute the optimised clearance parameters back into the momentum-theorem-based transient dynamic model. The simulated responses before and after the optimisation are compared. In the Tip in condition, the peak-to-peak speed fluctuation of the first-stage reducer gear is reduced from \(78.03\,\mathrm{r/min}\) to \(5.16\,\mathrm{r/min}\). In the Tip out condition, the peak-to-peak speed fluctuation of the same gear is reduced from \(88.47\,\mathrm{r/min}\) to \(5.53\,\mathrm{r/min}\). For the second-stage reducer gear, the optimised peak-to-peak speed fluctuation is reduced from \(30.04\,\mathrm{r/min}\) to \(2.03\,\mathrm{r/min}\) in the Tip in condition and from \(36.77\,\mathrm{r/min}\) to \(4.23\,\mathrm{r/min}\) in the Tip out condition. The detailed comparison is presented in the following table.
| Response quantity | Operating condition | Before optimisation (r/min) | After optimisation (r/min) |
|---|---|---|---|
| First-stage gear peak-to-peak speed | Tip in | 78.03 | 5.16 |
| First-stage gear peak-to-peak speed | Tip out | 88.47 | 5.53 |
| Second-stage gear peak-to-peak speed | Tip in | 30.04 | 2.03 |
| Second-stage gear peak-to-peak speed | Tip out | 36.77 | 4.23 |
These results demonstrate that the proposed multi-clearance optimisation design method can effectively suppress the transient impact of the electric vehicle powertrain. After the optimisation, the speed fluctuations of the reducer gears are reduced by more than one order of magnitude in most cases. More importantly, this improvement is achieved without moving any single clearance into a chaotic or unstable regime. The optimal clearances all lie within the stable ranges identified by the maximum Lyapunov exponent and the global bifurcation analysis. Therefore, the present method not only reduces the transient impact severity but also preserves stable dynamic behaviour of the whole system. In addition, because the optimisation is based on the momentum-theorem-based transient dynamics model, the predicted improvement is more reliable than the result that would be obtained with a conventional continuous contact model.
In summary, this thesis presents a systematic study on the transient impact of the powertrain system of electric vehicles under Tip in/out conditions. The main conclusions are as follows. First, I established a transient dynamic model of the electric vehicle powertrain that incorporates multiple clearances, time-varying mesh stiffness, nonlinear oil-film force, and two types of gear impact representations. The first representation is based on the conventional continuous contact-force assumption, while the second representation is based on the impulse-momentum theorem. The model is capable of describing the meshing, separation, and knocking states of the gear pairs during torque zero-crossing events. Second, I carried out full-vehicle road tests under realistic Tip in/out conditions. The measured CAN-bus data confirm that the electric vehicle powertrain exhibits significant rotational speed oscillations at the moment when the motor torque changes sign. By comparing the simulation results with the experimental data, I verified that both dynamic models can reproduce the general trend of the transient speed fluctuation. Third, by using the average relative error and the Pearson correlation coefficient as evaluation indicators, I compared the prediction performance of the two models. The comparison was performed under both large-clearance and small-clearance assembly conditions. The results show that the momentum-theorem-based model is superior to the spring-damper model, especially under the small-clearance condition where rapid and repeated gear impacts occur. The correlation coefficient of the momentum-theorem model reaches \(0.98\) for the Tip in condition, while the spring-damper model yields a correlation of only \(0.37\). These results indicate that the conventional continuous contact formulation is not sufficient for capturing the impulsive collision characteristics of the electric vehicle powertrain under Tip in/out transients. Fourth, I proposed a multi-clearance optimisation design method for suppressing the transient impact. The method consists of four stages: influence analysis of multi-clearance parameters, nonlinear stability analysis, global sensitivity analysis, and multi-objective optimisation. By using the global bifurcation diagram and the maximum Lyapunov exponent, the stable clearance intervals of the nonlinear subsystems are determined. These intervals provide a meaningful constraint for the subsequent optimisation. The multi-objective optimisation model minimises the peak-to-peak speed fluctuations of the first-stage and second-stage reducer gears simultaneously. The optimised clearance set substantially reduces the transient impact amplitudes while keeping the nonlinear response in a stable range. This work provides a theoretical and computational foundation for the clearance design of electric vehicle powertrains in engineering practice.
Future work may extend the present methodology in several directions. First, the transient dynamics model could be coupled with a motor control model to investigate the influence of torque rate and control delay on the impact severity. This would allow the optimisation of structural parameters together with control strategies. Second, more advanced data-driven techniques could be combined with the physical model to improve the efficiency of the multi-clearance parameter search. Third, the method could be extended to other electric vehicle configurations, such as four-wheel-drive or distributed-drive vehicles, where the transient impact path is more complex. These extensions would further enhance the applicability of the proposed multi-clearance design method for future electric vehicles.
