As electric vehicles demand ever higher safety, energy density, and service reliability, the solid state battery has emerged as one of the most promising next-generation energy storage systems. By replacing flammable liquid electrolytes with solid electrolytes, the solid state battery offers intrinsic safety, high thermal stability, and the potential for high energy density. However, the solid–solid interfaces inside a solid state battery behave very differently from the liquid–solid interfaces in conventional lithium-ion batteries. Interfacial wetting and self-adaptation are greatly reduced, and the contact state between electrode and solid electrolyte directly controls ion transport, charge transfer, and capacity utilization. In addition, volume changes of electrode materials during lithiation and delithiation generate internal stresses that can cause contact loss, solid electrolyte cracking, and impedance rise. Therefore, the performance of a solid state battery is governed not only by material properties and reaction kinetics but also by internal stress distribution, interfacial mechanical states, and external constraint conditions.
Axial pressure is a key external parameter for maintaining solid–solid interfacial contact in a solid state battery. Moderate pressure can compact the electrode/electrolyte interface, increase the real contact area, reduce interfacial impedance, and improve electrochemical performance. However, excessive pressure increases mechanical risk and assembly cost. The axial pressure window must therefore be determined by balancing electrochemical benefits, interfacial contact recovery, mechanical reliability, and pressurization cost. In this work, I establish a coupled electrochemical–mechanical model for a solid state battery that accounts for axial pressure and interfacial contact states. The pressure-dependent interfacial contact state is coupled to reaction kinetics and interfacial mechanical responses. On this basis, I perform multi-criteria optimization of axial pressure by considering usable areal capacity, interfacial contact factor, interfacial stress difference, and pressurization cost. The results provide a methodological reference for pressure regulation and interfacial reliability analysis of multilayer-integrated solid state battery cells for automotive applications.
1. Model Development
Because the in-plane dimensions of an automotive solid state battery are much larger than its thickness, and under ideal stacking conditions edge effects can be neglected, I simplify the cell into a one-dimensional structure along the thickness direction. The simplified model consists of a positive electrode, a solid polymer electrolyte (SPE), and a negative electrode. The positive electrode, SPE, and negative electrode have natural thicknesses \(l_p\), \(l_e\), and \(l_n\), respectively. I neglect in-plane material transport and potential variations and consider only lithium-ion transport along the thickness direction \(x\), interfacial charge transfer, and the corresponding electrochemical responses. The positive electrode, negative electrode, and SPE are treated as continuous homogeneous media, and the cell operates under isothermal conditions.

1.1 Electrochemical Model
The lithium transport in the positive and negative electrodes is described by
$$
\frac{\partial c_k}{\partial t} + \frac{\partial j_k}{\partial x} = 0, \quad k = p, n
$$
$$
j_k = -D_k \left( \frac{\partial c_k}{\partial x} – \frac{\Omega_k c_k}{RT} \frac{\partial \sigma_k}{\partial x} \right) \left( 1 – \frac{c_k}{c_k^{\max}} \right), \quad k = p, n
$$
where \(c_p\) and \(c_n\) are the lithium concentrations in the positive and negative electrodes, respectively; \(c_p^{\max}\) and \(c_n^{\max}\) are the maximum lithium concentrations; \(j_p\) and \(j_n\) are the lithium fluxes; \(D_p\) and \(D_n\) are the lithium diffusion coefficients; \(\Omega_p\) and \(\Omega_n\) are the partial molar volumes; \(\sigma_p\) and \(\sigma_n\) are the hydrostatic stresses; \(R\) is the gas constant; and \(T\) is the temperature.
The ion transport in the SPE is described by a modified Nernst–Planck equation:
$$
\frac{\partial c_e}{\partial t} + \frac{\partial j_e}{\partial x} = 0
$$
$$
j_e = -D_e \left( \frac{\partial c_e}{\partial x} – \frac{\Omega_e c_e}{RT} \frac{\partial \sigma_e}{\partial x} \right)
$$
where \(c_e\) is the lithium concentration in the SPE, \(j_e\) is the lithium flux, \(D_e\) is the lithium diffusion coefficient, \(\Omega_e\) is the partial molar volume, and \(\sigma_e\) is the hydrostatic stress. The diffusion coefficient and partial molar volume of the SPE are given by
$$
D_e = \frac{2 D_+ D_-}{D_+ + D_-}
$$
$$
\Omega_e = \Omega_+ + \Omega_-
$$
where \(D_+\) and \(D_-\) are the cation and anion diffusion coefficients, and \(\Omega_+\) and \(\Omega_-\) are the cation and anion partial molar volumes, respectively.
The reaction current in the SPE satisfies the charge conservation equation:
$$
\frac{\partial i_e}{\partial x} = 0
$$
$$
i_e = -\frac{2 F D_+ D_- c_e}{RT} \frac{\partial \Phi_e}{\partial x} + \frac{F (D_+ – D_-)}{RT} \frac{\partial c_e}{\partial x} – \frac{F (\Omega_+ – \Omega_-) c_e}{RT} \frac{\partial \sigma_e}{\partial x}
$$
At the electrode/electrolyte interfaces, the Butler–Volmer equation is used to describe the electrochemical reaction:
$$
i_k = i_{k,0} \left[ 2 \sinh \left( \frac{F \eta_k}{2RT} \right) \right], \quad k = p, n
$$
$$
i_{p,0} = F k_p (c_p^{\max} – c_{p,s})^{\beta_p} c_{p,s}^{1-\beta_p} c_{e,s}^{1-\beta_p}
$$
$$
i_{n,0} = F k_n (c_n^{\max} – c_{n,s})^{\beta_n} c_{n,s}^{1-\beta_n} c_{e,s}^{1-\beta_n}
$$
where \(i_p\) and \(i_n\) are the reaction current densities at the positive/SPE and negative/SPE interfaces, \(i_{p,0}\) and \(i_{n,0}\) are the reference exchange current densities, \(\eta_p\) and \(\eta_n\) are the interfacial overpotentials, and \(\beta_p\) and \(\beta_n\) are the charge transfer coefficients.
The state of charge (SOC) is defined as the ratio of the current lithium content in the negative electrode to the maximum lithium capacity of the negative electrode:
$$
SOC(t) = \frac{\int c_n(t) dx}{\int c_n^{\max} dx}
$$
The boundary conditions for lithium flux and current are summarized in Table 1.
| Boundary | Boundary condition |
|---|---|
| Positive electrode boundary | \(j_p(x=0) = 0\) |
| Positive/SPE interface | \(j_p(x=l_p) = \frac{i_p}{F}\) |
| Negative electrode boundary | \(j_n(x=l_p+l_e+l_n) = 0\) |
| Negative/SPE interface | \(j_n(x=l_p+l_e) = \frac{i_n}{F}\) |
| Positive/SPE interface | \(j_e(x=l_p) = \frac{i_p D_-}{(D_+ + D_-) F}\) |
| Negative/SPE interface | \(j_e(x=l_p+l_e) = \frac{i_n D_-}{(D_+ + D_-) F}\) |
| Positive/SPE interface | \(i_e(x=l_p) = i_p\) |
| Negative/SPE interface | \(i_e(x=l_p+l_e) = i_n\) |
To analyze the contributions of different physical factors to the cell voltage response, I decompose the cell terminal voltage into five parts: the reference potential term \(V_{\text{ref}}\), the concentration contribution \(V_{\text{con}}\), the stress contribution \(V_{\text{str}}\), the interfacial overpotential contribution \(V_{\text{ove}}\), and the electrolyte potential contribution \(V_{\text{ele}}\). The expressions are given in Table 2.
| Voltage component | Expression |
|---|---|
| Cell voltage | \(V_{\text{cell}} = V_{\text{ref}} + V_{\text{con}} + V_{\text{str}} + V_{\text{ove}} + V_{\text{ele}}\) |
| Reference voltage | \(V_{\text{ref}} = 3.9\ \text{V}\) |
| Concentration contribution | \(V_{\text{con}} = \frac{RT}{F} \ln \left( \frac{c_{e,s} (c_{n,s}^{\max} – c_{n,s}) c_{p,s}}{c_{e,s} (c_{p}^{\max} – c_{p,s}) c_{n,s}} \right)\) |
| Stress contribution | \(V_{\text{str}} = \frac{1}{F} \left[ \Omega_p \sigma_{p,s} – \Omega_n \sigma_{n,s} + \Omega_e (\sigma_{e,s,2} – \sigma_{e,s,1}) \right]\) |
| Overpotential contribution | \(V_{\text{ove}} = \eta_p – \eta_n\) |
| Electrolyte potential contribution | \(V_{\text{ele}} = \Phi_{e,s,1} – \Phi_{e,s,2}\) |
1.2 Mechanical Model
The mechanical response of the solid state battery satisfies the equilibrium equation:
$$
\nabla \cdot \sigma + b = 0
$$
External pressure is applied along the thickness direction \(x\). Considering that the solid state battery is strongly constrained in-plane by the substrate or packaging during automotive operation, I assume zero in-plane strains, i.e., \(\varepsilon_{yy} = \varepsilon_{zz} = 0\). The stress in the thickness direction is determined by the external axial pressure, i.e., \(\sigma_{xx} = -P\). The applied axial pressure \(P\) is the equivalent nominal axial pressure transmitted from the stack structure to the cell, which is applicable under ideal stacking conditions with uniform compression in the central region and negligible edge effects.
Each material region is treated as a homogeneous, isotropic linear elastic solid. During charge and discharge, lithium insertion and extraction cause chemical expansion or contraction, so the total strain consists of elastic strain \(\varepsilon_{\text{elas}}\) and chemical strain \(\varepsilon_{\text{chem}}\):
$$
\varepsilon = \varepsilon_{\text{elas}} + \varepsilon_{\text{chem}}
$$
Using partial molar volume and concentration change to describe chemical strain, the stress state under combined axial pressure and concentration change is given by
$$
\sigma_k = \frac{E_k}{3(1-2\nu_k)} \left( \varepsilon_{xx} + \varepsilon_{yy} + \varepsilon_{zz} \right) + \frac{E_k}{3(1-2\nu_k)} \Omega_k (c_k – c_{k,0}), \quad k = p, e, n
$$
where \(E_p, E_e, E_n\) and \(\nu_p, \nu_e, \nu_n\) are the Young’s moduli and Poisson’s ratios of the positive electrode, SPE, and negative electrode, respectively.
The strains of each material layer during operation are calculated as
$$
\varepsilon_p = -\frac{(1+\nu_p)(1-2\nu_p)}{E_p} P + \frac{1}{3} \Omega_p (c_p – c_{p,0})
$$
$$
\varepsilon_e = -\frac{(1+\nu_e)(1-2\nu_e)}{E_e} P + \frac{1}{3} \Omega_e (c_e – c_{e,0})
$$
$$
\varepsilon_n = -\frac{(1+\nu_n)(1-2\nu_n)}{E_n} P + \frac{1}{3} \Omega_n (c_n – c_{n,0})
$$
The thickness change is calculated as
$$
\Delta l = l_p \varepsilon_p + l_e \varepsilon_e + l_n \varepsilon_n
$$
1.3 Interfacial Contact Model
At the electrode/SPE interfaces of a solid state battery, the contact is solid–solid. Due to surface roughness and material stiffness differences, the real contact area is usually smaller than the nominal contact area. Incomplete interfacial contact affects two processes. First, it reduces the interfacial area available for ion transport and charge transfer, thereby increasing interfacial polarization. Second, the applied nominal axial pressure is not uniformly distributed over the entire nominal area but is mainly carried by the real contact regions, leading to local elastic load amplification at contact spots.
To quantitatively describe the effect of axial pressure on the real contact area at the electrode/SPE interface, I introduce the interfacial contact factor \(\gamma\), defined as the ratio of the real contact area \(A\) to the nominal contact area \(A_0\):
$$
\gamma = \frac{A}{A_0} = \int_{q_L}^{q_0} \frac{1}{\sqrt{\pi}} \exp \left( – \frac{q^2}{4} \right) \frac{E^*}{\sigma_0} C(q) dq
$$
where \(E^*\) is the equivalent modulus determined by the Young’s moduli and Poisson’s ratios of the two contacting materials:
$$
\frac{1}{E^*} = \frac{1-\nu_1^2}{E_1} + \frac{1-\nu_2^2}{E_2}
$$
\(C(q)\), \(q_L\), and \(\xi\) are the power spectral density of surface roughness, the lower wave number limit, and the magnification factor, respectively:
$$
C(q) = 10^m I q
$$
$$
q_L = \frac{2\pi}{A_0}
$$
$$
\xi = \frac{4}{D t}
$$
where \(t\) is the characteristic diffusion time, taken as 3600 s; \(D\) is the diffusion coefficient of Li\(^+\) in the solid electrolyte; and the nominal contact area \(A_0\) is taken as \(1\ \text{cm}^2\). The positive electrode is a continuous dense LiCoO\(_2\) film, while the graphite negative electrode has a more pronounced particulate morphology. Therefore, I classify the positive/SPE interface and negative/SPE interface as “film-type” and “bulk-type” interfaces, respectively. The parameter \(m\) is taken as \(-2.77\) and \(-3.08\), and the parameter \(I\) is taken as \(-9.35\) and \(-6.61\) for the positive and negative interfaces, respectively. \(\sigma_0\) is the nominal contact stress.
To describe the effect of axial pressure on the contact state of the electrode/electrolyte interface, the contact factor \(\gamma\) is introduced into the reference exchange current density:
$$
i_{p,0}^{\text{eff}} = \gamma_1 i_{p,0}
$$
$$
i_{n,0}^{\text{eff}} = \gamma_2 i_{n,0}
$$
In addition to the effect of contact on electrochemistry, the applied nominal axial pressure is mainly carried by the real contact regions, forming local elastic load amplification. Therefore, the effective stresses at the interfaces are corrected as follows:
$$
\sigma_{p,s,1}^{\text{eff}} = \frac{P}{\gamma_1} + \frac{E_p}{3(1-\nu_p)} \Omega_p (c_p – c_{p,0})
$$
$$
\sigma_{e,s,1}^{\text{eff}} = \frac{P}{\gamma_1} + \frac{E_e}{3(1-\nu_e)} \Omega_e (c_e – c_{e,0})
$$
$$
\sigma_{e,s,2}^{\text{eff}} = \frac{P}{\gamma_2} + \frac{E_e}{3(1-\nu_e)} \Omega_e (c_e – c_{e,0})
$$
$$
\sigma_{n,s,2}^{\text{eff}} = \frac{P}{\gamma_2} + \frac{E_n}{3(1-\nu_n)} \Omega_n (c_n – c_{n,0})
$$
The interfacial stress differences are defined as
$$
\Delta \sigma_{s,1}^{\text{eff}} = \sigma_{p,s,1}^{\text{eff}} – \sigma_{e,s,1}^{\text{eff}}
$$
$$
\Delta \sigma_{s,2}^{\text{eff}} = \sigma_{n,s,2}^{\text{eff}} – \sigma_{e,s,2}^{\text{eff}}
$$
These stress differences characterize the degree of in-plane stress mismatch caused by different elastic parameters and chemical strains on both sides of the interface.
Similarly, the hydrostatic stresses at the electrode/SPE interfaces are corrected as
$$
\sigma_{k,s,1}^{\text{eff}} = \frac{P}{\gamma_1} – \frac{\Omega_k E_k}{9(1-\nu_k)} (c_k – c_{k,0}), \quad k = p, e
$$
$$
\sigma_{k,s,2}^{\text{eff}} = \frac{P}{\gamma_2} – \frac{\Omega_k E_k}{9(1-\nu_k)} (c_k – c_{k,0}), \quad k = n, e
$$
1.4 Model Parameters
The main material parameters, initial conditions, and operating conditions used in my calculations are listed in Table 3. The temperature \(T\) is 300 K, and the reference concentration \(c_{\text{ref}}\) is \(1\ \text{mol/m}^3\). The solid state battery is charged at \(1\ \text{A/m}^2\) to a cutoff voltage of 4.03 V and then discharged at the same current density until the SOC reaches 0.05.
| Parameter | Positive electrode (LiCoO\(_2\)) | SPE (PEO-LiPF\(_6\)) | Negative electrode (graphite) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thickness (nm) | 550 | 2000 | 200 |
| Maximum concentration (mol/m\(^3\)) | 23300 | 1500 | 30555 |
| Initial concentration (mol/m\(^3\)) | 22135 | 1200 | 1527.75 |
| Reaction rate constant (m\(^{2.5}\)mol\(^{-0.5}\)s\(^{-1}\)) | \(1.53 \times 10^{-11}\) | – | \(5.03 \times 10^{-11}\) |
| Diffusion coefficient (m\(^2\)/s) | \(1.76 \times 10^{-15}\) | \(2.5 \times 10^{-13}\) (\(D_+\)), \(3 \times 10^{-13}\) (\(D_-\)) | \(8 \times 10^{-14}\) |
| Partial molar volume (m\(^3\)/mol) | \(1.92 \times 10^{-6}\) | \(3.95 \times 10^{-6}\) (\(\Omega_+\)), \(1.46 \times 10^{-4}\) (\(\Omega_-\)) | \(4.17 \times 10^{-6}\) |
| Charge transfer coefficient | 0.5 | – | 0.5 |
| Young’s modulus (GPa) | 70 | 0.5 | 10 |
| Poisson’s ratio | 0.20 | 0.40 | 0.30 |
The model is solved numerically in COMSOL Multiphysics using a fully coupled solver and the MUMPS linear solver. The relative tolerance is 0.005, and the tolerance factor is 0.1. The pressure scanning interval is 0.3 MPa for pressures up to 4 MPa and 1 MPa for pressures above 4 MPa.
1.5 Model Validation
To verify the validity of my model, I compare the terminal voltage–SOC curve with a reference model for the same solid state battery composition under the condition that both interfacial contact factors are set to 1. The results show that the charge–discharge curves agree well in terms of voltage plateau, SOC range, and voltage variation at high SOC. The coefficient of determination \(R^2\) is 0.9931, and the maximum absolute error is 0.0310 V. This indicates that my model effectively captures the key electrochemical behavior of the solid state battery.
Furthermore, previous experimental work reported that the area factor \(n\) describing the relationship between interfacial impedance and contact area ratio is between \(-1.13\) and \(-1.05\). In my model, the contact factor is introduced linearly into the exchange current density, giving an area factor of \(-1\). The interfacial impedance follows an inverse contact area scaling, which is close to the experimental range. For the pressure sensitivity of the charge transfer impedance, taking \(1.2\ \text{MPa}\) and \(0.43\ \text{MPa}\) as an example, experiments reported a normalized impedance of 0.7326, while my simulation gives 0.7041. The small difference supports the reasonableness of my coupling form and the pressure sensitivity of the impedance. Therefore, my model provides a reliable foundation for analyzing axial pressure effects in a solid state battery.
2. Electrochemical and Mechanical Responses under Axial Pressure
Based on the coupled electrochemical–mechanical model and the pressure-dependent interfacial contact model, I analyze the influence of axial pressure on the operating response of the solid state battery. I discuss interfacial contact and electrochemical output, internal stress and interfacial stress difference, and thickness variation to reveal the trade-off between improving interfacial reaction conditions and increasing interfacial mechanical mismatch.
2.1 Effect of Axial Pressure on Interfacial Contact State
As axial pressure increases, the contact factors at both the positive/SPE interface and the negative/SPE interface first increase rapidly and then gradually stabilize. This indicates that axial pressure can increase the effective contact area between the electrode and the SPE and improve the solid–solid interfacial contact state. When the axial pressure is further increased, the contact factor approaches saturation, and further pressurization brings limited contact improvement. For the positive/SPE interface, the contact factor rises rapidly in the low-pressure range and approaches 100% at about 4 MPa. In contrast, the contact factor at the negative/SPE interface responds more slowly to pressure and requires higher axial pressure to approach a fully contacted state.
2.2 Effect of Axial Pressure on Electrochemical Response
For different negative electrode contact factors, the discharge voltage–capacity curves show that as the contact factor increases, the discharge curve shifts toward higher voltage and higher capacity. A smaller contact factor means a smaller effective contact area at the electrode/SPE interface, which limits the effective reaction region for charge transfer. Under constant-current discharge, if the effective reaction area is insufficient, the same applied current must be carried by a smaller interfacial region, increasing interfacial charge transfer polarization and overpotential loss, so the terminal voltage drops faster. Therefore, the releasable capacity is limited at low contact factors. In contrast, a larger contact factor increases the effective interfacial reaction area, reduces interfacial overpotential loss, and allows the solid state battery to maintain a higher terminal voltage at the same discharge capacity, thereby extending the discharge process and increasing the releasable capacity.
I also analyze the cell terminal voltage and its main components as functions of SOC under different axial pressures. The electrolyte potential contribution is very small, so I mainly discuss the concentration contribution \(V_{\text{con}}\), the stress contribution \(V_{\text{str}}\), and the overpotential contribution \(V_{\text{ove}}\). At low pressure, the terminal voltage is generally lower, the voltage drop during discharge is more pronounced, and the operable SOC range is smaller. As axial pressure increases, the terminal voltage curve extends over a wider SOC range, indicating that pressurization improves the capacity utilization of the solid state battery.
Among the components, \(V_{\text{con}}\) mainly changes with SOC, and the curves under different pressures differ only slightly, indicating that axial pressure has a limited direct effect on the concentration term. \(V_{\text{str}}\) increases with SOC, indicating that concentration changes during lithiation and delithiation affect the terminal voltage through chemical strain and stress evolution. At higher pressures, \(V_{\text{str}}\) slightly increases overall, showing that external pressure enhances the stress-related voltage contribution. However, its magnitude is only tens of millivolts, so it remains a correction term in the terminal voltage. In contrast, \(V_{\text{ove}}\) is most sensitive to axial pressure. At low pressure, insufficient interfacial contact leads to a smaller effective reaction area, and a larger interfacial overpotential is required to maintain charge transfer under constant current. Therefore, the overpotential contribution is larger, causing more pronounced polarization loss in the terminal voltage. As axial pressure increases, the contact factor increases, the corrected exchange current density increases, interfacial charge transfer polarization weakens, and the overpotential loss decreases. The solid state battery can then maintain a higher terminal voltage over a wider SOC range.
The absolute magnitude proportions of the concentration, stress, and overpotential contributions at SOC = 0.2 and SOC = 0.45 are calculated as
$$
\text{Proportion}_i = \frac{|V_i|}{|V_{\text{con}}| + |V_{\text{str}}| + |V_{\text{ove}}|} \times 100\%, \quad i = \text{con}, \text{str}, \text{ove}
$$
At both SOC values, as axial pressure increases, the overpotential contribution proportion decreases significantly, while the concentration contribution proportion gradually increases. However, this does not mean that axial pressure significantly enhances the concentration contribution itself. Rather, improved interfacial contact increases the effective reaction area and reduces interfacial charge transfer polarization, thereby lowering the overpotential loss. When the overpotential contribution decreases, the relative proportion of the concentration contribution increases. Therefore, the rise in the concentration contribution proportion mainly reflects the relative contribution change after interfacial polarization is weakened. At SOC = 0.45, the overpotential contribution proportion is larger than at SOC = 0.2, indicating that interfacial polarization has a greater influence on the electrochemical reaction and transport state at higher SOC. Meanwhile, the stress contribution proportion at SOC = 0.45 is higher than at SOC = 0.2, because chemical strain and stress responses caused by concentration changes during lithiation and delithiation increase with SOC. Nevertheless, the stress contribution is significantly lower than the concentration and overpotential contributions at both SOC values, indicating that the stress voltage term mainly plays a corrective role and is not the dominant factor in terminal voltage variation.
In summary, the effect of axial pressure on the electrochemical response of the solid state battery is mainly transmitted through the interfacial contact state. At low pressure, the effective contact area at the electrode/SPE interface is small, the interfacial reaction region is limited, and interfacial charge transfer polarization increases under constant-current discharge. This increases the overpotential loss, lowers the terminal voltage, and limits the operable SOC range and capacity utilization. As axial pressure increases, the contact conditions at the positive/SPE and negative/SPE interfaces improve, the effective interfacial reaction area increases, the corrected exchange current density increases, and the overpotential contribution decreases significantly. The terminal voltage curve shifts toward higher voltage and higher capacity. When the pressure increases from 0.1 MPa to 10 MPa, the improvements in interfacial contact and electrochemical output are relatively obvious. Further pressure increase gradually saturates the contact factor, and the reductions in overpotential and increases in terminal voltage diminish, showing clear marginal diminishing returns. Therefore, from an electrochemical perspective, moderately increasing axial pressure improves interfacial reaction conditions and capacity utilization, but the electrochemical benefit of further pressurization is limited.
2.3 Effect of Axial Pressure on Mechanical Response
The in-layer stress distributions along the thickness direction under different axial pressures and SOC values show that the stress state of each material layer varies significantly with SOC. As SOC increases, the tensile stress in the positive electrode region increases significantly, the compressive stress magnitude in the negative electrode region increases synchronously, and the stress magnitude in the SPE region remains relatively small. This indicates that chemical strain caused by concentration changes during lithiation and delithiation is an important source of in-layer stress evolution. Because the positive electrode, SPE, and negative electrode have different elastic moduli and partial molar volumes, and their lithium concentration changes differ during operation, the chemical strains and constraint responses of each layer are inconsistent, resulting in pronounced interlayer stress differences along the thickness direction.
Compared with the effect of SOC variation, the direct effect of axial pressure on the in-layer stress distribution at the same SOC is relatively limited. When the pressure increases from 0.1 MPa to 1 MPa, the stress distribution changes only slightly. When the pressure further increases to 10 MPa and 50 MPa, the compressive stress magnitudes in the SPE and negative electrode regions increase slightly, while the tensile stress magnitude in the positive electrode region remains almost unchanged. These results indicate that the in-layer stress response is not controlled solely by axial pressure but is determined jointly by external pressure and concentration-induced strain. It is worth noting that at low pressure, the operable SOC range is narrower, whereas higher pressure improves interfacial contact and reduces polarization loss, allowing the solid state battery to enter a higher SOC range. At high SOC, chemical strain caused by concentration changes develops further, and the difference between positive electrode tensile stress and negative electrode compressive stress becomes more obvious. Therefore, the effect of axial pressure on mechanical response is not only the direct compression of the external pressure on the in-layer stress but also the enhancement of the stress state at high SOC after the operable SOC range is expanded.
The maximum interfacial stress differences at the positive/SPE and negative/SPE interfaces during operation increase overall as the axial pressure increases from 0.1 MPa to 50 MPa, but the growth trend has distinct stages. In the low-pressure range, the interfacial stress difference rises rapidly, and then the growth gradually slows. This behavior can be explained from two aspects: the actual load-bearing state of the interface and the development of chemical strain at high SOC. On the one hand, under incomplete interfacial contact, the real contact area is smaller than the nominal contact area, and the applied nominal pressure is mainly carried by the real contact regions, increasing the actual load level in the contact regions. As axial pressure increases, the contact factor increases, the effective contact area increases, and the local load concentration caused by incomplete contact is alleviated, so the growth of the interfacial stress difference slows in the medium- and high-pressure ranges. On the other hand, the external pressure itself continues to increase, and higher pressure improves interfacial contact and reduces polarization loss, allowing the solid state battery to enter a higher SOC range. At high SOC, chemical strain caused by concentration changes develops further. Therefore, the maximum interfacial stress difference still increases overall with axial pressure. Comparing the two interfaces, the maximum interfacial stress difference at the positive/SPE interface is generally higher than that at the negative/SPE interface and maintains a more obvious growth trend in the high-pressure range, indicating that the positive electrode side is the more significant interfacial mechanical response difference location in my model.
To analyze the overall thickness fluctuation during operation, I define the maximum thickness change \(H\) as the difference between the maximum and minimum total thickness of the solid state battery during operation under a given pressure:
$$
H(P) = \max_t l(P,t) – \min_t l(P,t)
$$
where \(l(P,t)\) is the cell thickness at time \(t\) under applied pressure \(P\). As axial pressure increases, \(H\) increases overall, but the change is mainly concentrated in the low-pressure range. When the pressure increases from 0.1 MPa to about 4 MPa, \(H\) increases from about 4 nm to about 8 nm, a relatively obvious increase. Further pressure increase makes the curve gradually flatten, and the difference in thickness variation amplitude among different pressure conditions in the high-pressure range decreases significantly. This is related to the effect of axial pressure on interfacial contact and capacity utilization. At low pressure, insufficient interfacial contact limits the operable SOC range, and the concentration change caused by lithiation and delithiation is small, so \(H\) is low. As pressure increases, the interfacial contact state improves, overpotential loss decreases, and the solid state battery can operate over a wider SOC range. The concentration change and corresponding chemical strain amplitude increase, so \(H\) increases significantly. When pressure further increases, the improvement in interfacial contact and electrochemical performance gradually saturates, the expansion of the operable SOC range is limited, and the thickness fluctuation caused by concentration changes also tends to flatten. Overall, although \(H\) increases noticeably in the low-pressure range, its absolute magnitude remains on the nanometer scale, which is small relative to the total cell thickness. This indicates that the thickness breathing response reflects the operating deformation change caused by pressure but is not the main factor limiting further pressurization in the high-pressure range.
In summary, the effect of axial pressure on the mechanical response of the solid state battery is mainly reflected in three aspects: in-layer stress distribution, interfacial stress difference, and overall thickness variation. First, the in-layer stress state is closely related to SOC. As SOC increases, the tensile stress in the positive electrode region increases, and the compressive stress magnitude in the negative electrode region increases, indicating that concentration changes and the resulting chemical strain are important sources of in-layer stress evolution. Compared with SOC variation, the direct effect of axial pressure on the in-layer stress distribution at the same SOC is relatively limited. Second, as axial pressure increases, the maximum interfacial stress differences at the positive/SPE and negative/SPE interfaces increase overall, with the positive/SPE interface showing a higher stress difference level. This indicates that high pressure improves solid–solid interfacial contact but also enhances the stress response difference between the two sides of the interface. Finally, the maximum thickness change \(H\) increases overall with pressure and increases noticeably in the low-pressure range. When pressure continues to increase, \(H\) gradually flattens, indicating that axial pressure can change the thickness response during operation, but the absolute magnitude of this change is small and is not the main limiting factor in the high-pressure range. Therefore, the effect of axial pressure on the mechanical response cannot be understood only as direct external compression; it should also consider the indirect effect on the high-SOC stress state after improving interfacial contact and expanding the operable SOC range. Compared with overall thickness variation, the interfacial stress difference continues to increase as pressure rises, better reflecting the mechanical response inconsistency between the two sides of the electrode/SPE interface under high pressure. Therefore, it should be regarded as an important mechanical factor limiting further pressure increase.
2.4 Mesh, Time-Step, and Parameter Sensitivity Analysis
To further verify the reliability of my simulation results, I conducted mesh independence verification, maximum time-step independence verification, and parameter sensitivity analysis.
I divided the model into five different mesh refinement levels and performed simulations. The number of mesh elements in each domain for each mesh scheme is listed in Table 4. For different mesh schemes, the maximum voltage deviation of the charge–discharge curves is only 0.274 mV, and the maximum deviation of the maximum stress difference at the positive/SPE interface is only 0.111 MPa. These deviations are small relative to the magnitudes of the original data. Therefore, the mesh scheme has little effect on the simulation results. I adopted mesh scheme M1 with uniform mesh distribution within each layer.
| Scheme | Positive electrode | SPE | Negative electrode | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| M1 | 14 | 18 | 10 | 42 |
| M2 | 21 | 27 | 15 | 63 |
| M3 | 35 | 45 | 25 | 105 |
| M4 | 70 | 90 | 50 | 210 |
| M5 | 140 | 180 | 100 | 420 |
I also used five different maximum time steps to simulate the model. The maximum voltage deviation of the charge–discharge curves is 0.53 mV, and the maximum interfacial stress difference is almost identical under different time steps. The effect of time step on the results is also small. To balance computational cost and accuracy, I set the maximum time step to 2 s.
| Scheme | Maximum time step |
|---|---|
| T1 | 2 s |
| T2 | 1 s |
| T3 | 0.5 s |
| T4 | 0.25 s |
| T5 | 0.125 s |
I also performed a wide-range sensitivity analysis of the parameters \(m\) and \(I\) to investigate the model behavior under different interfacial roughness parameters. The parameter settings are listed in Table 6. As \(m\) decreases and \(I\) increases, the interface becomes rougher, and the contact factors at both the positive/SPE and negative/SPE interfaces recover more slowly with increasing applied pressure.
| Positive/negative interface \(m\) | Positive/negative interface \(I\) |
|---|---|
| \(-2.77/-3.08\) | \(-9.35/-6.61\) |
| \(-2.67/-2.98\) | \(-10.35/-7.61\) |
| \(-2.72/-3.03\) | \(-9.85/-7.11\) |
| \(-2.82/-3.13\) | \(-8.85/-6.11\) |
| \(-2.87/-3.18\) | \(-8.35/-5.61\) |
Under different roughness parameters, the charge–discharge curves show some differences at low pressure but are similar at medium and high pressures. As \(m\) decreases and \(I\) increases, the interfacial roughness increases, and the operable SOC range at the same pressure becomes smaller. Even with different roughness parameters, the conclusion that the operable SOC range increases with applied pressure still holds. Combined with the small effect of different roughness parameters on the charge–discharge curves at medium and high pressures, I conclude that although different roughness parameters affect the contact response and related index values in the low-pressure range, they do not change the core qualitative conclusions of this work. The maximum stress difference at the positive/SPE interface decreases overall as the interfacial roughness increases, and the difference among different roughness parameters is relatively large in the low-pressure range and gradually decreases as the applied pressure increases. However, for different roughness parameters, the maximum interfacial stress difference monotonically increases with external pressure and the growth rate slows, meaning that the roughness parameters do not affect the general trend of the maximum interfacial stress difference with external pressure.
3. Multi-Criteria Evaluation and Optimization of the Axial Pressure Window
Axial pressure is an important operating parameter for regulating the solid–solid interfacial contact state of a solid state battery. Its reasonable value directly affects interfacial electrochemical reactions, ion transport, and interlayer mechanical reliability. Based on the axial pressure response analysis, axial pressure has a dual effect on the solid state battery. Therefore, the selection of axial pressure cannot be based solely on electrochemical performance improvement or a single mechanical constraint. It should comprehensively balance interfacial contact improvement, electrochemical performance enhancement, interfacial stress difference control, and pressurization cost. Based on this understanding, I established a multi-criteria evaluation and optimization method for the axial pressure window.
3.1 Multi-Criteria Evaluation and Optimization Method
I selected the usable areal capacity \(Q\), the minimum interfacial contact factor \(\gamma_{\min}\), the maximum interfacial stress difference \(S\), and the pressurization cost \(P\) to construct the multi-criteria evaluation method. \(Q\) measures the capacity utilization capability, \(\gamma_{\min}\) measures the contact recovery degree of the worse of the two electrode/SPE interfaces, \(S\) measures the stress response difference between the two sides of the interface and the corresponding local mechanical risk, and \(P\) measures the pressure constraint cost brought by applying and maintaining external pressure. The maximum thickness change \(H\) is mainly used to measure the overall thickness response during operation. Since the absolute magnitude of \(H\) is very small relative to the total cell thickness, it is difficult for \(H\) to be the dominant constraint determining the axial pressure window compared with capacity utilization, interfacial contact recovery, and effective interfacial stress difference. If \(H\) were directly included as an optimization objective and normalized, the small actual thickness fluctuation differences might be artificially amplified, making the comprehensive loss function overly sensitive to this auxiliary structural response index. Therefore, I treat \(H\) as a supplementary analysis quantity for the overall thickness response under axial pressure and do not include it in the main optimization objective function.
To establish a quantitatively computable comprehensive loss function, I mathematically characterize the above evaluation quantities and eliminate the influence of dimensions and numerical ranges through non-dimensionalization. The definitions and normalized forms of usable areal capacity, interfacial contact factor, effective interfacial stress difference, and pressurization cost are given below.
Under constant-current discharge, the areal capacity of the solid state battery is calculated from the discharge current density and cutoff time:
$$
Q(P) = \frac{i_{\text{app}} t_{\text{cut}}(P)}{3600}
$$
where \(Q(P)\) is the areal capacity under pressure \(P\) in Ah/m\(^2\), \(i_{\text{app}}\) is the discharge current density of 1 A/m\(^2\), and \(t_{\text{cut}}(P)\) is the single discharge time in seconds. The normalized capacity index is
$$
Q_n(P) = \frac{Q(P) – Q_{\min}}{Q_{\max} – Q_{\min}}
$$
The contact factor of the worse interface is expressed as
$$
\gamma_{\min}(P) = \min \{ \gamma_{s,1}(P), \gamma_{s,2}(P) \}
$$
where \(\gamma_{s,1}(P)\) and \(\gamma_{s,2}(P)\) are the contact factors at the positive/SPE and negative/SPE interfaces under axial pressure \(P\), respectively. The normalized contact factor of the worse interface is
$$
\gamma_{\min,n}(P) = \frac{\gamma_{\min}(P) – \gamma_{\min}^{\min}}{\gamma_{\min}^{\max} – \gamma_{\min}^{\min}}
$$
The maximum stress difference of the worse interface is
$$
S(P) = \max \{ |\sigma_{p,s,1}^{\text{eff}} – \sigma_{e,s,1}^{\text{eff}}|, |\sigma_{n,s,2}^{\text{eff}} – \sigma_{e,s,2}^{\text{eff}}| \}
$$
The corresponding normalized maximum interfacial stress difference is
$$
S_n(P) = \frac{S(P) – S_{\min}}{S_{\max} – S_{\min}}
$$
For automotive stack structures, a higher axial pressure usually means higher preload requirements, stricter assembly tolerance control, and higher structural stiffness and constraint requirements. Therefore, the normalized pressure index is used as the pressurization cost:
$$
P_n(P) = \frac{P – P_{\min}}{P_{\max} – P_{\min}}
$$
where \(P_{\min} = 0.1\ \text{MPa}\) and \(P_{\max} = 50\ \text{MPa}\).
Based on the above normalized indices, I establish the comprehensive loss function for axial pressure:
$$
J(P) = J_Q + J_\gamma + J_S + J_P
$$
The components are
$$
J_Q = \omega_Q [1 – Q_n(P)]^2
$$
$$
J_\gamma = \omega_\gamma [1 – \gamma_{\min,n}(P)]^2
$$
$$
J_S = \omega_S S_n(P)
$$
$$
J_P = \omega_P P_n(P)
$$
where \(\omega_Q, \omega_\gamma, \omega_S, \omega_P\) are the weight coefficients for areal capacity, interfacial contact, interfacial stress difference, and pressurization cost, respectively. Under a given weight scheme, the optimal axial pressure is expressed as
$$
P^* = \arg \min_{P_{\min} \le P \le P_{\max}} J(P)
$$
To examine the influence of different engineering preferences on the optimal pressure, I set three weight schemes: a performance-priority scheme, a balanced scheme, and a conservative scheme. The performance-priority scheme increases the weights of capacity and interfacial contact recovery for conditions that focus more on electrochemical performance improvement. The balanced scheme simultaneously considers capacity, contact, interfacial mechanical risk, and pressurization cost. The conservative scheme increases the weights of effective interfacial stress difference and pressurization cost for conditions that focus more on mechanical reliability and assembly constraints. The weight coefficients are listed in Table 7.
| Scheme | \(\omega_Q\) | \(\omega_\gamma\) | \(\omega_S\) | \(\omega_P\) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Performance-priority | 0.35 | 0.40 | 0.15 | 0.10 |
| Balanced | 0.30 | 0.35 | 0.20 | 0.15 |
| Conservative | 0.25 | 0.30 | 0.25 | 0.20 |
Since the comprehensive loss function \(J(P)\) is composed of multiple outputs from the COMSOL electrochemical–mechanical coupled model, it is difficult to obtain an explicit analytical expression. To directly perform derivative-free bounded search based on the full model response, I use particle swarm optimization (PSO) for the axial pressure variable. Each candidate pressure calls COMSOL again for a new solution without using interpolation surrogates. The position of each particle represents a candidate axial pressure value. In the \(k\)-th iteration, the position and velocity of the \(i\)-th particle are denoted as \(P_i^k\) and \(v_i^k\). The velocity and position update formulas are
$$
v_i^{k+1} = \omega v_i^k + c_1 r_1 (p_i^k – P_i^k) + c_2 r_2 (g^k – P_i^k)
$$
$$
P_i^{k+1} = P_i^k + v_i^{k+1}
$$
where \(p_i^k\) is the individual best pressure of the \(i\)-th particle, \(g^k\) is the global best pressure of the swarm, \(\omega\) is the inertia weight, \(c_1\) and \(c_2\) are the individual and social learning factors, and \(r_1\) and \(r_2\) are random numbers between 0 and 1. In each iteration, the pressure corresponding to the particle is input into the evaluation process to obtain \(Q_n(P_i^k)\), \(\gamma_{\min,n}(P_i^k)\), \(S_n(P_i^k)\), and \(P_n(P_i^k)\), which are substituted into the comprehensive loss function to calculate \(J(P_i^k)\). If the loss function of the current pressure is smaller than the historical best value of the particle, the individual best pressure is updated. If it is smaller than the current global best value, the global best pressure is updated. To avoid out-of-bounds pressure search, the updated particle position is limited within \([P_{\min}, P_{\max}]\), and a velocity upper limit is set to avoid excessive single-step search. I use 15 particles, 9 iterations, an inertia weight of 0.65, individual and social learning factors of 1.45, and a velocity upper limit of 8 MPa. To further confirm the optimization results, I perform a local scan around the preliminary optimal pressure obtained by PSO to determine the minimum position of the comprehensive loss function. The final optimal pressure for each scheme is determined by the minimum of the corresponding comprehensive loss function.
To verify that the optimization results do not vary significantly with a specific algorithm, I also use a deterministic method combining full-range coarse scanning and partition-based one-dimensional bounded optimization. The loss function and weight factors are consistent with the PSO optimization. To obtain the objective function under continuous pressure, I use shape-preserving piecewise cubic Hermite interpolation for \(Q_n(P)\), \(\gamma_{\min,n}(P)\), and \(S_n(P)\), while \(P_n(P)\) is still calculated analytically. This method reduces the possibility of interpolation overshoot in the low-pressure region where the contact factor changes rapidly. Then I perform a full-range coarse scan in the range 0.1–50 MPa with a maximum interval of 1 MPa. The coarse scan pressure set is
$$
\Omega_c = \{0.1\ \text{MPa}, 1.1\ \text{MPa}, \ldots, 49.1\ \text{MPa}, 50\ \text{MPa}\}
$$
For any scan node, if
$$
J(P_i) \le \min \{ J(P_{i-1}), J(P_{i+1}) \}
$$
then the node is taken as a local minimum candidate, and its adjacent two nodes form a candidate interval. For each candidate interval, a one-dimensional bounded optimization method is used for refined search:
$$
P_i^* = \arg \min_{P \in [P_{i-1}, P_{i+1}]} J(P)
$$
The MATLAB function fminbnd is used to implement the one-dimensional bounded optimization. This function combines golden-section search and parabolic interpolation to find the minimum of the objective function within a given pressure interval. After completing all candidate interval searches, the optimization results of each interval are compared with the pressure upper and lower bounds:
$$
P^* = \arg \min_{P \in \{P_{\min}, P_{\max}, P_1^*, P_2^*, \ldots, P_m^*\}} J(P)
$$
where \(m\) is the number of local minimum candidate intervals obtained by the coarse scan. I set the axial pressure convergence tolerance of fminbnd to \(10^{-3}\ \text{MPa}\), the maximum number of iterations to 200, and the maximum number of objective function evaluations to 500.
3.2 Optimization Results and Analysis of the Axial Pressure Window
I first present the optimization results of the two algorithms under different weight schemes and then determine the trade-off optimal pressure window under the current material system parameters and ideal layered structure.
The normalized evaluation indices change with axial pressure. \(Q_n\) and \(\gamma_{\min,n}\) both increase with pressure, but their growth rates differ: \(Q_n\) rises rapidly in the low-pressure range and flattens after about 10 MPa, while \(\gamma_{\min,n}\) continues to rise, and its overall recovery process is slower. This indicates that the contact improvement of the worse interface requires higher pressure to be gradually promoted. \(S_n\) and \(P_n\), as cost-type indices, continuously increase with pressure. \(P_n\) grows linearly, and \(S_n\) still maintains an upward trend in the medium- and high-pressure ranges. These results indicate that as axial pressure increases, capacity utilization and interfacial contact improvement show diminishing returns, while interfacial stress difference and pressurization cost continue to accumulate. Therefore, it is difficult to simultaneously achieve optimal electrochemical benefit and mechanical/engineering cost control only by increasing pressure.
Based on the comprehensive loss function, I optimize the axial pressure for the performance-priority, balanced, and conservative schemes. The optimization results obtained by PSO are listed in Table 8.
| Optimization scheme | Trade-off optimal pressure |
|---|---|
| Performance-priority | 15.8 MPa |
| Balanced | 12.2 MPa |
| Conservative | 10.0 MPa |
The optimization results obtained by the direct coarse scan combined with partition-based one-dimensional bounded optimization are listed in Table 9. The differences between the two algorithms are no more than 0.2 MPa for all three schemes, so the optimization results do not change significantly with the specific algorithm. If the direct scanning method is used, a large number of calculation nodes are required for high accuracy, resulting in a large computational cost. Compared with the one-dimensional optimization method combining full-range coarse scanning and partition-based bounded optimization, PSO does not have advantages in computational cost and algorithm complexity. However, as a derivative-free bounded swarm search method, it does not rely on interpolation surrogates or objective function gradients and is suitable for models like mine where analytical gradients are difficult to obtain. Moreover, if multiple design variables such as end-plate stiffness, preload displacement, or material parameters are further introduced and the problem is extended to a multivariable or multi-objective problem, the applicability of PSO-type algorithms will become more obvious. Based on these considerations, I use the PSO results in the following discussion.
| Optimization scheme | Trade-off optimal pressure |
|---|---|
| Performance-priority | 15.7 MPa |
| Balanced | 12.4 MPa |
| Conservative | 9.8 MPa |
Under the three weight schemes, the comprehensive loss function achieves relatively good results in the medium pressure range. In the low-pressure range, insufficient interfacial contact leads to low capacity and contact recovery. As pressure increases, capacity and contact factor increase significantly, and the comprehensive loss function decreases rapidly. When pressure continues to increase, capacity and contact improvement gradually saturate, while the maximum interfacial stress difference and pressurization cost continue to increase, causing the comprehensive loss function to rise again. As the evaluation preference shifts from electrochemical performance to interfacial mechanical reliability and pressure constraint cost, the trade-off optimal pressure gradually moves toward the low-pressure side.
The key indices under each optimization scheme are listed in Table 10.
| Scheme | \(Q\) (Ah/m\(^2\)) | \(\gamma_{\min}\) | \(S\) (MPa) | \(P\) (MPa) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Performance-priority | 0.1368 | 0.8079 | 579.25 | 15.8 |
| Balanced | 0.1342 | 0.7471 | 574.93 | 12.2 |
| Conservative | 0.1316 | 0.6971 | 569.51 | 10.0 |
Under the balanced scheme, the comprehensive loss function and the contributions of its components change with axial pressure. In the low-pressure range, the capacity term \(J_Q\) and the contact term \(J_\gamma\) dominate, indicating that the comprehensive loss mainly comes from insufficient capacity output and inadequate interfacial contact. As axial pressure increases, \(J_Q\) and \(J_\gamma\) decrease rapidly. When pressure further increases, the capacity term is already close to a low level, and the decrease in the contact term gradually slows, while the interfacial stress difference term \(J_S\) and the pressurization cost term \(J_P\) continue to increase. The comprehensive loss function \(J\) no longer continues to decrease. Under the balanced scheme, the comprehensive loss function achieves a relatively good result at about 12.2 MPa, indicating that this pressure achieves a relative balance among capacity improvement, contact recovery, interfacial stress difference, and pressurization cost.
To further illustrate the diminishing returns and accumulating costs in axial pressure regulation, I construct marginal benefit and marginal cost based on the normalized indices. The electrochemical benefit from capacity improvement and interfacial contact recovery is defined as
$$
B(P) = \frac{Q_n(P) + \gamma_{\min,n}(P)}{2}
$$
The cost of applying pressure, considering the maximum interfacial stress difference and pressurization demand, is defined as
$$
C(P) = \frac{S_n(P) + P_n(P)}{2}
$$
Based on these definitions, I calculate the marginal benefit \(\Delta B\) and marginal cost \(\Delta C\) when the applied axial pressure increases by 1 MPa. In the low-pressure range, the marginal electrochemical benefit of increasing axial pressure is high. As pressure continues to increase, the marginal electrochemical benefit decreases rapidly and gradually approaches zero after the medium pressure range. In contrast, the marginal mechanical/pressure cost persists over a wide pressure range, reflecting that the maximum interfacial stress difference and pressurization demand continue to accumulate with increasing pressure. Around 12 MPa, the electrochemical benefit and pressure cost are close, indicating that this pressure can better reflect the trade-off between performance improvement and pressure cost. When pressure continues to increase, the additional electrochemical benefit is limited while the cost term continues to increase. At this stage, the cost term is always greater than the benefit term, further verifying the dual effect of axial pressure on the solid state battery.
When the applied axial pressure reaches about 10 MPa, the improvement in usable areal capacity gradually slows, the interfacial contact factor continues to increase but at a decreasing rate, and the maximum interfacial stress difference and pressurization cost continue to increase. In the medium pressure range of about 10–16 MPa, the marginal benefit \(\Delta B\) gradually decreases and approaches the marginal cost \(\Delta C\), indicating that the electrochemical benefit and the cost of applying pressure are relatively close in this range. When the pressure exceeds about 16 MPa, the marginal cost \(\Delta C\) is higher than the marginal benefit \(\Delta B\), indicating that the capacity improvement and interfacial contact improvement from further pressurization are no longer sufficient to offset the increase in maximum interfacial stress difference and pressurization cost. The trade-off optimal pressures obtained from the three representative weight schemes are 15.8 MPa, 12.2 MPa, and 10.0 MPa, all located in the above medium pressure range. Combining the variation patterns of each index, the relationship between marginal benefit and marginal cost, and the multi-scheme optimization results, I take 10.0–15.8 MPa as the trade-off optimal axial pressure window, with 12.2 MPa as the trade-off optimal pressure under the balanced scheme.
To further examine the stability of the above trade-off optimal pressure window under a wider range of weight variations, I conduct sensitivity analysis on the component weights, normalization intervals, loss function forms, and charge–discharge current density.
First, I randomly generate multiple weight combinations over a wider weight range and calculate the corresponding optimal axial pressure. The weight ranges are
$$
0.18 \le \omega_Q \le 0.45
$$
$$
0.20 \le \omega_\gamma \le 0.50
$$
$$
0.08 \le \omega_S \le 0.35
$$
$$
0.05 \le \omega_P \le 0.30
$$
The random weight perturbation is sampled from a Dirichlet distribution with parameter vector \((3,3,2,2)\) under the constraint that the sum of the four weights is 1, and rejection screening is performed according to the above inequalities until 5000 valid samples are obtained. The random seed is 20260617. The results show that the optimal pressure is mainly distributed in the medium pressure range. The 5%, 25%, 50%, 75%, and 95% quantiles of the optimal pressure are 7.12 MPa, 9.10 MPa, 11.10 MPa, 13.81 MPa, and 17.92 MPa, respectively. The median of the trade-off optimal pressure is 11.10 MPa, which is close to the trade-off optimal pressure of 12.2 MPa obtained under the balanced scheme. Meanwhile, 63.56% of the 5000 samples are distributed within the trade-off optimal pressure window, indicating that the medium pressure window obtained in this work is not accidentally determined by a single weight combination but has a certain robustness under weight perturbations.
Second, I perform optimization for three different normalization intervals: the original scheme, an upper-limit-extended-by-20% scheme, and a 5%–95% quantile interval. The original scheme has a normalization interval of [0.1 MPa, 50 MPa], the upper-limit-extended scheme has [0.1 MPa, 60 MPa], and the 5%–95% quantile interval is [2.6 MPa, 47.5 MPa]. The corresponding weights for calculating the trade-off optimal axial pressure window remain unchanged. The optimization results are listed in Table 11.
| Normalization interval | Trade-off optimal pressure window |
|---|---|
| Original scheme | 10.0–15.8 MPa |
| Upper limit extended by 20% | 10.8–17.1 MPa |
| 5%–95% quantile interval | 11.8–17.9 MPa |
The results show that although the trade-off optimal pressure windows obtained under different normalization intervals shift to some extent, they are all concentrated in the medium pressure range and overlap significantly with the original pressure window. Therefore, the pressure window obtained in this work has a certain robustness to changes in the normalization interval.
Third, I perform optimization for different loss function forms. In addition to the original loss function, I add a fully quadratic form, an exponential form, and a normalized Huber loss function with threshold parameter \(\delta = 0.5\).
The fully quadratic loss function changes \(J_S\) and \(J_P\) in the original scheme to \(\omega_S S_n^2(P)\) and \(\omega_P P_n^2(P)\), while the other terms remain unchanged.
The normalized Huber loss function with threshold parameter \(\delta = 0.5\) is
$$
J(P) = \omega_Q H(1 – Q_n(P)) + \omega_\gamma H(1 – \gamma_{\min,n}(P)) + \omega_S H(S_n(P)) + \omega_P H(P_n(P))
$$
$$
H(x) = \begin{cases}
\frac{2}{3} x, & 0 \le x \le 0.5 \\
\frac{4}{3} x – \frac{1}{3}, & 0.5 < x \le 1
\end{cases}
$$
The exponential loss function is
$$
J(P) = \omega_Q E(1 – Q_n(P)) + \omega_\gamma E(1 – \gamma_{\min,n}(P)) + \omega_S E(S_n(P)) + \omega_P E(P_n(P))
$$
$$
E(x) = \frac{1 – e^{-x}}{1 – e^{-2}}
$$
The optimization results for different loss function forms are listed in Table 12.
| Loss function form | Trade-off optimal pressure window |
|---|---|
| Original form | 10.0–15.8 MPa |
| Fully quadratic form | 11.5–16.7 MPa |
| Normalized Huber form | 12.8–17.5 MPa |
| Exponential form | 11.0–18.6 MPa |
The results show that the trade-off optimal pressure windows obtained under different loss function forms are all in the medium pressure range and overlap significantly with the original pressure window. Although the window endpoints change to some extent, the overall pressure range does not deviate significantly, indicating that the pressure window obtained in this work has a certain robustness to the loss function form.
Finally, to investigate the influence of different charge–discharge current magnitudes on the optimal pressure window, I perform optimization for different charge–discharge current densities. The optimization results are listed in Table 13.
| Charge–discharge current | Trade-off optimal pressure window |
|---|---|
| Original scheme \(1\ \text{A/m}^2\) | 10.0–15.8 MPa |
| \(0.135\ \text{A/m}^2\) | 8.8–14.0 MPa |
| \(0.270\ \text{A/m}^2\) | 9.3–14.9 MPa |
| \(0.406\ \text{A/m}^2\) | 9.6–15.4 MPa |
| \(0.541\ \text{A/m}^2\) | 9.8–15.6 MPa |
| \(0.744\ \text{A/m}^2\) | 9.9–15.8 MPa |
The results show that as the current density decreases, the trade-off optimal pressure window shifts toward lower pressure, but the numerical change of the window is small, and all windows are in the medium pressure range. Therefore, the pressure window obtained in the original scheme has a certain stability.
After confirming that the obtained pressure interval has a certain robustness to operating conditions and evaluation settings, and examining its sensitivity to the evaluation method and the considered current density, it is also necessary to further examine its engineering load implications for large-area cells. For a large-area pouch solid state battery with an effective area of \(120\ \text{mm} \times 80\ \text{mm}\), the total preload force corresponding to the trade-off optimal pressure window of 10.0–15.8 MPa is 96.0–151.7 kN according to \(F = pA\), and the balanced scheme of 12.2 MPa corresponds to 117.1 kN. This pressure interval falls within the clamping pressure range of 10–30 MPa reported in previous work. When the end plate and clamping mechanism are properly designed, the cell can have good pressure uniformity. However, the preload force interval of hundreds of kilonewtons does place high demands on end plate strength and connector load capacity. I have not yet established a module structure or performed maximum equivalent stress and yield safety factor checks. Therefore, the obtained pressure interval should be understood as a trade-off result under the material parameters, ideal layered structure, and evaluation preferences of this work. Its application to automotive cells or modules still requires further design and verification considering the specific cell area and constraint structure.
In summary, the reasonable pressure of a solid state battery lies in the medium pressure range where performance benefit and mechanical cost are balanced. The initial selection and regulation of axial pressure should avoid pursuing high pressure solely for electrochemical performance improvement. It should comprehensively consider interfacial contact recovery, electrochemical performance improvement, maximum interfacial stress difference, and pressurization cost. Based on the above optimization results and sensitivity analysis, the trade-off optimal axial pressure window under the material system parameters of this work is 10.0–15.8 MPa, with a trade-off optimal pressure of 12.2 MPa under the balanced scheme.
4. Conclusions
I have addressed the axial pressure regulation requirements of a solid state battery by taking an ideal layered unit as the research object, establishing a coupled electrochemical–mechanical model that considers axial pressure and interfacial contact states, introducing the interfacial stress difference as a mechanical evaluation quantity, and constructing a comprehensive loss function to optimize the axial pressure window. The main conclusions are as follows.
1) In terms of electrochemical response, axial pressure can improve the electrochemical performance of a solid state battery by improving the electrode/SPE interfacial contact state, but the benefit has a marginal diminishing characteristic. At low pressure, the effective interfacial reaction area is limited, interfacial charge transfer polarization increases, and the terminal voltage and capacity utilization decrease. As pressure increases, interfacial contact improves, the overpotential contribution decreases, and the cell terminal voltage and capacity output improve. In the medium- and high-pressure ranges, the contact factor gradually approaches saturation, and the reductions in overpotential and increases in capacity diminish significantly. This indicates that an appropriate axial pressure is a necessary condition for maintaining effective solid–solid interfacial contact, but further pressurization beyond a reasonable range cannot significantly improve electrochemical performance.
2) In terms of mechanical response, axial pressure affects the in-layer stress level, enhances the interfacial stress difference, and changes the thickness variation response. First, the change in the in-layer stress level by axial pressure is mainly achieved indirectly by affecting the electrochemical reaction. Second, as pressure increases, the maximum interfacial stress differences at the positive/SPE and negative/SPE interfaces increase overall, with the positive/SPE interface showing a higher stress difference. This indicates that high pressure enhances the mechanical response difference between the two sides of the interface. Finally, the maximum thickness change \(H\) increases noticeably in the low-pressure range, but its absolute magnitude is small and gradually flattens in the high-pressure range. This indicates that the overall thickness change is not the main factor limiting further pressurization, and the interfacial stress difference better reflects the mechanical constraint under high pressure.
3) By optimizing the usable areal capacity, interfacial contact state, interfacial stress difference, and pressurization cost, the trade-off optimal axial pressure window under the material system parameters, ideal layered structure, and isothermal conditions of this work is 10.0–15.8 MPa, with a trade-off optimal pressure of 12.2 MPa under the balanced scheme. This pressure range can maintain good capacity output and interfacial contact state while reducing the further accumulation of interfacial stress difference and pressurization cost, reflecting the balance between electrochemical performance improvement and interfacial mechanical risk control.
In this work, I obtained the coupling law between axial pressure and interfacial contact state at the ideal thin-film layered unit scale, but the resulting pressure window is only applicable to the current material system parameters and ideal layered structure. Although the areal capacity of a single solid state thin-film battery unit is limited, previous studies have shown that multilayer thin-film unit integration has the potential to balance energy and power and is feasible for further packaging and manufacturing scale-up, providing a potential structural path for extending such batteries to automotive high-energy and high-power applications. The modeling and analysis method in this work can provide a reference for pressure regulation and interfacial reliability analysis of multilayer-integrated solid state battery cells for automotive applications. Future research can further address real rough interfaces, consider interfacial damage evolution, debonding, and local contact failure mechanisms, and establish more physically meaningful mechanical constraints combined with interfacial strength, fracture energy, and allowable stress thresholds. At the same time, module engineering constraints such as end-plate stiffness, structural mass, and pressure uniformity can be included in the evaluation, temperature effects can be introduced, and the performance and safety risks under high-rate, overcharge, overdischarge, and abnormal pressure conditions can be analyzed. In addition, the interfacial mechanical response can be further quantitatively verified experimentally, and the axial pressure window of cells or modules under different material systems and pressure constraint conditions can be verified and corrected.
