Optimization of Integrated Energy Systems with Electric Vehicle Car Swap Stations and Multi-Energy Regulation

In the context of the “dual carbon” strategy, the increasing penetration of new energy sources and the large-scale development of electric vehicle cars pose higher demands on the flexibility and coordination capabilities of energy systems. This paper focuses on integrated energy systems (IES) that incorporate electric vehicle car battery swap stations, proposing an optimization technique that accounts for the interactive regulation between electric vehicle cars and multi-energy sources. As an researcher in this field, I aim to address the challenges of renewable energy intermittency and load uncertainty through a coordinated approach. The integration of electric vehicle car swap stations as flexible resources can significantly enhance system performance, and in this work, I develop a comprehensive model to optimize economic and energy efficiency.

The core innovation lies in the synergistic interaction between electric vehicle car infrastructure and multi-energy regulation. I establish a multi-energy coordination system architecture that integrates flexible loads and swap stations, along with a control strategy for the swap station. Furthermore, I develop variable-condition models for combined heat and power (CHP) and gas boiler equipment, propose an electricity-heat coordinated demand response mechanism, and construct flexible load response models for electricity and heat. An optimization dispatch model targeting system operational economy and energy efficiency is then formulated. Through simulation of a typical day in a regional integrated energy system, multiple scenarios are set for comparative analysis, validating the crucial role of flexible load response and battery swapping station control in enhancing system performance. The widespread adoption of electric vehicle cars necessitates such integrated solutions to ensure grid stability and sustainability.

The framework of the IES with electric vehicle car swap station participation is designed to facilitate energy management across electricity, heat, and gas networks. It includes energy supply devices like wind turbines and photovoltaics, conversion devices such as CHP, gas boilers, and electric boilers, and storage devices like battery energy storage and heat storage tanks. The electric vehicle car swap station acts as both a load and a distributed storage unit, providing charging services for electric vehicle cars while participating in grid regulation. The energy management system coordinates daily operations, optimization, and demand-side management, leveraging price signals and device status to make optimal decisions. This integration is pivotal for accommodating the growing fleet of electric vehicle cars and their dynamic energy needs.

For the electric vehicle car swap station, I propose three regulation methods: time period control, power level control, and battery classification cluster control. The time period control divides the operation cycle into segments for charging, discharging, or idle states based on system conditions and market prices. Power level control adjusts the charging or discharging rate dynamically to manage energy exchange. Battery classification cluster control categorizes batteries based on state-of-charge (SOC) into non-regulatable, priority-regulatable, and backup-regulatable groups, optimizing resource allocation. The regulation process involves inputting system status and swap station data, evaluating battery capabilities, predicting swap demand, and coordinating with the IES to determine charging or discharging actions. This approach ensures that the electric vehicle car swap station can effectively balance service provision and grid support.

The demand for swap services is modeled using probabilistic methods. The daily driving distance of an electric vehicle car follows a log-normal distribution, and the hourly travel proportion is derived from statistical data. The swap demand threshold in terms of SOC is assumed to follow a normal distribution. Using Monte Carlo simulation, the number of electric vehicle cars requiring swap services at each time interval can be estimated. For a single electric vehicle car, the total mileage until a swap need arises is given by:

$$ S = \frac{100 \cdot (\text{SOC}_{\text{EV},0} – g) \cdot \text{CAP}}{100 \cdot \text{EC}} $$

where $\text{SOC}_{\text{EV},0}$ is the initial SOC, $g$ is the swap threshold SOC (normally distributed), $\text{CAP}$ is the battery rated capacity, and $\text{EC}$ is the energy consumption per 100 km. The mileage can also be expressed as:

$$ S = \sum_{t=1}^{n_t} s \cdot f_a(t) $$

with $s$ as the daily mileage from the log-normal distribution, $n_t$ as the swap time, and $f_a(t)$ as the hourly mileage proportion. The probability density function for $s$ is:

$$ f(s) = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi} \sigma_b s} \exp\left(-\frac{(\ln s – \mu_b)^2}{2\sigma_b^2}\right) $$

where $\mu_b = 3.2$ and $\sigma_b = 0.88$. This model captures the stochastic behavior of electric vehicle car users and informs swap station scheduling.

The charging and discharging dynamics of batteries in the swap station are modeled discretely. For battery $i$ at time $t$, the SOC update is:

$$ \text{SOC}_{i}(t+\Delta t) = \text{SOC}_{i}(t) + \Delta t \left( \frac{\eta_{c,\text{EV}} P_{i,c}(t)}{\text{CAP}} – \frac{P_{i,d}(t)}{\eta_{d,\text{EV}} \cdot \text{CAP}} \right) $$

where $P_{i,c}(t)$ and $P_{i,d}(t)$ are charging and discharging powers, $\eta_{c,\text{EV}}$ and $\eta_{d,\text{EV}}$ are efficiencies, and $\Delta t$ is the time step. Constraints include power limits:

$$ 0 \leq P_{i,c}(t) \leq P_{c,\text{max}}, \quad 0 \leq P_{i,d}(t) \leq P_{d,\text{max}} $$

SOC limits:

$$ \text{SOC}_{\text{min}} \leq \text{SOC}_{i}(t) \leq \text{SOC}_{\text{max}} $$

and swap service requirements:

$$ \sum_{i=1}^{N_{\text{to}}} b_{i,t} = N_{\text{swap}}(t) $$

where $b_{i,t}$ is a binary variable indicating swap action, and $N_{\text{swap}}(t)$ is the number of swap demands. Batteries used for swap must have SOC ≥ 95%:

$$ \text{SOC}_{i}(t) \geq 0.95 \cdot \text{SOC}_{\text{max}} \cdot b_{i,t} $$

The total charging and discharging power of the swap station is:

$$ P_{\text{BESS},c}^{t} = \sum_{i=1}^{N_{\text{to}}} \int_{t}^{t+\Delta t} P_{i,c}(t) \, dt, \quad P_{\text{BESS},d}^{t} = \sum_{i=1}^{N_{\text{to}}} \int_{t}^{t+\Delta t} P_{i,d}(t) \, dt $$

To avoid simultaneous charging and discharging, a linearized constraint is used:

$$ P_{\text{BESS},c}^{t} \leq M \cdot (1 – \xi^{t}), \quad P_{\text{BESS},d}^{t} \leq M \cdot \xi^{t} $$

where $M$ is a large constant and $\xi^{t}$ is a binary variable. This ensures efficient operation of the electric vehicle car swap station within the IES.

For IES equipment, variable-condition models are developed. The CHP system output depends on the load factor $\text{LF}_{\text{CHP}} = P_{\text{CHP,ac}} / P_{\text{CHP,rt}}$, with efficiency modeled as a quadratic function:

$$ \eta_{\text{CHP}}(\text{LF}_{\text{CHP}}) = \alpha_{\text{CHP}} \cdot \text{LF}_{\text{CHP}}^2 + \beta_{\text{CHP}} \cdot \text{LF}_{\text{CHP}} + \gamma_{\text{CHP}} $$

Similarly, the gas boiler efficiency is:

$$ \eta_{\text{GB}}(\text{LF}_{\text{GB}}) = \alpha_{\text{GB}} \cdot \text{LF}_{\text{GB}}^2 + \beta_{\text{GB}} \cdot \text{LF}_{\text{GB}} + \gamma_{\text{GB}} $$

where $\text{LF}_{\text{GB}} = Q_{\text{GB,ac}} / Q_{\text{GB,rt}}$. These models account for performance variations under partial loads, which is crucial for optimizing multi-energy dispatch, especially when integrating electric vehicle car charging loads.

The electricity-heat coordinated demand response mechanism leverages the complementary peaks of electric and thermal loads. In valley electricity periods coinciding with peak heat periods, demand response increases electric load to absorb excess renewable energy while reducing heat supply, lowering CHP output and purchasing cheaper electricity. In peak electricity periods with valley heat periods, electric load is reduced, and heat supply is increased to maintain CHP efficiency. This synergy enhances flexibility and reduces costs. Flexible electric load response includes curtailable, transferable, and shiftable loads:

$$ P_{L,e}^{t} = P_{L,e0}^{t} + \Delta P_{\text{CL},e}^{t} + \Delta P_{\text{TL},e}^{t} + \Delta P_{\text{ST},e}^{t} $$

where $\Delta P_{\text{CL},e}^{t}$, $\Delta P_{\text{TL},e}^{t}$, and $\Delta P_{\text{ST},e}^{t}$ are adjustments. Thermal load flexibility is modeled using a building thermal capacitance model:

$$ T_{\text{in}}^{t+1} = T_{\text{in}}^{t} e^{-\Delta t / \tau} + \left( R_{\text{th}} P_{L,h}^{t} + T_{\text{out}}^{t} \right) (1 – e^{-\Delta t / \tau}) $$

with $\tau = R_{\text{th}} C_b$. Thermal comfort is evaluated via the Predicted Mean Vote (PMV) index:

$$ I_{\text{PMV}}^{t} = \begin{cases}
0.3895(T_{\text{in}}^{t} – T_{\text{st}}), & T_{\text{in}}^{t} \geq T_{\text{st}} \\
0.4065(T_{\text{st}} – T_{\text{in}}^{t}), & T_{\text{in}}^{t} < T_{\text{st}}
\end{cases} $$

By constraining PMV, the allowable indoor temperature range gives minimum and maximum heating powers, enabling flexible thermal load participation. This demand response framework is essential for managing the added variability from electric vehicle car charging.

The optimization model minimizes total operating cost while maximizing energy efficiency. The cost objective is:

$$ \min C_{\text{IES}} = \sum_{t=1}^{T} \left[ C_{\text{grid}}^{t} + C_{\text{gas}}^{t} + C_{\text{RE}}^{t} + C_{\text{om}}^{t} + C_{\text{IDR}}^{t} + C_{\text{BESS}}^{t} \right] $$

where $C_{\text{grid}}^{t} = p_{\text{grid}}^{t} P_{\text{grid}}^{t}$ is grid purchase cost, $C_{\text{gas}}^{t} = V_{\text{IES}}^{t} p_{\text{gas}}^{t}$ is natural gas cost, $C_{\text{RE}}^{t}$ covers renewable generation and curtailment, $C_{\text{om}}^{t}$ includes device maintenance, $C_{\text{IDR}}^{t}$ is demand response compensation, and $C_{\text{BESS}}^{t} = \lambda_{\text{BESS},c} P_{\text{BESS},c}^{t} + \lambda_{\text{BESS},d} P_{\text{BESS},d}^{t}$ is swap station调度 cost. The energy efficiency objective is:

$$ \max F = \frac{\sum_{t} \left( \lambda_e P_{L,e}^{t} + \lambda_h Q_{L,h}^{t} + \lambda_e P_{\text{BESS},c}^{t} \right)}{\sum_{t} \left( \lambda_e P_{\text{grid}}^{t} + \lambda_e P_{\text{BESS},d}^{t} + \lambda_g P_{\text{gas}}^{t} \right)} $$

with $\lambda_e$, $\lambda_h$, $\lambda_g$ as energy quality coefficients. Constraints include supply-demand balances for electricity, heat, and gas; device operating limits; energy storage dynamics; demand response bounds; and swap station constraints as detailed earlier. The model is solved using Gurobi as a mixed-integer nonlinear programming problem, ensuring feasible and optimal调度 for the IES with electric vehicle car swap stations.

For simulation, I consider a regional IES with devices as shown in Table 1. The system operates in grid-connected mode without selling power, and typical daily data for winter is used with a 15-minute interval (96 periods). Time-of-use electricity prices are applied, and renewable generation along with electric and thermal loads are derived from historical data with uncertainty clustering. The electric vehicle car swap demand is predicted via the probabilistic model, with swapped battery SOC assumed normal with mean 0.24 and deviation 0.075. Four scenarios are designed to evaluate the impact of flexible load response and swap station regulation, as summarized in Table 2.

Table 1: Basic Parameters of IES Equipment
Device Type Parameter Value
Wind Turbine Rated Power (kW) 6000
O&M Cost (¥/kWh) 0.02
Photovoltaic Rated Power (kW) 4000
O&M Cost (¥/kWh) 0.02
CHP Rated Power (kW) 4166
Efficiency Coefficients α=-0.33, β=0.79, γ=0.43
Electricity-Heat Ratio 0.4:0.6
O&M Cost (¥/kWh) 0.04
Electric Boiler Rated Power (kW) 400
Efficiency 0.93
O&M Cost (¥/kWh) 0.03
Gas Boiler Rated Power (kW) 1000
Efficiency Coefficients α=-0.19, β=0.35, γ=0.7375
O&M Cost (¥/kWh) 0.03
Battery Storage Min Capacity (kWh) 150
Max Capacity (kWh) 1500
Charging/Discharging Efficiency 0.95
Max Power (kW) 300
O&M Cost (¥/kWh) 0.07
Heat Storage Tank Min Capacity (kWh) 150
Max Capacity (kWh) 1500
Charging/Discharging Efficiency 0.95
Max Power (kW) 300
O&M Cost (¥/kWh) 0.07
Demand Response Building Thermal Capacitance (MWh/°C) 0.52
Building Thermal Resistance (°C/MW) 1.65
Curtailable Load Compensation (¥/kWh) 0.3
Transferable Load Compensation (¥/kWh) 0.2
Shiftable Load Compensation (¥/kWh) 0.2
Electric Vehicle Car Swap Station Total Battery Groups 60
Battery Capacity (kWh) 56
Max Charging/Discharging Power (kW) 58
Other Parameters Natural gas price: 2.80 ¥/m³, LHV: 9.7 kWh/m³
Table 2: Scenario Settings for Simulation
Scenario Flexible Load Unordered Charging Ordered Charging Ordered Charging/Discharging
Scenario 1 × √ × ×
Scenario 2 √ √ × ×
Scenario 3 √ × √ ×
Scenario 4 √ × × √

The optimization results, as shown in Table 3, demonstrate that incorporating flexible load response and swap station regulation reduces total operating cost and improves energy efficiency. Scenario 2 with demand response lowers cost by 5.39% compared to Scenario 1, while Scenario 3 with ordered charging further reduces cost by 2.8%. Scenario 4 with ordered charging and discharging achieves the lowest cost, 5.6% lower than Scenario 3, and the highest efficiency of 92.12%. The electric vehicle car swap station plays a key role in shifting loads to valley periods and providing discharge during peaks, enhancing renewable energy absorption and reducing grid purchases.

Table 3: System Operating Cost and Efficiency Comparison
Scenario Total Cost (¥) Energy Purchase Cost (¥) Demand Response Cost (¥) O&M Cost (¥) Curtailment Cost (¥) Efficiency
Scenario 1 49374.4 44700.8 – 3906.2 767.4 90.16%
Scenario 2 46709.8 38800.5 3495.1 3863.4 550.7 91.71%
Scenario 3 45361.8 37768.0 3478.9 3875.6 239.3 91.85%
Scenario 4 42816.2 35380.4 3511.3 3924.5 0.00 92.12%

In terms of electricity system balance, Scenario 1 shows无序 charging of electric vehicle cars with high grid purchases during peaks. Scenario 2 shifts loads to valley periods via demand response. Scenario 3 concentrates swap station charging in valley periods, aligning with renewable output. Scenario 4 adds discharging during peaks, further reducing grid purchases and smoothing the load curve. The flexible electric load adjustments are evident in the reduction of peak demands and increased valley loads, facilitating better integration of electric vehicle car charging infrastructure.

For the thermal system, Scenario 1 relies on electric boilers during valley periods. Scenario 2 uses demand response to increase heat load during electricity peaks, boosting CHP efficiency. Scenario 3 and 4 optimize device operation through coordinated调度, keeping gas boilers and CHP at higher load factors and reducing storage usage. The flexible thermal load response allows indoor temperature variations within comfort bounds, enabling heat load shifting that supports electrical load management. The efficiency of CHP and gas boilers improves in Scenario 4 due to smoother operation, as illustrated by the variable-condition models.

The electric vehicle car swap station调度 results show that无序 charging in Scenarios 1 and 2 leads to random power draws, while ordered charging in Scenario 3 aligns with low电价 and high renewable periods. In Scenario 4, the swap station actively discharges during peak电价 times, providing grid support and reducing costs. The SOC dynamics of batteries reflect this regulation, with more batteries maintained at high SOC for swap readiness and others used for energy arbitrage. This highlights the dual role of electric vehicle car swap stations as both service providers and grid flexibility resources.

To validate the solution approach, I compare Gurobi with multi-objective algorithms like NSGA-II and MOPSO. As shown in Table 4, Gurobi achieves a lower optimal cost (42816.2 ¥) and faster convergence (63 seconds) than NSGA-II (45160.4 ¥, 102 seconds) and MOPSO (45201.3 ¥, 89 seconds), demonstrating its efficacy for this mixed-integer problem. The iterative curves confirm that Gurobi avoids local optima, ensuring reliable调度 for the IES with electric vehicle car components.

Table 4: Performance Comparison of Different Algorithms
Algorithm Optimal Solution (¥) Convergence Iterations Solving Time (s)
NSGA-II 45160.4 54 102
MOPSO 45201.3 33 89
Gurobi Solver 42816.2 25 63

In conclusion, this research presents a comprehensive optimization model for integrated energy systems that incorporate electric vehicle car swap stations and multi-energy regulation. By coordinating flexible demand response and swap station charging/discharging, the system achieves significant economic and energy efficiency improvements. The proposed methods enhance renewable energy absorption, reduce operational costs, and provide a framework for managing the growing integration of electric vehicle cars. Future work could explore real-time调度 with uncertainty considerations or expand to larger-scale networks. The findings underscore the importance of holistic energy management in the era of electric vehicle car proliferation and energy transition.

Scroll to Top