Energy Management Strategy of Electric Cars Based on Endurance Testing

Electric cars have evolved from early demonstration vehicles into highly optimised products in which range, efficiency, thermal comfort and battery durability must be balanced by a sophisticated energy management control architecture. As an engineer working in vehicle testing and control-strategy analysis, I have always regarded the energy management system of an electric car as the core software layer that determines how every kilowatt-hour stored in the high-voltage battery is converted into vehicle motion, cabin heating or cooling, accessory loads and regenerative braking. A well-designed energy management strategy should ensure that the electric car meets the driver’s power demand while constantly searching for the highest possible system efficiency. This is not a static optimisation problem. The optimal control action varies strongly with ambient temperature, battery state of charge, driving style, road grade, cabin thermal load and the operating state of every high-voltage and low-voltage component.

In this study, I designed and executed an analytical test programme for a state-of-the-art battery electric car, with the intention of understanding how its energy management strategy behaves under realistic driving conditions. The work was motivated by the observation that many electric cars show excellent certification results under moderate environmental conditions but suffer considerable range degradation when they are operated at low ambient temperature or high ambient temperature. This behaviour is not caused solely by electrochemistry. It is heavily influenced by the energy allocation decisions made by the vehicle control unit, battery management system, motor controllers and thermal management controllers. Therefore, an endurance test on a chassis dynamometer, combined with synchronised current, voltage, temperature and CAN-bus measurement, can reveal the energy distribution logic of an electric car much more clearly than a simple range value. In the following sections I describe the test architecture, signal acquisition method, measurement results, energy allocation strategy and regenerative braking strategy obtained from multi-condition endurance testing.

I selected a compact battery electric car equipped with dual motors. The rear motor is a permanent-magnet synchronous machine that provides the majority of traction torque under normal driving conditions. The front motor is an induction machine that can provide additional torque during hard acceleration, uphill driving or when road adhesion conditions require all-wheel-drive capability. The coordinated operation of these two electric machines is itself an important part of the energy management strategy. Compared with a single-motor electric car, a dual-motor configuration can switch between two-motor and one-motor operation, thereby shifting the operating point of each motor towards its high-efficiency region. It also enables torque distribution between the front axle and the rear axle during regenerative braking, which influences braking stability and energy recovery efficiency.

From the energy-flow perspective, the high-voltage battery is the only source of traction energy and the main source of energy for the cabin thermal system. The battery pack output power is consumed by the front electric drive unit, the rear electric drive unit, the air-conditioning compressor, the cabin positive temperature coefficient heater, the DC-DC converter and other distributed loads. The power relationship of an electric car can be written in a simplified form as:

$$P_{\text{batt}} = P_{\text{front motor}} + P_{\text{rear motor}} + P_{\text{compressor}} + P_{\text{PTC}} + P_{\text{DCDC output}} + P_{\text{low-voltage loads}}$$

During regenerative braking, the above equation is modified because the traction motors generate electrical power instead of absorbing it. The battery absorbs part of the recovered energy while accessories consume another part. This direct-by-accessory consumption path is especially important under high-temperature conditions because the air-conditioning compressor has a high electrical demand while the car is decelerating. A conventional brake system would dissipate the kinetic energy of the vehicle as heat. An electric car, by contrast, can convert part of that kinetic energy into electrical energy and supply it immediately to the high-voltage compressor, which reduces the net discharge from the battery and improves the total range. I found this strategy to be particularly visible in the experimental data discussed later.

Vehicle Topology under Test

Before mounting sensors on the car, I first performed a physical inspection of the vehicle architecture and removed several lower protective covers in order to trace the high-voltage cables and identify the locations of the main power components. This inspection was necessary because the correct attribution of measured energy flows depends on precise knowledge of the power network. The vehicle contains the following principal high-voltage components: the battery pack, front electric drive unit, rear electric drive unit, electric air-conditioning compressor, cabin PTC heater and the DC-DC converter. The thermal management components, including the battery water pump, motor water pump and radiator fans, are supplied with low-voltage alternating current through the front body controller. The low-voltage battery, onboard charger, voltage conversion device, power distribution unit and battery management system are integrated into the high-voltage service compartment below the rear seat. The front and rear drive motors and their controllers are mounted close to the corresponding axles.

The vehicle also has an active grille shutter that can be opened or closed according to cooling demand and aerodynamic drag. In an electric car, the active grille is a useful energy-saving device because closing the grille reduces aerodynamic drag when cooling demand is low. During motorway cruising, the active grille is usually closed to reduce drag; it opens only when the battery temperature or motor temperature exceeds a threshold or when the condenser in the air-conditioning circuit demands more airflow. This type of control logic can improve the high-speed energy consumption of an electric car. The data collected in this endurance test therefore include not only electrical quantities but also the activation state of the active grille, radiator fans, water pumps and high-voltage thermal components.

To analyse the energy management strategy, I needed to interpret several groups of signals. The first group is the driver-demand group, including vehicle speed, accelerator pedal opening and brake-pedal state. The second group is the battery group, including battery output voltage, output current, state of charge, highest cell temperature and lowest cell temperature. The third group is the electric-machine group, including front motor power, rear motor power, rear motor speed and rear motor torque. All these signals were acquired from the CAN bus through a reverse-engineered DBC file. The data acquisition system was connected to a laptop computer and the signal paths were monitored in CANoe before each test. In total, the critical signals that I identified for energy management analysis are summarised in the following table.

Signal domain No. Signal description Unit
Vehicle 1 Vehicle speed km/h
Vehicle 2 Accelerator pedal opening %
Battery 3 Battery pack output voltage V
Battery 4 Battery pack output current A
Battery 5 Battery state of charge %
Battery 6 Maximum cell temperature °C
Battery 7 Minimum cell temperature °C
Motor 8 Rear motor power kW
Motor 9 Rear motor speed r/min
Motor 10 Rear motor torque N·m
Motor 11 Front motor power kW

In order to verify the CAN signals and to obtain component-level energy data with higher accuracy, I installed additional voltage and current sensors on several key branches. The installation positions were selected according to the physical layout of the vehicle. Voltage sensors were installed at the rear electric drive unit, front electric drive unit, air-conditioning compressor, cabin PTC heater, DC-DC output, battery water pump, motor water pump, 12 V battery and cooling fan. Current sensors were installed on those branches where the measurement of power could not be obtained reliably from the CAN bus. Table 2 summarizes the sensor installation matrix used in this endurance study. Some components already provide sufficiently accurate power values through the CAN bus; in those cases the measured sensor signals were used only as a cross-check.

No. Component Voltage sensor Current sensor
1 Rear electric drive assembly Yes Yes
2 Front electric drive assembly Yes Yes
3 Air-conditioning compressor Yes Yes
4 Passenger-compartment PTC Yes Yes
5 DC-DC converter output Yes Yes
6 Battery water pump Yes Yes
7 Motor water pump Yes Yes
8 12 V battery Yes Yes
9 Cooling fan Yes Yes
10 Active grille Yes No

Test Design and Procedure

All endurance tests were performed on a chassis dynamometer inside a full-vehicle climatic chamber. The dynamometer is able to simulate the road-load coefficients that were derived from a coast-down measurement of the vehicle. In the endurance test, the vehicle begins from a fully charged condition and is driven until the vehicle speed can no longer follow the required test cycle. The durability, repeatability and comparability of different tests are ensured by strict soak temperature, vehicle preconditioning and equipment calibration procedures.

The test matrix contained five principal measurement items. The first item was the room-temperature CLTC-P range and energy-consumption test. The second item was the room-temperature energy-consumption test. The third was a room-temperature constant-speed endurance test at 100 km/h. The fourth was a high-temperature CLTC-P endurance test. The fifth was a low-temperature CLTC-P endurance test. In every test condition, the passenger-compartment HVAC settings and solar radiation followed the test rules defined by the EV-Test procedure used at the laboratory. The vehicle’s auxiliary devices such as infotainment and exterior lighting were switched off during all tests unless they were required for normal operation.

No. Test item Environmental condition Driving schedule
1 Room-temperature CLTC-P range Climatic dynamometer room CLTC-P
2 Room-temperature energy consumption Soak room CLTC-P
3 Room-temperature constant-speed range Climatic dynamometer room 100 km/h constant speed
4 High-temperature CLTC-P range Climatic dynamometer room CLTC-P
5 Low-temperature CLTC-P range Climatic dynamometer room CLTC-P

Before the room-temperature tests, the electric car was soaked for 12 to 15 hours at an ambient temperature of 25±5 °C. Before the high-temperature tests, the vehicle was first allowed to stabilise at 25±5 °C and then soaked at 35±3 °C with simulated solar radiation intensity of 550±45 W/m². Before the low-temperature tests, the vehicle was soaked for 12 to 15 hours at -7±3 °C. During the soak period, the thermal-management system of the vehicle was required to control the cabin and battery temperature according to the specified test method. The chassis dynamometer load was set using the measured road-load coefficients A, B and C. For the low-temperature endurance test, the road-load coefficients obtained from the room-temperature coast-down test were multiplied by 1.1, as required by the internal test specification. This adjustment was intended to represent the increased tyre rolling resistance and parasitic losses at low temperature.

During the test, the measured signals were sampled and recorded continuously. The current sensors were clamped around the corresponding cables, while voltage sensors were connected to the high-voltage terminals of each component. The CAN bus signals provided information about the control status of the vehicle. After the test, I calculated the total travelled distance, total battery discharge energy and energy consumption per 100 km. The energy consumption formula used in this investigation is:

$$C = \frac{E}{D} \times 100$$

where C is the energy consumption per 100 km, E is the total electrical energy discharged from the battery during the test and D is the travelled distance. The total battery discharge energy was obtained by integrating the product of battery output voltage and battery output current over time:

$$E_{\text{batt}} = \int_{0}^{T} U_{\text{batt}}(t) I_{\text{batt}}(t)\, dt$$

The recorded dataset was then post-processed to separate the contributions of the front motor, rear motor, compressor, PTC heater, DC-DC converter, pumps, fans and other loads. For each component, the consumed energy was computed as the time integral of the product of its measured voltage and current. This method allowed the high-level energy allocation strategy of the electric car to be reconstructed from real endurance-test measurements.

Endurance Results and Overall Evaluation

The complete test campaign produced a rich dataset that shows not only the range of the electric car but also the pattern of battery discharge under each condition. In the room-temperature CLTC-P test, the vehicle achieved a driving range exceeding 500 km. This is a considerable value for a modern battery electric car and reflects an efficient balance between traction power, regenerative braking and low auxiliary consumption. In the constant-speed test at 100 km/h, the range was lower than that of the room-temperature CLTC-P condition but the reduction was relatively small compared with the high-temperature and low-temperature cycle tests. The reason is that constant-speed driving creates almost no transient acceleration loss and allows the motor drive system to operate in a relatively stable high-efficiency region, although the aerodynamic load is higher than the average aerodynamic load of the CLTC-P cycle.

The high-temperature CLTC-P endurance test produced an evident range reduction relative to the room-temperature result. The low-temperature CLTC-P endurance test produced the most severe range reduction. To compare the conditions more conveniently, I normalised the measured range and consumption results to the room-temperature CLTC-P condition as the baseline. The normalised tendencies are provided in the table below. The intention of this normalisation is to illustrate the relative effect of ambient temperature and driving schedule on the energy management strategy.

Operating condition Range index Energy consumption per 100 km index Battery discharge energy index
Room-temperature CLTC-P 100 100 100
Room-temperature 100 km/h ≈ 91 ≈ 110 ≈ 99
High-temperature CLTC-P ≈ 83 ≈ 118 ≈ 98
Low-temperature CLTC-P ≈ 62 ≈ 156 ≈ 97

An interesting outcome is that the battery-discharge energy index in the high-temperature and low-temperature tests was close to that of the room-temperature test, despite the very different travelled distances. This means that the range reduction under severe ambient conditions is not caused simply by obvious differences in the total energy available from the battery. Instead, the additional energy consumed by the thermal-management system, and by the cabin heating or cooling equipment, must be held responsible for the larger energy consumption per kilometre. In other words, the same amount of battery discharge energy has to move the vehicle over a shorter distance because part of that energy is consumed by auxiliary loads that do not contribute to propulsion.

The low-temperature case deserves special attention. During the low-temperature CLTC-P test, the battery pack did not necessarily reach the same final depth of discharge as in the room-temperature test because the test termination criterion was based on the ability of the vehicle to follow the speed curve. When the state of charge became low, the maximum discharge power of the battery was no longer sufficient to supply both the traction motor and the thermal-management system. The vehicle speed then began to deviate from the CLTC-P trace, and the test was stopped according to the definition of the end-of-discharge condition. This effect is visible in the data near the end of the low-temperature range test, where the battery output power remains high but the vehicle is no longer able to meet the positive acceleration demand of the cycle. Therefore, the low-temperature range result is strongly influenced by the power-capability envelope of the battery rather than only by the total stored energy.

Another important observation is the relatively low decay of the battery discharge capability at low temperature. The battery pack reached a power level at the end of its discharge that was still adequate to satisfy a substantial part of the thermal-management demand. This indicates that the battery thermal-management strategy of this electric car has a good capability to keep the cell temperature within a suitable window even under sub-zero conditions. Battery heating during the pre-conditioning phase and during vehicle operation raises the cell temperature, which improves the lithium-ion diffusion rate and increases the available power for a given state of charge. Thus, the vehicle was able to continue the low-temperature test for a long time. If the battery temperature had been allowed to remain at the ambient level, the range would have been even shorter and the energy management strategy would have been forced to limit traction power much earlier.

Energy Distribution Strategy

The component-level energy analysis gives a clear picture of where the battery energy goes in an electric car. In the room-temperature CLTC-P test, the largest share of energy is consumed by the traction motors. The compressor and PTC heater are inactive because the ambient temperature is close to the comfortable thermal-neutral condition. The DC-DC converter supplies electrical energy to the low-voltage network, which includes controllers, sensors, pumps and small actuators. The low-voltage accessory load in the room-temperature condition is relatively small, but it forms the baseline energy cost of operating the car.

Under the room-temperature constant-speed condition at 100 km/h, the traction motor remains the dominant energy-consuming component. The energy consumption per kilometre increases because the aerodynamic drag increases strongly with speed. The aerodynamic power consumption can be described by the standard longitudinal-dynamics equation:

$$P_{\text{aero}} = \frac{1}{2} \rho C_D A_f v^3$$

where rho is the air density, C_D is the drag coefficient, A_f is the frontal area and v is the vehicle speed. Because power is proportional to the cube of speed, the increase in average speed from the CLTC-P cycle to a constant 100 km/h has a significant effect on the energy demand. Nevertheless, the measured range reduction at a constant speed of 100 km/h was not disproportionately large. The reason is that the absence of frequent acceleration and braking removes the energy losses associated with transient operation, and the efficiency of the rear electric motor remains high in the constant-power region at 100 km/h.

Under the high-temperature CLTC-P condition, the energy distribution shifts towards the air-conditioning compressor and radiator fans. The compressor is used both for cabin cooling and battery cooling, depending on the cooling demand of the refrigerant circuit. When the battery temperature is higher than a control threshold, a valve changes the direction of refrigerant flow and the compressor begins to cool the battery cooling plate. The cooling fan speed increases with condenser pressure and vehicle speed. In the high-temperature measurements, the compressor power and cooling-fan power are much larger than in the room-temperature tests. This auxiliary load increases the total energy consumption per 100 km and shortens the endurance range. The cabin PTC heater, however, is inactive because no heating demand exists at high ambient temperatures.

Under the low-temperature CLTC-P condition, the PTC heater is one of the most important auxiliary loads. The PTC heater heats the air that is blown into the passenger compartment, and it can also be used to heat the coolant in some thermal-management circuits. In addition, the battery heater, if present, may consume electrical energy to warm the cells during charging, parking and driving. The total thermal-management power in the low-temperature test is high enough to significantly increase the energy consumption per 100 km. The following equation expresses the total energy consumption per distance as the sum of the traction-related energy and the auxiliary thermal energy:

$$c_{\text{total}} = c_{\text{traction}} + c_{\text{aux}}$$

where c_aux includes the energy allocated to the compressor, PTC heater, cooling fans, water pumps and other low-voltage systems. The thermal-management system of an electric car is therefore not merely a comfort feature; it is an integral part of the vehicle energy balance, especially in climates with hot summers or cold winters.

Component group Room CLTC-P Room 100 km/h High-temp CLTC-P Low-temp CLTC-P
Traction motors Dominant Dominant Dominant Dominant
AC compressor Inactive Inactive High load Inactive or low
Cabin PTC Inactive Inactive Inactive High load
Cooling fans Low Moderate High Low
Water pumps Low power Moderate Moderate Moderate
DC-DC / low-voltage loads Baseline Baseline Baseline Slightly higher

During the room-temperature CLTC-P test, I observed that the water pumps of the electric car operated at a low power level and the radiator fans remained inactive for the greater part of the test. This behaviour indicates that the battery temperature and motor temperatures were within their preferred operating windows, and therefore the thermal-management controller was able to follow a minimum-energy strategy. During the room-temperature constant-speed test and the high-temperature CLTC-P test, once the battery temperature exceeded a certain threshold, the radiator fans switched on and the water-pump speed increased. This is a classic feedback control law in an electric car: the thermal-management controller tries to keep component temperatures below the degradation threshold while using the smallest possible amount of electrical power. The actual coolant temperature response is delayed by the thermal capacitance of the coolant and the mechanical components, which is why the controller tends to use hysteresis to avoid rapid switching of fans and pumps.

In the high-temperature endurance test, the compressor power increased sharply after the battery temperature exceeded its cooling threshold. This was clearly visible in the instantaneous power traces. The compressor draws electrical power from the high-voltage bus even when the driver is not demanding torque. During the many deceleration phases of the CLTC-P cycle, the regenerated electrical power from the motors is not necessarily stored entirely in the battery; part of it can be consumed directly by the compressor. This strategy has the advantage of reducing the net battery discharge during high-temperature driving. It also helps to keep the battery within the desired temperature window without drawing a disproportionately large amount of additional energy from the battery.

Effect of Driving Speed and Ambient Temperature on Electric Car Range

The influence of speed on electric car range can be analysed using the road-load equation. The total tractive force required at the wheels is the sum of rolling resistance, aerodynamic drag, grade force and acceleration force:

$$F_{\text{trac}} = m g f \cos\theta + \frac{1}{2} \rho C_D A_f v^2 + m g \sin\theta + \delta m a$$

where m is the vehicle mass, g is gravitational acceleration, f is the rolling-resistance coefficient, theta is the road angle, rho is the air density, C_D is the drag coefficient, A_f is the frontal area, v is the vehicle speed, delta is the rotational inertia factor and a is the longitudinal acceleration. The corresponding instantaneous power at the wheels is:

$$P_{\text{wheel}} = F_{\text{trac}} v$$

During a transient test cycle such as CLTC-P, frequent acceleration events require high power peaks, while regenerative braking recovers part of the kinetic energy during deceleration. During constant-speed driving at 100 km/h, the acceleration term is zero, but the aerodynamic power is continuously high because of the cubic dependence on speed. For an electric car with a highly efficient motor and inverter, the constant-speed condition can still produce a relatively good range because no energy is lost in repeated braking and because the motor operates in a narrow torque range with high efficiency. The measured result confirmed that the range loss at 100 km/h was moderate when compared with the range loss caused by high-temperature and low-temperature thermal loads.

The influence of ambient temperature on electric car energy consumption is connected to the thermodynamic load of the cabin. In a conventional car, waste heat from the engine is used to warm the cabin almost without additional fuel cost. In an electric car, the cabin is generally heated by the PTC heater or by a heat-pump system, and both require electrical energy from the high-voltage battery. In summer, the air-conditioning compressor must remove heat from the cabin and often from the battery pack as well. The thermal resistance model of the cabin can be written as:

$$Q_{\text{cabin}} = \frac{T_{\text{amb}} – T_{\text{cabin}}}{R_{\text{thermal}}}$$

where Q_cabin is the external heat load entering the cabin, T_amb is the ambient temperature, T_cabin is the interior air temperature and R_thermal is the equivalent thermal resistance of the vehicle body and glazing. The energy consumed by the HVAC system is proportional to the difference between the desired cabin temperature and the ambient temperature, and also depends on solar radiation, humidity and blower airflow. This explains why the high-temperature and low-temperature CLTC-P tests in this study consistently showed a higher energy consumption per kilometre than the room-temperature test.

The internal temperature of the battery also has a significant impact on the energy management strategy. The available energy and power of a lithium-ion cell are functions of cell temperature. At low temperature, the internal resistance rises and the maximum allowable charge current is often reduced to protect the cell from lithium plating. This means that regenerative braking power is limited at low temperature. At high temperature, the battery cooling system may need to run continuously, consuming energy that could otherwise be used for vehicle propulsion. The relationship between battery temperature and recoverable energy is a central issue in electric car thermal management. The measured data show that the vehicle tries to maximise the use of waste heat and reduce the electrical heating load by optimising the operating range of the battery temperature.

From the comprehensive endurance tests, I concluded that the tested electric car has reached an internationally advanced level in three important aspects: the room-temperature CLTC-P driving range, the range behaviour at constant high speed, and the discharge-capability attenuation of the battery pack at low temperature. These three aspects are important for the customer acceptance of an electric car because they directly reflect the usable range under realistic driving conditions. However, the vehicle also shows serious range attenuation under low-temperature and high-temperature CLTC-P conditions. Through additional component-level analysis, I found that this attenuation is mainly caused by the electrical energy demand of the thermal-management system. This is one of the most difficult challenges in the development of high-performance electric cars.

Regenerative Braking Energy Management

Regenerative braking is one of the most important technical measures that distinguishes an electric car from a conventional vehicle. During braking or coasting, the kinetic energy of the vehicle is transferred to the electric machine, which operates as a generator. The mechanical energy is converted into electrical energy and the inverter controls the generated current according to the braking torque request. In general, the vehicle controller determines the total braking demand based on the brake-pedal position, and then decides how much braking force should be provided by regenerative braking and how much by the conventional hydraulic brake. This decision is made under several constraints.

The first constraint is the maximum braking torque that the electric machine can generate at the current speed and inverter temperature. The second constraint is the maximum allowable charging current of the battery, which is determined by the battery management system. The maximum charging current depends on the battery temperature, state of charge and recent charge history. When the battery is too cold, the allowable charging current is limited because high charge currents at low temperature can damage the graphite anode. When the state of charge is very high, the electric car also reduces regenerative braking power to avoid overcharging the battery. Finally, the stability and comfort of the vehicle must be maintained. Therefore, the final regenerative-braking command is usually the minimum value among the driver demand, motor capability and battery capability:

$$P_{\text{regen, final}} = \min\left(P_{\text{regen, demand}}, P_{\text{regen, motor limit}}, P_{\text{charge, BMS limit}}\right)$$

During regenerative braking, the generated electric power can either flow to the battery or be consumed instantly by electrical loads. In modern electric cars, the high-voltage compressor and PTC heater are often connected to the same DC bus as the motor inverter and battery. Therefore, when an electrical load is active, the regenerated power can supply that load without first passing through the battery. This bypass path increases the effective energy recovery because it avoids the round-trip efficiency loss of charging and then discharging the battery. The measured data in this study clearly demonstrate the existence of this control strategy.

Figure 8 originally used in the source work compared the motor-regeneration energy and battery-recovery energy under several conditions. According to my analysis, the room-temperature CLTC-P test produced the largest energy-recovery value, mainly because the battery had high activity and because the long endurance test contained a large number of deceleration events. The high-temperature CLTC-P test also produced a considerable amount of regenerated energy. However, approximately 6.59 kWh of the recovered electrical energy did not flow back into the battery; instead it was consumed directly by the air-conditioning compressor and other electrical accessories. This is an intelligent energy-management behaviour because the compressor load in a hot environment is otherwise supplied by the battery. Supplying the compressor with recovered braking energy reduces the net energy drawn from the battery without adding any extra electrical load.

In the low-temperature CLTC-P test, the total recovered energy was the smallest among the tested conditions. This is partly because the low-temperature battery pack has a reduced ability to accept charge, and partly because the thermal-management system consumes a significant proportion of the recovered energy. In addition, the low-temperature test was terminated earlier than the room-temperature test because the vehicle was unable to follow the speed trace near the end of the test, so there were fewer complete deceleration cycles. According to the measured data, approximately 4.15 kWh of the electrical energy regenerated by the motors was not stored in the battery but was consumed directly by the PTC heater and other low-voltage electrical components. This direct supply path helps to maintain cabin comfort and battery temperature during cold operation, but it also means that the regenerated energy cannot be used later for propulsion if it is consumed as heat during the deceleration event.

The difference between motor-regenerated energy and battery-recovered energy is an important indicator for evaluating the energy management strategy of an electric car. If the former is much larger than the latter, a significant part of the recovered energy is consumed by accessories rather than stored in the battery. This is not necessarily a bad result, because every kilowatt-hour that is consumed directly from the motor during regeneration is a kilowatt-hour that does not need to be discharged from the battery in the future. However, if the direct-consumption path is too large relative to the available accessory load, the regenerative braking system may be forced to limit the braking torque so that the hydraulic brake absorbs the remaining kinetic energy. Therefore, an ideal strategy should coordinate the regenerative torque with the instantaneous accessory load so that the electric deceleration capability is always used to the maximum extent without exceeding the battery charge limit.

Condition Regenerated energy from motors Recovered energy into battery Directly used by accessories
Room-temperature CLTC-P Highest Highest Small
High-temperature CLTC-P High Moderate ≈ 6.59 kWh
Low-temperature CLTC-P Lowest Lowest ≈ 4.15 kWh

The regenerative braking control strategy of an electric car also depends on the brake-blending algorithm. When the driver presses the brake pedal, the pedal travel sensor sends a signal to the brake controller. The controller estimates the total braking demand and calculates the maximum regenerative braking torque that can be provided without making the vehicle unstable. If the demanded braking torque is low, all braking can be performed by the motor. If the demanded torque exceeds the motor capacity, the hydraulic brake system is activated to provide the additional torque. In this tested electric car, the brake pedal force was controlled to feel similar to that of a conventional car, which is important for driver acceptance. The smooth transition between regenerative braking and hydraulic braking is difficult to achieve because the conventional hydraulic brake response is not as fast as the motor torque response, and any discontinuity in the total braking force can be felt by the driver.

From an energy point of view, the regenerative braking system should avoid adding excessive load to the battery when the battery is cold. I observed that during the low-temperature test, the battery management system limited the charging power at the beginning of the test because the cell temperature was low. The vehicle controller also reduced the regenerative torque during the first phase of the low-temperature test. After the battery temperature increased, the regenerative braking limit was gradually relaxed. This type of temperature-dependent control protects the battery but slightly reduces the energy recovery efficiency. Therefore, the range benefit of regenerative braking in winter is smaller than in summer. This is also why the low-temperature electric car range in many studies is considerably reduced even though the total energy consumption per kilometre is not as high as one might expect from the cabin-heating load alone.

Thermal Management Interaction with Battery State of Charge

The thermal management of an electric car cannot be separated from the battery state-of-charge control. At high state of charge, many electric cars limit both battery discharge power and charge power to protect the cells from overvoltage and undervoltage. At low state of charge, the discharge power limit decreases as the cell voltage approaches the lower cutoff. When the ambient temperature is normal, the battery discharge power is usually sufficient to follow the entire CLTC-P speed trace until the battery reaches the required final discharge condition. In a low-temperature test, however, the available battery discharge power is lower because the internal resistance of the cell increases. If the thermal-management system also demands power from the battery, the total power requested by the traction motor and the thermal system may exceed the maximum power available from the battery before the nominal end-of-discharge state is reached.

The relationship between battery rated energy, usable energy and discharge power can be described by the following simple model:

$$E_{\text{usable}} = \int_{SOC_{\text{min}}}^{SOC_{\text{max}}} V_{\text{oc}}(SOC) C_{\text{cell}}(T)\, dSOC$$

where V_oc is the open-circuit voltage as a function of state of charge and C_cell is the cell capacity that changes with temperature and discharge current. In the tested vehicle, the room-temperature usable energy was close to the nominal energy because the battery temperature was well controlled by the cooling system. In the low-temperature test, the usable energy was reduced by the poorer lithium-ion transport in the cells, but the reduction was not as severe as I have observed in some less optimised electric cars. The battery pack thermal-management control in this vehicle appears to preheat the cells before the endurance test begins and to maintain a favourable temperature distribution throughout the pack during the discharge phase. Good temperature uniformity between cells also reduces the possibility that one weak cell limits the entire pack power.

The temperature distribution inside a battery pack depends on the cooling-circuit topology and the flow rate of the coolant. If the coolant channels are connected in series, the cells near the inlet may be cooler than the cells near the outlet, which creates an undesirable temperature gradient. The thermal management controller has to decide whether to increase the coolant flow rate or to switch into a different cooling mode when the temperature difference becomes too large. Increasing the water-pump speed consumes additional electrical energy. Therefore, the thermal control strategy of an electric car should balance three goals: keeping the maximum cell temperature below the safety threshold, maintaining a small temperature gradient across the pack and reducing the auxiliary power consumption as much as possible.

In the high-temperature endurance test, the thermal-management system was able to keep the battery temperature below the upper limit for most of the test. The compressor was switched into the battery-cooling mode when the battery coolant temperature exceeded the target value. This was apparent from the measured compressor current, which increased sharply after the maximum cell temperature passed the threshold. The heat extracted from the battery was rejected to the ambient air through the condenser. The condenser fan speed increased with the refrigerant pressure, which was itself related to the ambient temperature. Although the high-temperature air-conditioning power was substantial, the control strategy successfully prevented the battery from overheating, allowing the electric car to complete the full test without an early power reduction.

At the end of the high-temperature test, the battery state of charge was low and the total discharge power was still sufficient to track the CLTC-P speed trace. This indicates that the battery cooling load during the high-temperature test did not force the vehicle into the power-limited region until the normal end-of-discharge condition. In the low-temperature test, on the other hand, the battery power limit was reached earlier because of the additional cabin-heating load. This difference shows that the high-temperature range loss of an electric car is mainly caused by the continuous auxiliary load, while the low-temperature range loss is a combined result of reduced battery power capability and the auxiliary heating load. Both mechanisms should be addressed separately in the design of the energy management strategy.

Comparison of Room-Temperature and Constant-Speed Energy Management

The constant-speed condition at 100 km/h is often used in the endurance testing of electric cars because it represents motorway driving. In this condition, the electric machine operates with a relatively constant torque and speed. The electronic control unit does not need to react to rapidly changing accelerator pedal positions, so the torque-control algorithm can operate near its steady-state calibration point. The measured range at 100 km/h was close to the room-temperature CLTC-P range, although the constant-speed condition generally produces higher aerodynamic drag and lower energy recovery. This result can be explained by the different test mechanics. In a CLTC-P cycle, the vehicle frequently accelerates to a speed of up to 120 km/h, but it also frequently brakes and stops. The kinetic energy gained during acceleration is partly recovered during deceleration. In a constant-speed test, there is no large acceleration phase, but at the same time there is no regeneration event. Therefore, the net energy consumption per kilometre is not as high as it would be in a cycle with a high average speed and very aggressive accelerations.

The energy management strategy of the tested electric car evidently tries to keep the rear motor in the high-efficiency area whenever the total power demand is below a threshold. The front motor is usually disconnected from the torque path unless the driver requests a high torque or the road condition requires all-wheel-drive traction. Disconnecting the front motor reduces the no-load losses of the induction motor. This is an important strategy because an induction motor can generate eddy-current and magnetisation losses even when it produces zero torque. The controller can reduce these losses by using the inverter to switch off the excitation current or by mechanically disconnecting the motor if a clutch is installed. In many dual-motor electric cars, the front axle is equipped with a decoupler so that the front motor can be disconnected from the wheels during normal highway cruising. This reduces both friction drag and the rotating inertia of the front drive unit, helping to extend the range of the electric car.

During acceleration phases, the rear motor is typically operated alone up to the point where its torque reaches a calibration limit. If the driver demand continues to increase, the front motor is activated to provide the additional torque. This torque split strategy ensures that the rear motor does not operate at very high currents with low efficiency. By activating the front induction motor only during peak-power events, the overall efficiency of the electric drive system is improved. The same principle is also used during regenerative deceleration, where the rear motor is preferred because the rear axle has a higher dynamic load capacity in some driving situations. However, the exact torque distribution depends on the vehicle stability controller, the state of the brake system and the estimated friction coefficient of the road.

The measured data from the constant-speed test show that the battery current was relatively smooth and slightly negative under cruise conditions, because the inverter current was used to sustain the vehicle speed against aerodynamic drag and rolling resistance. The active grille was mostly closed during this condition, which helped to reduce the aerodynamic drag coefficient. The radiator fans operated at a low duty cycle because the battery temperature did not increase excessively at a steady motor load. This is an important difference between the constant-speed test and the more aggressive CLTC-P test. During the CLTC-P cycle, high power peaks heat up the battery more quickly, causing the cooling fans to switch on earlier. In the constant-speed condition, the lower average current demand reduces the amount of heat generated by the cells, which reduces the cooling energy required by the battery thermal-management system.

Implications for Electric Car Energy Management Optimisation

The energy management strategy of an electric car should be optimised not only for a single driving cycle but over a wide matrix of ambient temperatures, payloads, road gradients and traffic conditions. The results of this endurance study show that the most difficult operating conditions for a battery electric car are cold weather and hot weather. At moderate temperatures, the range and energy consumption of modern electric cars are already close to the practical limits imposed by battery chemistry and motor efficiency. Further improvements in room-temperature energy consumption are difficult and relatively expensive. On the other hand, reducing the energy consumption of the thermal-management system at low and high temperatures offers a large opportunity to increase the usable range of an electric car without increasing the battery size.

The most direct approach is to improve the coefficient of performance of the cabin heating system. A PTC heater has a coefficient of performance of approximately one, which means that one kilowatt of electrical energy produces one kilowatt of heat. A heat-pump system can deliver two to three kilowatts of heat for each kilowatt of electrical energy by extracting heat from the ambient air or from the battery-cooling circuit. Therefore, replacing the PTC heater with a heat pump can significantly reduce the heating load in winter. In an electric car equipped with a heat pump, the waste heat from the motor and inverter can also be recovered and used to heat the cabin. The control system must decide whether to send the waste heat to the battery, to the cabin or to the radiator based on the temperature requirements of each component.

The recovery of waste heat is equally important in an electric car. During high-power driving, the motor windings and power electronics produce heat. This heat is normally rejected to the ambient air through the cooling radiator. In winter, the same heat can be used to preheat the battery or to heat the passenger compartment. This requires a more complex coolant circuit and a flexible valve system. The energy management controller must decide in real time whether it is more beneficial to use the heat source for the cabin or for the battery. In general, the cabin-heating demand is determined by the difference between the target cabin temperature and the ambient temperature, while the battery heating demand is determined by the electrochemical performance and charging capability of the cells. The optimal decision changes rapidly with driving conditions and passenger behaviour, so a model-based predictive control strategy is often used to improve the thermal management of modern electric cars.

Another promising direction is to reduce the energy demand of the thermal-management components themselves. Water pumps with electronically commutated motors have a higher efficiency than brushed pumps. Pumps with variable speed control can operate at the minimum flow rate necessary to keep the temperature difference within an acceptable band, rather than operating at a fixed speed. Cooling fans with adaptive blade designs or low-loss electric motors can reduce the electrical power required to supply a given amount of airflow. Active grille shutters reduce the aerodynamic drag at high speed and should be opened only when cooling demand exceeds the passive airflow capability. The measured test data indicate that the water pumps and fans in this tested electric car are already well-matched to their thermal loads, but there is still room for improvement in their calibration during partial-load conditions.

Advanced thermal-management technologies can further improve the overall efficiency of an electric car. Evaporative cooling systems, refrigerant-based battery cooling and immersion cooling can remove heat more effectively than conventional water-glycol cooling circuits. Phase-change materials can absorb peak thermal loads and reduce the frequency of compressor operation. Nanoparticle-enhanced coolants can improve the heat-transfer coefficient of the cooling loop without significantly increasing the pumping power. In cold climates, heat-pump systems with an internal heat exchanger and an accumulative ice storage device can continue to supply heat even when the outdoor temperature is very low and the moisture in the air starts to freeze on the evaporator. All of these technologies must be integrated with the energy management strategy of the electric car to achieve the best balance between comfort, range and cost.

Experimental Challenges in Electric Car Energy Management Testing

Conducting accurate endurance tests of an electric car requires precise measurement of every energy path and careful control of the test environment. The chassis dynamometer must be accurately calibrated so that the road-load coefficients are reproduced correctly. The temperature of the climatic chamber must be stable within the tolerance band specified by the test standard. In addition, the solar radiation intensity must be set to the required level in high-temperature tests. The vehicle state of charge must be carefully managed before the test, because the initial SOC affects the driving range and the battery discharge behaviour. The vehicle is charged to a full condition and then soaked at the target temperature. During the soak, the battery management system may consume energy to heat or cool the battery, and this energy must be recorded if the analysis is intended to include the full conditioning energy.

The installation of current and voltage sensors on the high-voltage cables requires special attention to electrical safety. The sensors must be connected with appropriate isolation and insulation because the battery voltage of an electric car can exceed 400 V. The sensor output signals must be electrically isolated from the data acquisition system in order to prevent ground loops and to protect the measurement equipment. The voltage sensors are usually connected to the positive and negative terminals of the component through high-voltage probes. The current sensors are usually installed around the cable using a Rogowski coil or a Hall-effect clamp. It is important to verify that the insertion of the sensors does not disturb the vehicle’s normal electromagnetic compatibility. The high-frequency switching of the motor inverter and DC-DC converter can generate electromagnetic interference, so the sensor cables should be shielded and the data acquisition system should be properly grounded.

Another important challenge is the alignment of the CAN bus data with the high-frequency analogue measurements. Some CAN messages are transmitted at a low rate, which makes it difficult to calculate the exact instantaneous power of a component if the voltage and current change quickly. To solve this problem, I used the high-resolution analogue signals from the external sensors as the primary source for energy calculations. The CAN bus data were used to determine the control mode and operating state of each component. For example, the compressor power was obtained from the measured voltage and current, while the CAN signal was used to determine whether the compressor was in cooling mode, heating mode or standby mode. This combination of analogue and digital signals provides a reliable basis for the energy management analysis.

The dynamic response of the sensors must also be considered. A current sensor with a low bandwidth may not accurately follow the steep current pulses produced by the motor inverter. Therefore, the sensors used in this study were selected with a sufficiently high bandwidth. The sampling rate of the data acquisition system was set to at least 100 Hz so that the short acceleration and deceleration events of the CLTC-P cycle could be captured with adequate resolution. The energy results were obtained by time integration of the instantaneous power. Any small DC offset in the current sensors must be corrected by using a zero-offset adjustment before the test, because the offset error accumulates during the long endurance test and can produce a non-negligible error in the total battery discharge energy.

In order to determine the net energy consumption of the traction motors, I separated the positive motor power from the negative motor power. The positive power represents the motoring operation, while the negative power represents the generating operation. The net mechanical energy delivered to the wheels was not directly measured, but it can be estimated from the motor speed and torque signals recorded on the CAN bus. The difference between the electrical energy consumed by the motors and the mechanical energy delivered to the wheels represents the losses in the inverter, motor windings, iron, friction and the transmission. These losses are not constant; they depend strongly on torque, speed and temperature. The energy management strategy of the electric car determines the operating point of each motor, and therefore strongly influences the total losses of the electric drive system.

Methodology for Energy Analysis

After completing the endurance tests, the recorded data were processed according to a structured methodology. First, the measured voltage and current signals from each sensor were converted to power by multiplying the two signals. The power signals were then filtered with a moving-average window to remove high-frequency switching noise. The filtered power signals were integrated over time to obtain the total energy consumption of each component. The battery energy was calculated from the battery voltage and current measured at the battery terminals. The motor energy was calculated from the DC voltage and current at the motor controller input. The DC-DC converter energy was measured at its output side, which means that the energy consumed by the low-voltage accessories was measured directly at the 12 V output terminal. The energy consumed by the DC-DC converter itself appears as an additional loss that is not assigned to any particular component.

The total energy balance can be written in the following form:

$$E_{\text{batt}} = E_{\text{front}} + E_{\text{rear}} + E_{\text{comp}} + E_{\text{PTC}} + E_{\text{DCDC}} + E_{\text{misc}}$$

where E_front and E_rear are the net electrical energies supplied to the front and rear inverters, E_comp is the compressor input energy, E_PTC is the PTC heater input energy, E_DCDC is the DC-DC output energy and E_misc includes all power consumed by the pumps, fans and active grille. In this equation, the regenerated energy is already subtracted from the net motor energies because the motor power can be negative during regenerative braking. Therefore, the sum of the component energies is equal to the battery discharge energy, apart from measurement errors and energy losses in the high-voltage distribution network. If the measured sum does not match the battery energy, the difference can be used as an indicator of wiring losses, cable losses and the energy consumed by devices that are not directly monitored.

The energy consumption per 100 km for the complete electric car is calculated as described by the equation shown earlier. In addition, I calculated the traction energy consumption per 100 km by dividing the sum of the motor energies by the travelled distance. The thermal-management energy consumption per 100 km was calculated by dividing the energy consumed by the compressor, PTC heater, pumps, fans and active grille by the travelled distance. The difference between the total energy consumption and the traction energy consumption is used to evaluate the auxiliary energy overhead. This overhead is especially important in high-temperature and low-temperature tests because it directly affects the customer-observed range of the electric car.

Discussion of Results and Control Strategy Observations

One of the clearest observations from the endurance tests is that the baseline energy consumption of the electric car is already very competitive under moderate temperature conditions. The vehicle has a long room-temperature range, which is the result of many engineering decisions: high battery capacity, efficient permanent-magnet motor, low aerodynamic drag, low rolling resistance tyres and a well-tuned torque coordination algorithm. The room-temperature CLTC-P test also showed a relatively low average auxiliary power because the water pumps and fans are controlled according to the actual thermal demand rather than operating continuously. The vehicle control unit appears to use a state-machine-based energy management strategy in which the main cooling devices are switched on only when the component temperatures reach the upper hysteresis boundary and are switched off when the temperature falls below the lower boundary.

The high-temperature test demonstrated the importance of an efficient refrigerant system in an electric car. The compressor is the largest single auxiliary load in the high-temperature condition. Its power increases steeply as the ambient temperature and the battery temperature rise. A conventional fixed-displacement compressor would have to cycle on and off, causing large power oscillations and temperature fluctuations. The tested vehicle uses an electrically driven variable-displacement compressor, which can continuously adjust its displacement and speed to match the required cooling capacity. This allows the compressor to operate at lower power when the cooling demand is low and to increase its power smoothly when the cooling demand rises. The compressor control algorithm is thus an important part of the electric car’s overall energy management strategy.

In the low-temperature condition, the cabin PTC heater was the main energy-consuming thermal device. The data show that the PTC heater power was regulated according to the difference between the measured cabin temperature and the target temperature. When the vehicle first started the CLTC-P test after the low-temperature soak, the cabin temperature was far below the target. The PTC heater therefore operated at a relatively high power for several minutes in order to warm the cabin quickly. After the cabin temperature approached the target, the PTC heater power was reduced and the blower fan speed was adjusted to maintain the cabin temperature. This heating strategy causes a higher energy consumption in the initial phase of a cold-start test. The energy management strategy must decide whether to use battery power to heat the cabin before departure while the car is connected to the charger, because pre-conditioning using grid power can reduce the depletion of the battery during driving. In this test, the vehicle was not connected to the charger during the soak phase, so all the cabin heating energy was drawn from the battery during the test itself.

The effect of low temperature on battery capacity was apparent from the low-temperature test data. The battery management system limited the maximum charge current and discharge current during the early phase of the test when the cell temperature was low. As the battery warmed up under the effect of its internal heat generation, the discharge current limit increased and the vehicle could accelerate more quickly. This behavioural evolution can be seen in the recorded data by comparing the voltage response of the battery during an acceleration event. At the beginning of the low-temperature test, the battery voltage drops sharply because of the high internal resistance. After several minutes of driving, the voltage drop becomes smaller, indicating that the battery temperature has increased and the internal resistance has decreased. The thermal management strategy in this phase relies mainly on internal heat generation rather than on an electrical battery heater. This is a reasonable approach because it avoids the additional energy consumption of a heater while still improving the battery performance.

Analysis of Regenerated Energy under Different Temperatures

The regenerative-braking analysis showed that the tested electric car is capable of recovering a substantial portion of the deceleration energy in the room-temperature condition. In the room-temperature CLTC-P test, the battery charge acceptance is high and the battery is able to absorb a large amount of current during regenerative braking. In the high-temperature test, the battery charge acceptance is also relatively high, but the air-conditioning compressor consumes a large amount of electrical power at the same time. Therefore, the regenerated power can be used directly by the compressor without first passing through the battery. This direct path is particularly effective when the compressor is operating at high load during a deceleration event. In the measured high-temperature endurance test, about 6.59 kWh of the regenerated energy was consumed in this direct mode. This value is quite significant and confirms that the vehicle control algorithm actively uses the recovered energy to supply the auxiliary loads.

In the low-temperature endurance test, the total regenerated energy was lower because the battery charge acceptance was constrained by the low temperature. The battery management system sets a maximum charge current limit based on the lithium plating boundary, so the maximum regenerative power is lower than in the room-temperature test. The vehicle controller therefore relies more on the hydraulic brake to provide the additional braking torque. This is a safe decision, but it reduces the advantage of regenerative braking in winter. The measured direct-use energy in the low-temperature test was about 4.15 kWh, which was mainly consumed by the PTC heater and other electrical loads. The existence of this direct path is beneficial because it allows the recovered energy to be used for cabin heating without imposing an additional discharge on the battery. In an ideal electric car, all regenerative energy would either flow to the battery or to the active electrical loads, so that the hydraulic brake is used only when the battery and motor cannot provide the required braking torque.

In order to evaluate the electrical behaviour of the battery during regenerative braking, I also studied the relationship between the regenerated power and the battery voltage. During strong regenerative-braking events, the battery voltage rises because of the internal resistance, and the battery management system checks whether the cell voltage stays below the maximum allowable voltage. If the cell voltage approaches the upper limit, the regenerative power is reduced gradually rather than being turned off abruptly. This gradual reduction is important for drivability. The motor controller can also adjust the torque on the rear axle to recover as much energy as possible while preserving the stability of the vehicle. If the battery is almost fully charged, the state of charge limit becomes the dominant constraint and the car applies only a small regenerative torque, relying on the hydraulic brake for the rest of the braking demand. This behaviour was not prominent in this test because the endurance tests begin at full SOC and quickly consume energy, thereby creating a sufficient buffer for regenerative charge acceptance.

Future Development of Test Methods for Electric Car Energy Management

Future endurance-test methods should place more emphasis on the combined energy management of the traction system and the thermal system. The current range tests supply important information about the performance of an electric car under a specific ambient temperature and driving schedule. However, they do not fully describe the ability of the onboard controller to optimise energy flows during a trip. For example, two electric cars with identical driving cycles and identical environment could consume different amounts of energy if their thermal-management strategies are different. The energy management strategy can decide whether to use the battery to precondition the cabin before the trip, when to switch from heating mode to ventilation mode and how much waste heat to recover from the electric drive system.

To analyse these higher-level strategies, it is necessary to measure the component-level power flows in a more complete way than a single energy-consumption test. The test engineer should synchronise the CAN bus data with high-frequency current and voltage data, and should also record the temperature at multiple points in the coolant circuit and refrigerant circuit. This enables the development of a heat-flow model for the electric car. Such a model can be used to verify the control logic and to identify the conditions under which the energy management strategy is optimal or suboptimal. The results obtained in this work can serve as a benchmark for other electric cars, because they show the expected best-practice behaviour in terms of energy distribution and regenerative braking.

The selection of the driving schedule is also very important. The CLTC-P schedule has a lower average speed and more frequent stops than some older test cycles. This makes it representative of urban and suburban driving in China, but it contains less motorway driving than a real-world route with high-speed sections. Therefore, a single test condition is not enough for a complete evaluation of the energy management of an electric car. The test programme should include a 100 km/h constant-speed condition to evaluate the energy consumption at high speed, and it should be repeated at low, room and high temperatures to evaluate the seasonal influence. The combination of these results gives a much more complete picture of the electric car’s energy management strategy than a single range figure.

The continuous development of test methods for electric cars should also consider the use of artificial intelligence and machine-learning tools in the analysis of energy management strategies. The large amount of data collected during an endurance test contains many subtle patterns that are not visible in an average value. For instance, a neural network can be used to predict the instantaneous power demand of the cabin heater as a function of ambient temperature, cabin temperature, solar radiation, blower speed and HVAC mode. The output of such a prediction model can be used to explain the energy management logic and to identify the most influential variables in the control system. During the analysis of the data obtained in this study, I found that the thermal-management model of an electric car is highly nonlinear and cannot be captured reliably by linear regressions.

Model-Based Interpretation of Measured Energy Consumption

In order to understand the measured energy consumption in a more systematic way, I combined the test data with a simple mathematical representation of the energy flow in the vehicle. The total electrical power required from the battery at every instant is equal to the sum of the traction power and the auxiliary power. The traction power depends on the road-load force and the drivetrain efficiency. The auxiliary power depends on the state of the thermal-management system and the low-voltage electrical system. The traction energy and auxiliary energy can be expressed as:

$$E_{\text{traction}} = \int P_{\text{traction}}(t)\,dt$$

$$E_{\text{aux}} = \int P_{\text{aux}}(t)\,dt$$

The total range can then be interpreted by dividing the usable battery energy by the sum of the average traction power and average auxiliary power, multiplied by the total test time:

$$R = \frac{E_{\text{usable}}}{\overline{P}_{\text{traction}} + \overline{P}_{\text{aux}}}$$

For an electric car, P_aux is small in the room-temperature CLTC-P test because the compressor and PTC heater are inactive. In the high-temperature CLTC-P test, P_aux is larger because of the compressor load. In the low-temperature CLTC-P test, P_aux is even larger in relative terms because the vehicle may not be able to complete the full discharge of the battery before the speed-tracking constraint is violated. The measured range reduction is therefore a direct consequence of the auxiliary power demand and the reduced usable energy.

A further refinement of the model can be obtained by considering the energy regeneration path. The net traction energy is the difference between the motoring energy and the regenerative energy. The regenerative energy itself can be split into the part stored in the battery and the part consumed directly by the auxiliary loads:

$$E_{\text{regen}} = E_{\text{regen,batt}} + E_{\text{regen,aux}}$$

The direct-use path improves the effective range of the electric car because it replaces energy that would otherwise be drawn from the battery. Therefore, the total range can also be written as:

$$R = \frac{E_{\text{usable}} + E_{\text{regen,aux}}}{\overline{P}_{\text{traction}}}$$

where E_regen,aux is the regenerated energy that is consumed by the auxiliary loads without being stored in the battery. This expression shows that the direct consumption of regenerated energy is equivalent to increasing the usable capacity of the battery. In high-temperature conditions, the compressor can consume a significant amount of the recovered energy; this effect alone can partly compensate for the negative influence of the air-conditioning load.

Recommendations for Optimising Electric Car Energy Management

The results of this endurance test lead to several practical recommendations for the improvement of electric car energy management. First, the thermal-management system should be designed with a flexible architecture that allows the waste heat from the electric drive system to be recovered and used for the cabin or battery. The current architecture of the tested vehicle already provides a good foundation for this approach, but more advanced heat-pump systems can further reduce the low-temperature energy consumption. Second, the regenerative braking strategy should anticipate the state of the auxiliary loads. If the vehicle control unit knows that the high-voltage compressor is active, it should ensure that the regenerative torque limit is not unnecessarily reduced by the battery charge limit, because part of the recovered energy can be consumed directly. Third, the battery preheating and cabin pre-conditioning schedule should be optimised for real-world customer trips. If the car is connected to the charger overnight, the cabin can be pre-warmed using grid power before departure in winter, thereby preserving battery energy for driving.

Another important recommendation is to improve the efficiency of the cooling fans and water pumps by using demand-based control. During constant-speed driving at motorway speed, the ram airflow through the heat exchangers is usually sufficient to cool the coolant and refrigerant without operating the fans at high speed. Therefore, the fan speed can be reduced in favour of aerodynamic drag reduction. The active grille should be closed whenever possible. The water pump can also be operated in a pulsed manner to maintain a uniform temperature distribution while reducing pumping power. Modern electric cars should use continuously variable pumps with the lowest possible parasitic power consumption.

The energy management strategy can also be improved by using navigation data and traffic prediction. If an electric car knows the remaining distance to the destination and the expected traffic conditions, it can adjust the cabin temperature and battery temperature in advance to reduce the total energy consumption. For example, before reaching a motorway segment, the battery can be cooled to a lower temperature to reduce the risk of power derating during high-power driving. Near the end of a trip, the cabin temperature can be allowed to drift slightly towards the ambient temperature in order to save energy. These predictive strategies are not yet fully reflected in current certification tests, but they will become increasingly important as connectivity and automated driving functions evolve.

Battery heating should be performed by using the most energy-efficient heat source available. If the electric car has a heat-pump system, the battery heater can be connected to the heat-pump circuit so that the heat is extracted from the ambient air or from the waste heat of the power electronics. If the battery has a very low state of charge, the control strategy should reduce the cabin-heating power before the battery temperature control is affected, because maintaining the minimum battery discharge power is more important for the range than maintaining the target cabin temperature near the comfort setpoint. This prioritisation logic is a key part of the energy management strategy and should be defined explicitly according to safety and drivability constraints.

Ultimate Findings from the Endurance Study

The tested electric car achieved an advanced international level on the room-temperature CLTC-P range. Its constant-speed range at 100 km/h was close to the room-temperature cycle result. The battery pack also showed a relatively limited performance reduction at low temperature, which indicates that the battery thermal-management strategy is successful in maintaining the cell temperature at a favourable level. However, the range results obtained in the low-temperature and high-temperature CLTC-P tests confirmed that the thermal-management energy demand is the main weak point of the electric car. The large energy consumption of the PTC heater and compressor is the direct cause of the reduced range. Improving the efficiency of the cabin thermal system and reducing the energy consumption of the auxiliary electrical system are therefore the most important measures to further increase the usability of electric cars in extreme climates.

In the low-temperature test, the PTC heater consumed a lot of electrical energy in order to raise the cabin air temperature. Because the ambient temperature was -7 °C, the temperature difference between the cabin and the outside air was high. The heating demand of the cabin is approximately proportional to the difference between the target cabin temperature and the ambient temperature. The tested vehicle did not use a heat pump, so all of the heating energy came from the electrical resistance of the PTC heater. This explains why the energy consumption per 100 km was higher in the low-temperature test than in any other test. Nevertheless, the energy management strategy still recovered 4.15 kWh of regenerated energy for direct use by the heater, which shows that the regenerative-braking system and the thermal-management system are integrated into the overall energy management logic of the electric car.

In the high-temperature test, the compressor consumed a large amount of electrical energy to reject heat from the cabin and battery. The cooling load was increased by solar radiation and by the heat generated by the battery and electric drive components. The compressor energy consumption can be reduced by increasing the efficiency of the condenser, using a more efficient compressor and by reducing the heat ingress into the cabin. Solar-reflective glazing, exterior paint with high infrared reflectivity and better cabin insulation can reduce the cooling load of an electric car in summer. The tested vehicle performed reasonably well in the high-temperature test, but the energy management strategy showed that there is still an opportunity to improve the control of the refrigerant circuit when the battery cooling demand and the cabin cooling demand are both high.

The dual-motor architecture of the tested electric car is beneficial for the energy management in several operating conditions. During normal urban driving, the front motor can be disconnected from the driveline to avoid drag losses. During high-power acceleration, the front motor provides additional torque and avoids overloading the rear motor. During high-speed cruising, the front motor is normally inactive, which reduces the electrical loss of the induction machine. During regenerative braking, both motors can be used to recover energy if the battery can accept the total regenerative power. The selection of the motor operating mode is a discrete event that is controlled by the energy management strategy. This mode selection depends on the estimated wheel torque demand, the vehicle speed, the battery voltage and the temperature of the motors and inverters. The results of this study show that the tested electric car selects the majority of its operating points in the most efficient single-motor mode, while the all-wheel-drive mode is used only when necessary.

In conclusion, I believe that this endurance-test based analysis provides a useful framework for studying the energy management strategy of a battery electric car. The integration of chassis dynamometer testing, climatic chamber conditioning, high-precision current and voltage sensors and CAN-bus diagnostic information allowed me to reconstruct the energy distribution, thermal management operation and regenerative braking behaviour of the vehicle under different conditions. This approach can be used as a benchmarking method for other electric cars and can help identify the strength and weakness of their control strategies. The long room-temperature range of the tested electric car confirms that a well-coordinated electric drive system can achieve excellent efficiency. The large thermal-management consumption under low-temperature and high-temperature conditions indicates that thermal-system optimisation is the next major frontier for improving the real-world range of electric cars.

Future research on electric car energy management should combine test data with simulation models to evaluate the potential improvements of new technologies before they are integrated into the vehicle. The thermal management of the battery, the cabin and the electric drive system should be treated as one integrated control problem. The optimal energy management strategy should be able to predict the future power demand of the vehicle and the future thermal load of the cabin, then adjust the operating state of the motors, pumps, fans, compressor and heater accordingly. In this way, an electric car can operate as efficiently as possible in every season and every traffic condition, which will be a decisive competitive factor in the future transportation market.

Scroll to Top