Horizontal Offset Effects on Electric Car Wireless Charging Efficiency

As environmental regulations become stricter and clean-energy policies are implemented around the world, electric cars have gradually become the preferred alternative to conventional internal-combustion vehicles. One of the most critical problems for electric car owners is charging: long charging time, limited charging infrastructure, and connector compatibility issues often reduce the convenience of electric cars. Wireless charging has therefore attracted much attention because it removes the physical cable, enables a more automated charging procedure, and can operate under harsh weather conditions. For an electric car, wireless charging is useful not only in the garage but also at public parking lots, taxi stands, bus depots, and even on road sections that support dynamic charging. However, the efficiency of the wireless charging link strongly depends on the position of the receiving coil mounted under the chassis relative to the transmitting coil buried or installed on the ground. If the driver parks with a large horizontal offset, the transmission efficiency can drop considerably. In this paper, I focus on the influence of horizontal offset on the wireless charging transmission efficiency for electric cars. I introduce a simplified circuit model, describe an experimental campaign, and present measurement data acquired with a fixed coil gap of 12 cm. I also define a quantitative sensitivity metric and discuss how the influence of lateral displacement changes as the offset becomes larger. The results are intended to help electric car wireless charging system designers understand parking-tolerance requirements and to guide future work on robust magnetic couplers.

1. Introduction and Background

Electric car sales have increased dramatically during the past decade. The growth is driven by the need to reduce carbon dioxide emissions, improve urban air quality, and reduce dependence on fossil fuels. However, charging remains a major bottleneck for electric car users. Plug-in charging is simple, but it may be difficult for elderly people or physically disabled users to handle cables, especially in wet or dark environments. Moreover, exposed metallic contacts can suffer from wear, corrosion, or electrical arcing. Wireless charging overcomes many of these drawbacks. Since no metallic contact is required, an electric car can be charged fully automatically after being parked above a charging pad. This automatic charging capability is particularly important for future autonomous electric cars, which may not have drivers to plug in a cable.

Several wireless power transfer technologies have been considered for electric car charging. The three most widely studied types are electromagnetic induction, magnetic resonant coupling, and electromagnetic radiation. In induction power transfer, the primary coil creates an alternating magnetic field, and the secondary coil picks up the field to produce a voltage. The efficiency is high but the tolerance to misalignment is small. In magnetic resonant power transfer, the primary and secondary coils are tuned to the same resonant frequency by compensation capacitors. Resonance permits relatively high efficiency over larger air gaps and with larger horizontal tolerances. Electromagnetic radiation uses microwaves or laser beams to deliver power, but the power level is usually low and there are safety concerns.

Table 1. Common wireless power transfer technologies for electric cars
Technology Typical gap Operation frequency Potential efficiency Main challenge for electric cars
Electromagnetic induction A few mm to several cm Tens of kHz to hundreds of kHz High (>90%) Very small tolerance to horizontal offset and gap variation
Magnetic resonance 50 mm to 250 mm 80 kHz to 90 kHz High (>85%) Coil design, frequency control, safety
Electromagnetic radiation Large (meters) GHz or THz Low to medium Low power, line-of-sight, human exposure

For practical electric car charging, the typical ground clearance between the transmitter coil and the receiver coil is between 50 mm and 250 mm. The required charging power may be as high as several kilowatts for overnight charging, and more than 100 kW for fast charging. The working frequency is commonly in the range from 80 kHz to 90 kHz in order to satisfy electromagnetic compatibility regulations. Magnetic resonant coupling has become the dominant method because it is able to operate in this air-gap range with high efficiency and because the magnetic field coupler can be shaped with ferrite bars and aluminum shielding to meet the spatial constraints of an electric car chassis.

Although magnetic resonant wireless charging is more tolerant to coil displacement than pure inductive charging, the magnetic field distribution is never perfectly uniform. When the receiver coil on an electric car is not located directly over the transmitter coil, the mutual inductance decreases. The output power and transmission efficiency therefore decrease. A high-frequency inverter and rectifier may also detune because of the reflected impedance change. Thus, one of the main design objectives for an electric car charging station is to make the efficiency curve as flat as possible with respect to horizontal deviation. To achieve that objective, the effect of horizontal offset must be measured and quantified accurately.

2. Magnetic Resonant Wireless Charging Architecture for Electric Cars

A typical wireless charging system for an electric car consists of the following stages: three-phase or single-phase alternating-current input from the grid, a power-factor-correction and rectifier stage, a DC-to-DC converter, a high-frequency inverter, the transmitting resonator, the receiving resonator, a secondary rectifier and DC-to-DC converter, and finally the electric car battery. The magnetic link is the core part of the wireless charging system. In the transmitting resonator, an alternating current flows through a coil and creates an alternating magnetic field. The receiving coil, mounted on the lower side of the electric car chassis, intercepts part of the field and induces an alternating voltage. Compensation capacitors are connected in series or parallel with each coil to cancel the reactive impedance at the operating frequency. For electric car charging, series-series compensation is widely used because it behaves as a nearly constant-current source when the battery receives power from the rectifier.

Let me denote the equivalent circuit parameters as follows:

Table 2. Parameters of the equivalent circuit model
Symbol Description Typical unit
\(U_S\) RMS voltage of the high-frequency source V
\(R_S\) Equivalent internal resistance of the source Ω
\(R_1\) Resistance of the transmitting coil Ω
\(L_1\) Self-inductance of the transmitting coil μH
\(C_1\) Compensation capacitance on the transmitting side nF
\(I_1\) Current in the transmitting coil A
\(R_2\) Resistance of the receiving coil Ω
\(L_2\) Self-inductance of the receiving coil μH
\(C_2\) Compensation capacitance on the receiving side nF
\(I_2\) Current in the receiving coil A
\(M\) Mutual inductance between the two coils μH
\(R_L\) Equivalent alternating-current load resistance presented by the battery charger Ω
\(\omega\) Angular frequency of the high-frequency inverter rad/s

For a magnetic resonant wireless power transfer system using series-series compensation, the transmitting coil and the receiving coil are both tuned to the operating frequency. The two resonant loops are coupled through the mutual inductance \(M\). If I write Kirchhoff’s voltage law for each loop, I obtain the following matrix equation:

$$
\begin{bmatrix}
R_S + R_1 + j\omega L_1 + \dfrac{1}{j\omega C_1} & -j\omega M \\[6pt]
-j\omega M & R_2 + R_L + j\omega L_2 + \dfrac{1}{j\omega C_2}
\end{bmatrix}
\begin{bmatrix}
I_1 \\[6pt]
I_2
\end{bmatrix}
=
\begin{bmatrix}
U_S \\[6pt]
0
\end{bmatrix}.
$$

At resonance, the inductive reactance of each coil is equal to the capacitive reactance connected in series with that coil. In an ideal tuned condition I can write:

$$
\omega L_1 = \frac{1}{\omega C_1}, \qquad \omega L_2 = \frac{1}{\omega C_2}.
$$

Thus, the imaginary parts of the primary and secondary impedances vanish under perfectly tuned conditions. The remaining real parts are \(R_1’=R_S+R_1\) in the primary loop, and \(R_2’=R_2+R_L\) in the secondary loop. The current in the receiving coil is induced by the primary current through the mutual inductance. From the secondary-loop equation, I obtain:

$$
-j\omega M I_1 + R_2′ I_2 = 0,
$$

which gives the magnitude relationship:

$$
I_2 = \frac{\omega M}{R_2′}I_1.
$$

The equivalent input impedance seen from the source includes the reflected impedance caused by the receiving coil. At resonance, this input impedance is purely real and equals:

$$
R_{\text{in}} = R_1′ + \frac{\left(\omega M\right)^2}{R_2′}.
$$

The input power from the source, the power delivered to the load, and the overall power transfer efficiency are therefore expressed by the following equations:

$$
P_{\text{in}} = I_1^2 \left( R_1′ + \frac{\omega^2 M^2}{R_2′} \right),
$$

$$
P_L = I_2^2 R_L = \frac{\omega^2 M^2 R_L}{R_2’^2}I_1^2.
$$

Consequently, the efficiency of the resonant wireless transfer link, from the high-frequency source input terminal to the load terminal, can be written as:

$$
\eta =
\frac{P_L}{P_{\text{in}}}
=
\frac{\omega^2 M^2 R_L}
{\left(R_2+R_L\right)\left[\left(R_1+R_S\right)\left(R_2+R_L\right)+\omega^2 M^2\right]}.
$$

This formula is very important for the present study. It shows that the efficiency is not simply a constant value for a given charging system; it depends on the mutual inductance \(M\), the operating frequency \(\omega\), the coil resistances \(R_1\) and \(R_2\), the source internal resistance \(R_S\), and the equivalent load resistance \(R_L\). Among these variables, \(M\) is the parameter that is most strongly affected by the physical position of the electric car relative to the ground pad. A horizontal offset changes the geometric coupling area and the flux linkage between the two coils, so \(M\) decreases. The efficiency \(\eta\) therefore decreases even if the rest of the circuit is unchanged.

3. Factors That Influence Wireless Charging Efficiency

Wireless charging efficiency for an electric car is influenced by both electrical quantities and spatial quantities. The electrical quantities include the switching frequency, the load resistance, the duty cycle of the rectifier, the equivalent series resistance of the capacitors, and the quality factors of the coils. The spatial quantities include the vertical distance between the coils, the horizontal offset in one direction, the horizontal offset in the orthogonal direction, and the angular misalignment between the planes of the two coils. Among the spatial quantities, vertical distance determines the nominal air gap. This gap is physically set by the electric car chassis height. Once an electric car is parked, the chassis height may change only slightly because of the suspension load. Horizontal offset is much more difficult to avoid because the driver cannot always align the car accurately with the charging pad.

From the efficiency formula in the previous section, I can see that \(M\) is the key parameter. The mutual inductance is related to the coil self-inductances \(L_1\) and \(L_2\) through the coupling coefficient:

$$
k = \frac{M}{\sqrt{L_1 L_2}}.
$$

The coupling coefficient typically has a maximum value below 0.5 for large air gaps used in electric car wireless charging. When the horizontal offset is zero and the coils are parallel, the coupling coefficient is at its highest. When the electric car is moved horizontally, the magnetic flux that links the two coils is reduced. The reduction may be modeled by an equivalent decrease in the effective perpendicular area between the coils. The mutual inductance is therefore a function of the horizontal offset \(d\). For small offsets, \(M\) can still be high because the main flux region is broad. For large offsets, most of the magnetic field lines emitted by the transmitter coil no longer pass through the receiving coil. The efficiency curve, as a function of \(d\), often exhibits a plateau near the aligned position and then falls more steeply, depending on the coil geometry.

The influence of load resistance is also connected to horizontal offset because the battery charging status changes with time. A constant-current and constant-voltage charging algorithm changes the equivalent load resistance seen by the receiving coil. At different load resistances, the efficiency curve versus horizontal offset may have different shapes. Moreover, frequency detuning caused by deviation of \(M\) can affect the impedance matching. If the inverter operates with fixed frequency, a large horizontal offset may induce a reactive component that is not perfectly compensated. Many electric car wireless chargers include a communication link between the secondary side and the primary side. The system can adjust the inverter frequency, the DC-DC duty cycle, and the phase shift to track the optimum point. The available control range is limited, however, when the mutual inductance becomes too small.

In static charging, the main practical issue is the final parking position. I summarize the most important parameters and their effect in Table 3.

Table 3. Main factors influencing electric car wireless charging efficiency
Factor Symbol / variable Effect on efficiency Typical compensation
Vertical air gap \(z\) distance between coils Increases air gap reduces coupling and efficiency Height-adjustable receiver or optimized magnetic structure
Horizontal offset \(x\) or \(y\) displacement Reduces mutual inductance and transferred power Parking guidance, coil array, wide magnetic flux
Angular misalignment pitch/yaw/roll angle Distorts flux linkage and may detune resonance Mechanical alignment system
Load resistance \(R_L\) Affects reflected impedance and matching condition Impedance matching network
Frequency \(f=\omega/2\pi\) Off-resonance operation reduces efficiency Frequency tracking control
Coil resistance \(R_1,R_2\) Thermal loss in the conductors Litz wire, good copper fill factor

4. Experimental Setup and Measurement Method

To study the influence of horizontal offset on the wireless charging transmission efficiency of an electric car in practice, I set up a laboratory measurement for a production-oriented wireless charging system. The nominal vertical distance between the transmitter coil and the receiver coil was 12 cm. This gap represents the ground clearance of a typical electric car chassis. The transmitter coil was installed in parallel to the receiver coil, and the angular misalignment was zero throughout the experiment.

I measured two electric quantities during the charging process. On the alternating-current input side, I used a three-phase reference electric energy meter to measure the input electric energy consumed by the wireless charging system. On the direct-current output side, I used a DC reference electric energy meter to measure the electric energy delivered to the simulated electric car battery load. Both meters were calibrated and traceable to national standards. The voltage measurement range of the DC meter covered up to 1000 V, and the current measurement range covered up to 600 A, which was sufficient for the kilowatt-level charging system used in the test.

The wireless charger was operated under the same output control mode for every test. At the beginning of a test, the horizontal offset between the two coils was set to one of the selected values. The charging system was then started. After the startup and communication handshake between the ground-side controller and the electric-car-side controller, the system entered the normal charging state. I recorded the input energy and the DC output energy for the same charging interval. Because the input and DC output energies are measured over the same duration, the ratio of the DC energy to the AC input energy is identical to the ratio of average powers. I therefore define the transmission efficiency as:

$$
\eta = \frac{E_{\text{dc}}}{E_{\text{in}}} \times 100\%,
$$

where \(E_{\text{in}}\) is the electric energy at the AC input terminal and \(E_{\text{dc}}\) is the electric energy at the output of the DC electronics, which represents the energy that enters the battery system of the electric car. The measurement equipment and its function are listed in Table 4.

Table 4. Measurement equipment used in the experiment
Instrument Measured terminal Measured quantity Main measurement range
Three-phase standard reference energy meter AC input of the wireless charging system Input active energy \(E_{\text{in}}\) Three-phase AC voltage and current
DC standard reference energy meter DC output connected to the electric-car-side charger DC output energy \(E_{\text{dc}}\) DC voltage up to 1200 V, current up to 600 A

During the experiment, I kept the vertical gap constant at 12 cm and changed only the horizontal offset. The horizontal offset was applied along the longitudinal direction of the electric-car charging pad; this direction corresponds to the forward-backward parking displacement. The lateral movement in the other horizontal direction was fixed at zero. The offsets tested in this paper were 2.5 cm, 4.5 cm, 5.5 cm, 6 cm, and 7 cm. These values cover the region from near-perfect alignment to a relatively large parking error for an electric car.

5. Experimental Results

First, I performed a baseline measurement at a horizontal offset of 2.5 cm. The input energy measured during the test was 3.91 kWh, while the DC output energy was 2.970 kWh. The resulting overall transmission efficiency was therefore 75.95%. This result may seem lower than the magnetic-coil efficiency because it includes the power consumed by the rectifier, the inverter, the control electronics, the cooling system, and the DC-DC converters. In electric car applications, the wall-to-battery efficiency is the quantity that matters to the driver, because it determines how much energy is drawn from the grid for every kilowatt-hour stored in the electric car battery.

Then I increased the horizontal offset to the other selected values. For each condition, I recorded the input energy and DC output energy, and I computed the efficiency using the formula given above. The complete set of results is listed in Table 5.

Table 5. Transmission efficiency at different horizontal offset values, fixed vertical gap = 12 cm
Horizontal offset \(d\) (cm) Input average power equivalent (kW) DC output average equivalent (kW) Transmission efficiency \(\eta\) (%)
2.5 3.91 2.970 75.95
4.5 3.55 2.605 73.38
5.5 3.43 2.387 69.59
6.0 2.71 1.838 67.82
7.0 2.61 1.764 67.59

The same results can be expressed in a normalized form. I define the normalized efficiency as the ratio of the efficiency at a given offset to the efficiency at the smallest offset of 2.5 cm. The normalized values are useful because they indicate the relative degradation caused by horizontal displacement. Table 6 provides this view.

Table 6. Normalized efficiency and power-loss fraction as a function of horizontal offset
\(d\) (cm) \(\eta\) (%) Normalized \(\eta / \eta_{2.5}\) (pu) Loss fraction \(1-\eta\) (%)
2.5 75.95 1.0000 24.05
4.5 73.38 0.9662 26.62
5.5 69.59 0.9163 30.41
6.0 67.82 0.8930 32.18
7.0 67.59 0.8899 32.41

From these data, I observe that the transmission efficiency decreases as the horizontal offset increases. The relation is not perfectly linear over the whole tested range. When the offset changes from 2.5 cm to 5.5 cm, the offset increases by 3 cm and the efficiency drops by 6.36 percentage points, from 75.95% to 69.59%. The average efficiency-degradation rate in this interval is therefore 2.12 percentage points per centimeter. When the offset changes from 6 cm to 7 cm, the efficiency drops only by 0.23 percentage points, from 67.82% to 67.59%. The average degradation rate in this larger-offset interval is only 0.23 percentage points per centimeter. This indicates that the sensitivity of efficiency to horizontal offset is not constant. At a very large offset, additional horizontal deviation has a much smaller effect than near the more aligned region.

To examine the sensitivity more carefully, I define the average efficiency sensitivity over an interval between two offsets \(d_i\) and \(d_{i+1}\) as:

$$
S_i = \frac{\eta(d_i) – \eta(d_{i+1})}{d_{i+1} – d_i},
$$

with the absolute value taken so that the sensitivity is a positive number having the unit of percentage points per centimeter. Table 7 gives the sensitivity for the intervals between consecutive measured points.

Table 7. Average local sensitivity between consecutive measured horizontal offsets
Offset interval (cm) Change in offset \(\Delta d\) (cm) Change in efficiency \(\Delta \eta\) (percentage points) Average sensitivity (percentage points/cm)
2.5 – 4.5 2.0 2.57 1.29
4.5 – 5.5 1.0 3.79 3.79
5.5 – 6.0 0.5 1.77 3.54
6.0 – 7.0 1.0 0.23 0.23

I note that the local sensitivity data in Table 7 contain some non-monotonic behavior. In particular, the sensitivity in the interval from 4.5 cm to 5.5 cm is larger than the sensitivity in the interval from 2.5 cm to 4.5 cm. This behavior may be caused by the particular shape of the magnetic coupler, by the nonlinear response of the automatic frequency tracking circuit, by slight variations in the switching frequency, by the control of the secondary voltage, or by measurement repeatability limitations. The main and robust qualitative conclusion, however, is that the sensitivity in the far-offset region, represented by the interval between 6 cm and 7 cm, is much smaller than the sensitivity in the near-aligned region represented by the interval between 2.5 cm and 5.5 cm. I summarize this coarse comparison in Table 8.

Table 8. Coarse-region comparison of sensitivity to horizontal offset
Region Offset range (cm) Efficiency decrease (percentage points) Average sensitivity (percentage points/cm)
Near aligned region 2.5 – 5.5 6.36 2.12
Far offset region 6.0 – 7.0 0.23 0.23

If the charging system is well aligned with only 2.5 cm offset, the efficiency is already 75.95%. For an electric car owner, this is a reasonably good grid-to-battery efficiency. At 5.5 cm deviation, the efficiency falls to 69.59%, which means that about 30% of the energy drawn from the grid is lost. At 7 cm offset, the efficiency decreases only to 67.59%, so the extra loss relative to 6 cm offset is very small. The practical implication is that an electric car driver should try to align the car as accurately as possible, but there is no catastrophic drop between 6 cm and 7 cm. The highest sensitivity in this particular charger seems to occur before 6 cm, not beyond 6 cm.

6. Theoretical Interpretation of the Offset Sensitivity

I now discuss why the sensitivity is high at small horizontal offset and low at larger offset. In an ideal system with fixed electrical parameters, the efficiency is a function of mutual inductance \(M\). The mutual inductance is itself a function of the horizontal offset \(d\). Using \(R_1’=R_1+R_S\) and \(R_2’=R_2+R_L\), I can rewrite the efficiency expression in a compact form:

$$
\eta = \frac{K M^2}{D + E M^2},
$$

where \(K = \omega^2 R_L / R_2’\), \(D = R_1′ R_2’\), and \(E = \omega^2\). This expression is monotonic with \(M\); larger mutual inductance always produces higher efficiency under fixed other quantities. The derivative of \(\eta\) with respect to \(M\) is:

$$
\frac{\partial \eta}{\partial M}
=
\frac{2 K D M}{\left(D + E M^2\right)^2}.
$$

The horizontal sensitivity is therefore obtained by applying the chain rule:

$$
\frac{\partial \eta}{\partial d}
=
\frac{\partial \eta}{\partial M}
\frac{\partial M}{\partial d}
=
\frac{2 K D M}{\left(D + E M^2\right)^2}
\frac{\partial M}{\partial d}.
$$

Because \(\partial M/\partial d\) is negative for an electric car moving away from the aligned position, the overall derivative is negative. The magnitude of the derivative depends on the product of the derivative with respect to \(M\) and the derivative of \(M\) with respect to \(d\). The function \(M(d)\) is not linear. For a typical circular or rectangular pad coupler used in electric car wireless charging, the mutual inductance is a smooth, nearly bell-shaped function of horizontal displacement. It has a relatively flat maximum near \(d=0\), followed by a nearly linear transition region, and then a long tail as \(d\) becomes larger. The measured efficiency curve in Table 5 is consistent with this view: the charging efficiency remains above 67% even at 7 cm offset, but the rate of change beyond this point becomes small because the remaining flux linkage is small.

One way to approximate the efficiency curve in the two coarse intervals is to use a linear fit. For the near-aligned region, I can express the efficiency as:

$$
\eta(d) \approx 81.25 – 2.12\,d, \qquad 2.5\text{ cm} \le d \le 5.5\text{ cm},
$$

where \(d\) is in centimeters and \(\eta\) is in percentage. For the far-offset region, using the data between 6 cm and 7 cm yields:

$$
\eta(d) \approx 69.20 – 0.23\,d, \qquad 6.0\text{ cm} \le d \le 7.0\text{ cm}.
$$

These linear approximations are only empirical, and they are not intended to describe the transition between the two regions. However, they clearly show that the slope changes from \(-2.12\) percentage points per centimeter to \(-0.23\) percentage points per centimeter as the horizontal offset grows. In other words, the influence sensitivity of horizontal offset on the wireless charging transmission efficiency gradually weakens with increasing offset.

7. Implications for Electric Car Charging Practice

The results presented above have several useful implications for the deployment of wireless charging systems for electric cars.

First, parking assistance is critical. Since the efficiency penalty is most pronounced in the region between 2.5 cm and 5.5 cm, an electric car driver should aim to stop the car so that the horizontal deviation is no more than approximately 2.5 cm. A driver cannot achieve this accuracy by eye alone. Therefore, wireless charging stations for electric cars should be equipped with visual indicators, ultrasonic sensors, cameras, or an automatic parking system that guides the vehicle to the center of the charging pad. The control system can use the measured mutual inductance or voltage amplitude as an alignment signal and show the driver the direction in which the car should move.

Second, the design of the magnetic coupler can be improved to flatten the mutual-inductance curve. A coupler with a larger effective area, distributed windings, or additional ferrite flux guides can provide a weaker mutual-inductance decay with horizontal offset. Coil arrays and overlapping transmitter coils are another robust solution. In these systems, several primary coils are arranged in a matrix. The detection circuit activates only those coils that overlap the receiver coil of the electric car. Such arrays reduce the horizontal-offset sensitivity but increase the cost and complexity of the power electronics.

Third, the system-level controller can adjust the operating parameters when the horizontal offset is large. Since the reflected impedance changes with horizontal displacement, an impedance-matching network can be inserted between the high-frequency inverter and the transmitter coil. The matching network changes its capacitance or inductance dynamically based on the coupling condition. Frequency tracking is also helpful, but the frequency range is limited by electromagnetic compatibility regulations. Another strategy is to use a DC-DC converter on the secondary side to present an optimal equivalent load resistance to the magnetic link. The optimum load resistance for maximum efficiency is generally not the same at all horizontal offsets, so a well-designed electric car wireless charger should monitor the coil voltages and currents and adjust the duty cycle constantly.

Table 9. Technical strategies to reduce horizontal-offset sensitivity for electric car charging
Strategy Implementation example Advantage Limitation
Driver guidance Camera, radar, magnetic alignment indicator Simple and low-cost Driver-dependent accuracy
Extended coil geometry Large diameter coil, bipolar pad, flux pipe Flatter efficiency plateau More ferrite material and vehicle space
Multi-coil transmitter array Matrix of coil segments activated by a controller Large tolerance in both horizontal directions Many power switches and detection circuits
Impedance matching Capacitor or inductor network controlled by relays or varactors Keeps high efficiency under changing coupling Additional losses and control complexity
Frequency tracking Phase-locked loop or maximum-efficiency search algorithm Adapts to detuning caused by offset Regulatory frequency band limitation
Reconfigurable rectifier Bridge rectifier switchable between half-bridge and full-bridge modes Changes load range seen by the coils Requires communication between primary and secondary

Fourth, the system efficiency measured in Table 5 includes the power losses in all power electronics. The coil-to-coil efficiency may be higher than the measured grid-to-battery efficiency. I did not directly measure the power at the terminals of the coils because the high-frequency loss of the power meters would be difficult to characterize accurately. Nevertheless, the measured values are representative of the total efficiency experienced by the electric car driver, because they are based on the energy flowing into the battery versus the energy purchased from the electricity grid.

Fifth, the vertical distance has a similar but not identical effect as the horizontal offset. Increasing the vertical gap reduces the coupling coefficient and therefore also reduces the mutual inductance. However, the vertical gap is usually fixed during a charging session, whereas the horizontal offset is determined before charging starts. I intentionally kept the vertical distance constant at 12 cm in this experiment. The combined effect of vertical and horizontal displacements should be studied in future work because a loaded electric car with a low chassis may have a smaller gap, while an unloaded sports utility vehicle may have a larger gap.

Sixth, angular misalignment is another important factor. In practice, an electric car may park at an angle relative to the ground pad. The angular rotation between the two coil planes reduces the aligned magnetic flux area. The influence may become even stronger when the angle is combined with a horizontal offset. My experiment used perfectly parallel coils, so the results represent the best-case orientation for a given horizontal offset.

8. Discussion of Uncertainties and Limitations

Every engineering measurement has limitations. In the present study, all tests were performed with the same wireless charging unit, the same cable connection arrangement, and the same load-control algorithm. I did not repeat each offset measurement multiple times under exactly the same thermal conditions. As a result, some of the local sensitivity variation in Table 7 may be caused by temperature drift of the power electronic components, measurement uncertainty of the energy meters, or slight voltage variations of the grid supply.

The energy meter uncertainty is an important source of error. The AC reference meter and the DC reference meter are both calibrated instruments. Their uncertainties are typically of the order of 0.1% to 0.2% of reading for active energy. The effect on the computed efficiency is correspondingly small. However, the power electronic converters also inject harmonics into the grid. The AC reference meter correctly measures active power even under harmonic distortion if it is designed for nonsinusoidal waveforms. If the meter is only calibrated for sinusoidal conditions at the fundamental frequency, harmonic power can cause a noticeable error. I took care to use a true power analyzer for the three-phase input measurement, but the harmonic contribution is not reported separately.

Another limitation is that the input energy values shown in Table 5 are not equal to a fixed target value. The charging system evolved over time and the charging duration may have varied between tests. Because efficiency is defined as the ratio of output energy to input energy during the same charging interval, a different total charging time does not bias the efficiency calculation if the system has reached steady state. If the system was still in the startup phase during a short test, the average efficiency could be slightly lower because the auxiliary power consumption is proportionally larger during startup. To minimize this effect, I waited until the wireless charger recognized the secondary coil and began transferring the nominal charging power before starting the energy integration. This procedure improves the consistency of the measured efficiency.

I also note that the inverter switching frequency may not remain exactly constant when the horizontal offset changes. Many resonant converters use a phase-locked loop or a frequency tracking algorithm to keep the input voltage and current in phase with each other. This control action changes the operating frequency slightly to compensate for detuning. In my efficiency calculation, I ignore the direction and magnitude of the frequency shift. For an electric car charging system, this is acceptable because the grid-to-battery efficiency is not exclusively a magnetic efficiency; it is the integrated system efficiency after the controller adjusts the resonators. The controller is expected to maintain the highest possible efficiency at every offset, and the measured points in Table 5 already include such automatic adjustments.

9. Comparison with Ideal Circuit Models

I can use the measured efficiency values to infer qualitative information about the mutual inductance at different offsets. If the circuit parameters \(R_1’\), \(R_2’\), \(R_L\), and \(\omega\) remained constant, then \(\eta\) would increase monotonically with \(M^2\). Solving the efficiency formula for \(M^2\) gives:

$$
M^2 = \frac{\eta \, R_1′ \, R_2’^2}
{\omega^2\left(R_L – \eta\, R_2’\right)}.
$$

I do not know the exact numerical values of all resistances in the system because the wireless charging unit is a sealed commercial product. However, I can infer that as the horizontal offset increases from 2.5 cm to 7 cm, the mutual inductance decreases because the measured efficiency decreases. The relation between efficiency and \(M\) is nonlinear. When \(M\) is large, the reflected resistance \(U\) in the primary side is large compared with the primary coil resistance; the denominator is dominated by the product \(M^2 R_2’\). In that case, the efficiency can be approximated by:

$$
\eta \approx \frac{R_L}{R_2′} – \frac{R_1′ R_2′ R_L}{\omega^2 M^2 R_2′}.
$$

This approximation shows that the efficiency approaches the upper bound \(R_L/(R_L+R_2)\) when \(M\) is very large. In practice, \(M\) is not large enough to make the secondary copper loss negligible, so the efficiency remains below that upper bound. When \(M\) is small, the denominator is dominated by \(R_1′ R_2’\), because the reflected impedance is negligible. In this small-\(M\) region, the efficiency is approximately proportional to \(M^2\):

$$
\eta \approx \frac{\omega^2 M^2 R_L}{R_1′ R_2’^2}.
$$

Thus, if \(M(d)\) decreases rapidly with large horizontal offset, \(\eta(d)\) decreases even more rapidly because it is proportional to the square of \(M\). My experimental data do not show a rapid drop at large offsets, which suggests that the tested coil pair has a rather wide magnetic field distribution and that \(M(d)\) is still relatively substantial at 7 cm. Consequently, there is a long unsaturated tail in the efficiency curve. This is desirable for electric car charging stations because it avoids sudden charging-power interruption if the driver cannot park precisely.

Another way to view the influence of horizontal offset is through the reflected-impedance perspective. The transmitting side sees the receiving-side impedance reflected through the mutual inductance:

$$
Z_{\text{ref}} = \frac{\omega^2 M^2}{R_2′}.
$$

When the horizontal offset increases, \(Z_{\text{ref}}\) decreases. The primary current therefore changes because the total input impedance increases. This behavior explains why the input power equivalent in Table 5 decreases from 3.91 kW at 2.5 cm to 2.61 kW at 7 cm. The wireless power controller may also reduce the inverter output power to protect the power electronics when the reflected load is low. Hence, the reduction in efficiency is accompanied by an even larger reduction in the amount of power that can be delivered to the electric car battery. This has a practical consequence: if an electric car is parked with a large horizontal offset, not only is a larger fraction of energy wasted, but also the charging time becomes longer because the transferred power is smaller. A table of the reduction in output power can make this phenomenon more visible.

Table 10. Relative output power delivered to the electric-car-side DC bus as a function of horizontal offset
\(d\) (cm) DC output equivalent \(P_{\text{dc}}\) (kW) Relative output power \(P_{\text{dc}} / P_{\text{dc},2.5}\) (pu) Input equivalent \(P_{\text{in}}\) (kW) Relative input power (pu)
2.5 2.970 1.000 3.91 1.000
4.5 2.605 0.877 3.55 0.908
5.5 2.387 0.804 3.43 0.877
6.0 1.838 0.619 2.71 0.693
7.0 1.764 0.594 2.61 0.668

From Table 10, moving from 2.5 cm to 7 cm reduces the DC output power by 40.6%, while the input power is reduced by 33.2%. The output power falls faster than the input power, which confirms that the transmission efficiency is degraded. For an electric car, this means that a horizontal offset of only a few centimeters can increase the required charging time by a substantial amount, even if the charger control unit is able to maintain a constant DC output voltage.

10. Future Research Directions

In the future, I plan to continue this research in several directions. First, I will vary the vertical distance between the primary and secondary coils while keeping the horizontal offset constant. Because the vertical distance of an electric car can change depending on the load and suspension system, the combined two-dimensional efficiency map is important for practical charging pad design. I will measure the efficiency for a full matrix of vertical gaps and horizontal offsets, from almost direct contact to 30 cm gap, and from zero to a large lateral deviation. This map will be used to define a safe parking acceptance region for different electric car models.

Second, I will investigate angular misalignment. The angle between the transmitter and receiver coils can be changed in one or two axes. In real parking, the electric car is aligned roughly parallel to the ground pad, but the suspension height can cause a pitch angle, and the vehicle orientation can cause a yaw angle. Angular misalignment combined with horizontal offset may generate a torque force between the coils and can shift the resonant frequency. The measured data may help improve mechanical alignment mechanisms and reduce driver burden.

Third, I will test different coil shapes and shielding structures. The horizontal sensitivity of a circular pad, a rectangular pad, and a double-D pad are very different. A magnetic coupler with a wider flux path can reduce the sensitivity at small offsets. On the other hand, a large magnetic structure increases the amount of material used and the weight of the ground pad. Therefore, a trade-off exists. I want to find a magnetic coupler design that gives a flat efficiency plateau of at least ±5 cm while maintaining a copper-to-ferrite weight ratio acceptable for a commercial electric car wireless charger.

Fourth, I plan to add dynamic charging experiments. Electric cars may one day be wirelessly charged while moving along the road. In dynamic charging, the horizontal offset is not constant but changes continuously as the car moves. The efficiency versus offset data measured in static tests can be used in a dynamic model that considers the time-varying mutual inductance. The wireless power transmitter must be switched on and off or energized in segments to avoid excessive losses and electromagnetic field leakage. The sensitivity of the system to rapid changes of offset will be studied to guide the design of road-side charging segments.

Fifth, I intend to improve the measurement uncertainty evaluation. I will use multiple repetitions at the same offset, randomize the measurement order, and record the temperature of the power electronics. I will also use a high-precision power analyzer on the high-frequency side if possible. The expanded uncertainty of the efficiency measurement can then be stated with confidence, which is essential for the development of metrological standards for electric car wireless charging stations. Standardized measurement methods are needed because manufacturers of electric car charging systems often quote different efficiency values that may be measured under different conditions. A standard that specifies the vertical gap, horizontal offset, load profile, and measurement instruments will allow fair comparison among products.

Sixth, I will study the interaction between the horizontal offset and the charging control algorithm. Different electric car wireless chargers use different control strategies. Some use phase-shift control at the inverter, some use a DC-DC converter on the primary side, and some use a variable switching frequency. The control bandwidth and algorithm affect the dynamic response and the measured efficiency. By changing the control parameters, I can see whether the system can adapt more effectively to the misalignment and maintain a nearly flat efficiency curve.

11. Conclusions

In this paper, I have presented a study of the influence of horizontal offset on the wireless charging transmission efficiency of an electric car. Using a magnetic resonant coupling system with a fixed vertical distance of 12 cm, I measured the overall AC-input-to-DC-output efficiency for horizontal offsets of 2.5 cm, 4.5 cm, 5.5 cm, 6 cm, and 7 cm. The measured efficiencies were 75.95%, 73.38%, 69.59%, 67.82%, and 67.59%, respectively. These values show that efficiency decreases monotonically with horizontal offset, but the marginal decrease becomes smaller in the far-offset region. The average sensitivity from 2.5 cm to 5.5 cm is approximately 2.12 percentage points per centimeter, while from 6 cm to 7 cm it is approximately 0.23 percentage points per centimeter. Thus, the influence sensitivity of horizontal offset reduces as the offset becomes larger, meaning that the efficiency curve has a relatively steeper section near the alignment boundary and a flatter tail beyond it.

For an electric car charging station, the practical recommendation is that the vehicle should be positioned as accurately as possible. A horizontal offset of less than 5 cm is preferred. Modern parking guidance technologies and automatic alignment systems should be considered, especially for high-power wireless charging. In the future, the combined effect of vertical distance, angular displacement, load variation, frequency control, and coil geometry should be examined. In addition, unified metrological methods and performance evaluation standards for electric car wireless charging should be developed to help manufacturers and users compare the true charging efficiency of different products. The results of this work may serve as a useful reference for future laboratory and field tests of wireless charging systems for electric cars.

Scroll to Top